Jump to content

.:Dog-King:. vs Benny D ended. Winner Card B


Recommended Posts

Well

 

Dog King

 

PIC: 7.5 (Need a background)

OCG: 8.5 (Good OCG)

Effect: 8 (Little OP)

Overall: 24/30

 

Benny D

 

PIC: 9 (Nice pic but not a type of a yugioh)

OCG: 10 (I can't see errors XD)

Effect: 9 (Really nice)

Overall: 28/30

 

So my vote goes to Benny D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dog King's card:

Pic: 5.1/10 (has no background).

OCG: 7.9/10 (errors which DeMeNTeD corrected out already in this other contest).

Effect: 8.1/10

Creativity: 7.6/10

 

Overall: 28.7/40

 

(For Dog King's judgement I used exactly the same with pitski's 1on1 with Dog King cos it's exactly the same as the card Dog King posted for the 1on1 with pitski)

 

Benny D's card:

Pic: 8.6/10 (isn't that a PG picture?)

OCG: 8.1/10

Effect: 8.1/10

Creativity: 9.1/10

 

Overall: 33.9/10

 

Benny D has a better card because, better creativity and better pic and a tiny bit better OCG (e.g. defense position = Defense Position). Dog King has OCG errors but atleast only Grammar errors and very least OCG errors. Pic would've been much more better with a background.

Thus, my vote goes to Benny D.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Latest Tally,

Card A: 3

Card B: 4

 

Closing in 1 hour!!!! get your votes in!!!!


Contest Ended. Winner Card B. Thanks!

Dog King, kindly send the reps to Benny D.

Honestly, i preferred the second card that you posted Dog King. Well, you can always challenge someone again:)


Contest Ended. Winner Card B. Thanks!

Dog King, kindly send the reps to Benny D.

Honestly, i preferred the second card that you posted Dog King. Well, you can always challenge someone again.

 

This was a close match!

Card A: 3

Card B: 4

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...