A memo about pop culture YCMing

[Guest Supreme Gamesmaster]

THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR MAKING A BAD CARD.

 

POP CULTURE CARDS SHOULD BE JUDGED BY THE SAME STANDARDS AS IF THEY WERE IN REALISTIC CARDS.

 

DO NOT CLAIM THAT PC CARDS DON'T HAVE TO BE PERFECT.

 

THEY DO.

 

EDIT: As people are misunderstanding the question, let me clarify: I don't expect perfection; rather, I want perfection as the standard. The objective in YCMing is to meet the standard; by using a perfect standard, one must always improve. That said, claiming that your card "doesn't have to be perfect" means that you're using an imperfect standard, and thus, don't have to improve to meet the standard.

 

On-topic:

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by sending 2 Spell or Trap Cards from your hand or field to the Graveyard. This card is unaffected by Spell Cards. Once per turn, you can select and activate 1 of the following effects: •Activate the effect of a Spell Card in your hand and send it to the Graveyard. •Send 1 monster from your Deck to the Graveyard to Special Summon 1 non-DARK monster from your Graveyard whose Level is lower than the Level of the sent monster. The Summoned monster cannot attack until the End Phase.

[.Requiem]

On topic =.= post the effect.

[Guest Supreme Gamesmaster]

Already done.

[.Requiem]

kk, well don't know what anime that is from >_>

 

But I do find uses for it. I think the last line kinda makes it OP, but that is just me.

[Guest Supreme Gamesmaster]

Slayers, what do you expect?

 

It would be OP'd, except DARKs are everywhere now. The only thing it really stops is JD.

 

Respond to the memo pl0x?

[Esplin 9466 Primary]

Its good,

But if your going for perfect, your not even close.

 

I can find 2 screw ups in your card.

[Umbra]

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card cannot be Special Summoned except by sending 2 Spell or Trap Cards in your hand or from your side of the field to the Graveyard. This card is unaffected by Spell Cards and non-DARK monsters. Once per turn, you can activate one of the following effects:

• Activate the effect of a Spell Card in your hand, and send it to the Graveyard.

• Send 1 Monster Card in your Deck to the Graveyard and Special Summon 1 non-DARK monster from your Graveyard whose Level is lower than the sent monster's. The Summoned monster cannot declare an attack during the turn you use this effect.

 

That's how I would write it. A list makes it easier to manage.

[Guest Supreme Gamesmaster]

Its good' date='

But if your going for perfect, your not even close.

 

I can find 2 screw ups in your card.

[/quote']

Name them.

 

Of course I'm going for perfect. The idea is, if one posts a card, one wishes that card to be perfect.

 

@Umbra: Many thanks. Reorganizing now.

[.Requiem]

Slayers' date=' what do you expect?

 

It would be OP'd, except DARKs are everywhere now. The only thing it really stops is JD.

 

Respond to the memo pl0x?

[/quote']

 

w/e this card can be very useful though.

 

The memo -_- I put the same effort in my PC cards as I do in RC cards. Too many noobs disgrace both sections.

[RetroGamer379]

THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR MAKING A BAD CARD.

 

POP CULTURE CARDS SHOULD BE JUDGED BY THE SAME STANDARDS AS IF THEY WERE IN REALISTIC CARDS.

 

DO NOT CLAIM THAT PC CARDS DON'T HAVE TO BE PERFECT.

 

THEY DO.

 

That sounds kinda ominous...

 

No offence, seriously.

 

Back on topic...

Practice what you preach.

That card ain't perfect. That pic is like, bad.

9.2/10

 

Otherwise very nice card, but it ain't perfect.

 

(Oh, and NOTHING is perfect. Except God.)

[Guest Supreme Gamesmaster]

THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR MAKING A BAD CARD.

 

POP CULTURE CARDS SHOULD BE JUDGED BY THE SAME STANDARDS AS IF THEY WERE IN REALISTIC CARDS.

 

DO NOT CLAIM THAT PC CARDS DON'T HAVE TO BE PERFECT.

 

THEY DO.

 

That sounds kinda ominous...

 

No offence' date=' seriously.

 

Back on topic...

Practice what you preach.

That card ain't perfect. That pic is like, bad.

9.2/10

 

Otherwise very nice card, but it ain't perfect.

 

(Oh, and NOTHING is perfect. Except God.)

[/quote']

It does, doesn't it? I'm just fed up.

 

The pic doesn't matter. ^_^

 

Since when were Gods perfect? Kazuki Takahashi is perfect at YCMing, though.

 

Perfection is the ultimate goal because of its impossibility. I wasn't saying 'every card has to be perfect', I was saying 'PC cards aren't exempt from criticism because they're in PC; they should be treated like realistic cards'.

[Esplin 9466 Primary]

I wasn't saying 'every card has to be perfect'' date=' I was saying 'PC cards aren't exempt from criticism because they're in PC; they should be treated like realistic cards'.

[/quote']actually i think PC should be held to higher standard's because there are people that put effect's that have nothing to do with the anime your basing it off.

 

But i still disagree with how you expect perfection out of everybody.

[Umbra]

PC and RC are both CC. Same thing could be said about AOC, but I won't speak further on that subject. The classifications and categorizations of CC is not one of my favorite subjects, so I'll stick in my WC.

[Esplin 9466 Primary]

PC and RC are both CC. Same thing could be said about AOC' date=' but I won't speak further on that subject. The classifications and categorizations of CC is not one of my favorite subjects, so I'll stick in my [b']WC[/b].

what?

[Guest Supreme Gamesmaster]

I wasn't saying 'every card has to be perfect'' date=' I was saying 'PC cards aren't exempt from criticism because they're in PC; they should be treated like realistic cards'.

[/quote']actually i think PC should be held to higher standard's because there are people that put effect's that have nothing to do with the anime your basing it off.

 

But i still disagree with how you expect perfection out of everybody.

I don't expect perfection; rather, I want perfection as the standard. The objective in YCMing is to meet the standard; by using a perfect standard, one must always improve. That said, claiming that your card "doesn't have to be perfect" means that you're using an imperfect standard, and thus, don't have to improve to meet the standard.

[Umbra]

PC and RC are both CC. Same thing could be said about AOC' date=' but I won't speak further on that subject. The classifications and categorizations of CC is not one of my favorite subjects, so I'll stick in my [b']WC[/b].

what?

 

I advise you to take a look at our other CC sections.