Reaper, Marshmallon, or Fool

[Tabris]

Reaper > Marsh > Fool

[CrabHelmet]

I don't know about you guys, but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

[HORUS]

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

[EHERO Andrew]

Marshmallon>Fool>Reaper

 

Marshmallon beats all. I mean, he inflicts 1000 damage right off the bat.

[Phantom Roxas]

Reaper > Marsh> Fool

 

Anyone who says otherwise is retarded

 

Q4E&T

[HORUS]

Marshmallon>Fool>Reaper

 

Marshmallon beats all. I mean' date=' he inflicts 1000 damage right off the bat.

[/quote']

 

[Discarding cards from your opponent's hand + easy Special Summoning with Zombie Master, Il Blud, Pyramid Turtle, Book of Life, Mezuki, Monster Reborn + easy access with Goblin Zombie + Dark Attribute] > 1000 Damage

[CrabHelmet]

' pid='1025992' dateline='1219722927']

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

 

Yes.

[Tickle Me Emo]

Reaper>>>>>Marsh>>>>>Fool

[Guest PikaPerson01]

' pid='1025992' dateline='1219722927']

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

 

Yes.

 

Lol wut no. Book flips it facedown.

[CrabHelmet]

' pid='1025992' dateline='1219722927']

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

 

Yes.

 

Lol wut no. Book flips it facedown.

 

Blast, I forgot Reaper's effect isn't Continuous, so it doesn't interrupt chains. >_< IGNORE ME.

[Tickle Me Emo]

' pid='1025992' dateline='1219722927']

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

 

Yes.

 

Lol wut no. Book flips it facedown.

 

Blast, I forgot Reaper's effect isn't Continuous, so it doesn't interrupt chains. >_< IGNORE ME.

 

Can you explain how this works?

[Phantom Roxas]

' pid='1025992' dateline='1219722927']

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

 

Yes.

 

Lol wut no. Book flips it facedown.

 

Blast, I forgot Reaper's effect isn't Continuous, so it doesn't interrupt chains. >_< IGNORE ME.

 

Can you explain how this works?

 

Somehow, PikaPerson01 believes that Book actually flips SR face-down, even though it's targetting it, and would thus destroy it. Crab Helmet somehow managed to make a mistake without the world imploding and agrees with PikaPerson01.

[Tickle Me Emo]

' pid='1025992' dateline='1219722927']

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

 

Yes.

 

Lol wut no. Book flips it facedown.

 

Blast, I forgot Reaper's effect isn't Continuous, so it doesn't interrupt chains. >_< IGNORE ME.

 

Can you explain how this works?

 

Somehow, PikaPerson01 believes that Book actually flips SR face-down, even though it's targetting it, and would thus destroy it. Crab Helmet somehow managed to make a mistake without the world imploding and agrees with PikaPerson01.

 

So.... you book a reaper it dies?

[Phantom Roxas]

' pid='1025992' dateline='1219722927']

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

 

Yes.

 

Lol wut no. Book flips it facedown.

 

Blast, I forgot Reaper's effect isn't Continuous, so it doesn't interrupt chains. >_< IGNORE ME.

 

Can you explain how this works?

 

Somehow, PikaPerson01 believes that Book actually flips SR face-down, even though it's targetting it, and would thus destroy it. Crab Helmet somehow managed to make a mistake without the world imploding and agrees with PikaPerson01.

 

So.... you book a reaper it dies?

 

Wait, just checked the Rulings, Pika was right.

[Guest PikaPerson01]

"Spirit Reaper" is only destroyed by its own effect if it is face-up on the field when the effect designating it as a target activates' date=' AND after the effect designating it as a target resolves. If you Special Summon "Spirit Reaper" with Monster Reborn, or flip it face-down with "Book of Moon", or flip it face-up with "Book of Taiyou", it is not destroyed.[/quote']

 

Source: http://entertainment.upperdeck.com/yugioh/en/gameplay/faqs/cardfaqs/default.aspx?first=S&last=T

[Tickle Me Emo]

' pid='1025992' dateline='1219722927']

I don't know about you guys' date=' but I'd like to have my wall self-destruct when my opponent Brain Controls it.

 

And what other non-destruction effects that target might you encounter? Shrink and E-Con are the only two that instantly spring to mind.

 

Also, DARK Zombie > LIGHT Fairy.

 

' pid='1025950' dateline='1219721773']

* Damage Effect is re-usable with Book of Moon

 

Short of exceptional circumstances - i.e. the opponent just got out Zanji, or the opponent is mentally retarded - I wouldn't call the damage effect "re-usable".

 

True. I just know Marshmallon is run in Monarch decks that use Book of Moon.

 

 

By the way, does Book of Moon destroy Spirit Reaper?

 

Yes.

 

Lol wut no. Book flips it facedown.

 

Blast, I forgot Reaper's effect isn't Continuous, so it doesn't interrupt chains. >_< IGNORE ME.

 

Can you explain how this works?

 

Somehow, PikaPerson01 believes that Book actually flips SR face-down, even though it's targetting it, and would thus destroy it. Crab Helmet somehow managed to make a mistake without the world imploding and agrees with PikaPerson01.

 

So.... you book a reaper it dies?

 

Wait, just checked the Rulings, Pika was right.

 

I dont understand why though, since the Reapers effect says that if its targeted then its destroyed, unless it needs the effect to resolve first before reaper can activate...?

 

 

 

EDIT!!!!!!

 

Pika posted as to why as I was posting this.

[Sixty]

Reaper > Marsh > Fool

 

I personally like Marshy a bit more, but Reaper is still better.

 

Spirit Reaper:

PROS: Makes opponent discard, allureable, zombie, can't be destroyed in battle.

CONS: Destroyed if targeted.

 

Marshmallon:

PROS: Can't be destroyed in battle, inflicts 1000 if attacked while face-down.

CONS: Almost always in defense, easily destroyed by Sheild Crush; Smashing Ground; Fissure; etc.

 

The Fool:

PROS: If tails, can't be targeted by opponent.

CONS: 50/50 effect.

[JesusofChaos™]

Blast missed the rulings discussion, reaper needs to be face up on the field after the card that has finished targetting it has finished resolving to destroy itself

[Gravitize Me Cap'n!]

Awesome, Reaper vs Marshmallon. Well it's a good thing the world keeps spinning while I'm gone.

[uzumakinaruto93]

Reaper > Marsh> Fool

 

Anyone who says otherwise is retarded

[Wyhe]

Marshmallon is the most resistant one of them all

[An Idiot]

i say run all of them

 

btw reaper>marsh>foo

[Exiro]

Reaper > Marsh> Fool

 

Anyone who says otherwise is retarded

 

Meh, I'd say Fool > Marshmallon, because it has some combos that wouldn't be possible with Marshmallon, like using Creature Swap on it. Also, when summoned by Nova Summoner, it might become unable to be targeted.

 

However, it's clear that Reaper is better than both others.

[Skuldur]

Reaper > Marsh> Fool

 

Anyone who says otherwise is retarded

[{Verifying...}]

Marshmelon (Because of +1000dmg to opponent) Spirit Reaper, Fool... but Fool IS HORRID