1 vs 1 (Galesonic vs. Gir: Ruler of Tacoz)(Constructive Criticism Needed)

[galesonic]

Another 1-on-1 contest. This match: Galesonic vs Gir: Ruler of Tacoz

 

 

Rules: both players are to make 2 monster cards with a field spell supporting the cards.

 

reward to both players: +3 reps to the winner and +1 rep to the loser (for trying)

 

End date to vote: Sunday April 12, 2009

 

 

[spoiler= Gir: Ruler of Tacoz's cards]

Lore:

This card cannot be Special Summoned. This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set except by Tributing 3 Beast-Type monsters. The ATK of this card is equal to the combined Levels of the Tributed monsters x 400. Once per turn you can pay 500 Life Points to Special Summon 1 Hound Token(Machine-Type/EARTH/Level 4/ATK 1500/DEF 500) on your side of the Field.

 

Lore:

When this card is Summoned, add one "Eight Gentle Judge Sanctuaty - Neo Acadia" to your hand from your Deck or Graveyard, if "Eight Gentle Judge Sanctuaty - Neo Acadia" is played the turn this effect is activated, add 2 Judge Counters to it.

 

 

 

 

[spoiler= Galesonic's cards]

If this card is Tribute Summoned by removing 2 Soul Counters from "River of Souls", the original ATK of this card becomes 2800. During your opponent's Battle Phase, you can change the position of 1 monster your opponent controls. If this card is destroyed, add 1 Soul Counter to "River of Souls".

 

If this card is Tribute Summoned by removing 2 Soul Counters from "River of Souls", the original ATK of this card becomes 2800. If this card is the only LIGHT Warrior-Type monster you control, this card cannot be selected as an attack target. If this card is destroyed, add 2 Soul Counters to "River of Souls".

 

For each monster destroyed by battle as long as you control this face-up card, place 1 Soul Counter on this card (Max. 12). you and your opponent can remove up to 3 Soul Counters to Tribute Summon a monster. The ATK of the monster is halved and the DEF becomes 0. You can remove 12 Soul Counters to Special Summon "Soul Dragon" from your hand, Deck, or Graveyard. The ATK and DEF of the "Soul Dragon" becomes 1000 and the effect is negated.

 

 

[.Requiem]

lol >_> unsuspected challenge. Who challenged who?

 

Gale wins effects are better also both of you have OCG errors. Gale's set revolve more around that river card. They seem a little OP. Gir's first card is random as it does nothing with the field card. Both sets seem OP, but gale is less.

[galesonic]

thanks for the vote. And Gir challenged me.

[.Requiem]

Gir wanted a fair challenge I see. >_> he was right, well I want to see more cards.

[galesonic]

We'll probably have more 1 on 1 contests later. And the 'Soul' monsters are unique in their case.

 

Socre so far: Galesonic: 2 Gir: Ruler of Tacoz: 0

[.Requiem]

lol >_> I didn't even used the polls. Soul monster can become more unique if you expand the idea.

[galesonic]

Well its my first generation so..yeah. I'll keep making them because this is basically the only set that I like.

[.Requiem]

Well that is fine >_> lol I get bored on a set and I work on a new one. Also I am looking for OCG, I will post it. This will take a while.

[galesonic]

Okay then. You can make some suggestions about the set as well if you want.

[.Requiem]

There is one part I don't understand. Is how can you tribute summon a monster with counters? Don't you mean special summon?

[galesonic]

Well, you remove the counters to summon the monster, but it will count as a normal summon.

[.Requiem]

Then it should say something like it is treated as a normal summon, but is a special summon. I don't know how to word it.

[mr.tacos]

I like galesonics better

[galesonic]

I didn't know how to word it either so i used Tribute Summon, since it is a Normal Summon.

 

@mr.tacos: Thank you for your vote.

[RickiMinaj]

Actually, i go to the point to see that Gir is more interesting while gale, ive seen those kinds of effects before

 

on top of that, Gir's images are waaaay better. Overall, i do choose gir just for the fact as it attracts me to her cards overall. ^^

 

Go Tacoz!

[galesonic]

Thanks for your comment and vote.

 

Score so far:

 

Galesonic: 4

Gir: Ruler of Tacoz: 2

[.Requiem]

lol >_> gir is a guy.

[Shocked]

galesonic's better...

Balance effect

[galesonic]

Thanks for the vote. Its a really close match.

 

Scores so far

 

Galesonic: 5

Gir: Ruler of Tacoz: 3

[BDR]

Well to me galesonic do have some ocg, but i think that that was the right way to put SOUL KNIGHT CRUSADER when it comes to summoning that card b/c the feild card provides the token, and he is trying to say if you want that first card effect you needs to have a card that produce tokens of that calibur which is the feild card. but he should have been more detailed and say you can remove soul counters to tribute summon soul monsters b/c that part had me lost but i still was able to catch on.