[Ø] Random Xing vs. DeMeNTeD - Over[LOCK] [Ø]

[╬「Selatcia」╬]

[spoiler=[b]Rules for voters[/b]]

-No simple votes. (Ex: Person 1 > Person 2; Person 1 gets my vote) Please put some detail into your votes.

 

-No biased votes. (Ex: Person 1 because I hate Person 2)

 

-Not following the above rules = vote not counting.

 

-All other YCM rules apply here.

 

 

 

End Date: Sunday, or whoever can get 10 votes first.

 

Prize: 3 +reps to the winner.

_________________________________________

 

[spoiler=[b]Random Xing[/b]]

Lore: 1 Tuner monster + 1 or more non-Tuner Machine-Type monsters

When this card is Synchro Summoned, inflict 100 damage to your opponent. During your Standby Phase, you can discard 1 card to destroy 1 Spell or Trap Card on the field. Once per turn, during your Main Phase 1, you can pay 500 Life Points to draw 1 card. If the drawn card is a WIND monster, inflict 300 damage to your opponent. During your Battle Phase, you can pay Life Points in multiples of 100 (max. 300) to have this card gain that much ATK until the End Phase. During each of your End Phases, flip all Set monsters you control face-up. When this card is destroyed by battle, destroy all Spell and Trap Cards on the field.

 

Cred: http://fc01.deviantart.com/fs16/i/2007/219/4/5/Mecha_Dragon___Color_by_LancerAdvanced.jpg

 

[spoiler=[b]DeMeNTeD[/b]]

 

Effect:

This card is also treated as a DARK Fiend-Type monster. Each time your opponent Summons a monster, place 1 Mist Counter on it (max. 5). Monsters gain 200 DEF for each Mist Counter on them. Once per turn, during your opponent's Battle Phase, you can pay 500 Life Points to place 1 Mist Counter on a monster your opponent controls. If a monster attacks with 1 or more Mist Counters on it, the controller of the targeted monster can change the attack target to another monster on his/her field. The controller of the targeted monster can use this effect as many times per turn as the number of Mist Counters on the 1st attacking monster. If a monster is destroyed by battle or removed from the field by a card effect you control, remove all Mist Counters from it. If this card is removed from the field, remove all Mist Counters from the field.

 

Pic Credit: http://fc00.deviantart.com/fs16/f/2007/137/9/8/DM001_by_Kaizy.jpg

 

[.Impact]

i dont kno demented ur ocg on that one seems a little too iffy for me its good but not nearly as good as ur other so by barely anything at all random xing wins my vote

[Rook Bishop]

Random Xing: Like the effect but no good if you have low Life Points.

DeMeNTeD: Like the pic, really like the pic, but can't quite understand the effect.

 

........This may take awhile

[.Impact]

yea bit random xing is meant for an early play to get a quick advantage

[Azmodius]

There both good. But I like DeMeNTeD's better just by a tiny bit.

 

Demented - Awsome pic and holo, sort of confusing effect. But still clever and a good pic

 

Random Xing - Meh pic, the effect is realy good though.

 

Both are great, but DeMeNTeD gets my vote by a bit.

[.Impact]

seems fair enough

[§hadow §triker]

Better pic: Demented

Effect: Tough decision so both

OCG: DeMeNtEd

Balance: Both I guess

Demented get my vote

[Monkey]

Random Xing:

 

Image: Not so Yu-Gi-Oh-like and looks too sketchy

Name: Matches the image sort of, but is a little long. What is with "Cyborg -"?

OCG: Seems a little iffy towards the end but overall, pretty solid

Balance: A little OP'ed because of all the effects that it can use

 

DeMeNTeD:

 

Image: Awesome, the holo really brings out the monster in the image

Name: Matches the image because it gives a sense of destruction

OCG: Seems pretty solid to me :)

Balance: Seems balanced, giving that it requires 2 tributes but yet still it has low ATK and DEF. The effect makes up for this disadvantage.

 

Why EARTH and Rock-Type on the card? It looks seems weird

 

OVERALL:

 

DeMeNTED gets my vote

[Cocodomoco]

my vote goes to demented because i like his card pic better, boths ocg are great, but i like dementeds cards effect better.

[╬「Selatcia」╬]

i dont kno demented ur ocg on that one seems a little too iffy for me its good but not nearly as good as ur other so by barely anything at all random xing wins my vote

 

If you have a better way of wording my effect' date=' please say so. ^_^

 

[b']@ Primal Release:[/b] IMO, the image looked like a combination of a DARK-EARTH Rock-Fiend-Type monster, so I made it be treated as both types & attributes.

 

Also the DEF is higher than the ATK, which might be another reason it's partially EARTH Rock-Type.

[.Requiem]

Both cards are over doing it with some random or unneeded effects -_-'

 

I feel the first card is OP, what 500 LP to draw a card that is cheap. I hardly doubt you will have a lot of set monsters. Also cheap way of nuking the field of spell and trap cards.

 

First is overdoing it, but that is just demented for you. I am a little confused, when your opponent summons a monster you place a mist token on it and the monste gains 200 ATK. So if the opponents monster has a counter on it, then it attacks and the targeted monster can be switched correct? Also is the next line necessary, doesn't a monster when destroyed lose all the counters anyway?

 

Well that is all I have to say, I say demented wins my vote.

[Xing]

I know DeMeNTeD will win.

Oh well. At least I have 1 vote.

[╬「Selatcia」╬]

Keep the votes coming. ^_^

[Shocked]

Random Xing :

 

• Balance : 8/10

• Pic : 6/10

• Effect : 8/10

• OCG : 9/10

• Overall : 7.75/10

 

DeMeNTeD :

 

• Balance : 9/10

• Pic : 10/10

• Effect : 9.5/10

• OCG : 10/10

• Overall : 9.6/10

 

So, DeMeNTeD gets my vote

 

Both have a great card. Keep working for the both ^^

[.Impact]

srry thats wat i mean the effects seem uneeded and then they dont flow right ur cards still good though im not denying that

[¶nÇØGn¶TØ]

Hahahaha. Nothing biased but the card DMNT made reminds me of one of my favorite cards - "Patrician of Darkness". DMNT made a good Job of using counters. Although the counters made it a little confusing. Just a little. But.... DMNT made the card a little Under-powered by giving away 200 DEF per Mist Counter and paying Life Points to add them. Random Xing's card is also great and deserves all the respect. DMNT just hit the right spot.

 

 

DeMeNTed gets my vote.

[╬「Selatcia」╬]

I thought my card would be overpowered if the restrictions weren't put on it.