Jump to content

DeMeNTeD rematch


Who better  

1 member has voted

  1. 1. Who better

    • DeMeNTed
      4
    • Angel
      0


Recommended Posts

If its a vanilla, you need to grade on:

 

Mainly the image and balance between ATK,DEF, and Level

Maybe the description but I don't know how to rate descriptions...

 

If its based on images, Goliard wins (but we need to wait for the entries)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This isn't even a real card match. Two of the most major parts of making a card aren't going to be used; which is OCG and balance. It's a biased match because the only reasons for votes will be " I vote for _____ because his card looks cooler"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

79521.jpg

 

Description:

He was a man that was abandoned as a toddler, digging through dumpsters and garbage cans. He did everything he could to stay alive, until he was founded by a top secret spy organization. The members of the organization knew he had potential. Knowing that very few knew of this organization, he was sent to many places, watching who he needs to watch. For many years, he did his job successfully, and to this day, nobody was able to recognize this man as a spy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Normal Cards rating.

 

1. Card Name: DeMeNTeD did a better job to name the card. -DeMeNTeD

Picture: Angel of Death's pic is like a symbol rather than a monster while DeMeNTed's has the blur/black area on the left side of the pic. It is a tie

2. Card Attribute: Both got it correct so it is a tie.

3. Card Type: DeMeNTeD has the correct monster type. -DeMeNTeD

4. Text/Spelling/Content: Spelling errors on Angel Of Death's card including "sacrifised". Should be sacrificed. Both have good ideas but Angel Of Death's text was more appealing even though it's short. -Angel Of Death

5. ATK/DEF Balance: Both seems balance enough. - It is a tie

6. Set ID: DeMeNTeD had it correct. the first 4 characters should be letters and the last 5 characters should begin with "EN" for english. -DeMeNTeD

7. Creator: It is a tie. Geesh! and i even have to add this^_^

 

 

Overall: DeMeNTeD gets my vote

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow Demented Always Seems To Amaze Me When I See His 1 on 1 Matches But I've Never Voted In One Until Now(Because Its A Contest Of Vanillas)

 

Name To Image: Demented's Name Matches The Image Very Well While Angel Of Death's Matches As Well Just Not As Well Imo. - DeMeNTeD

Image: As Pitski Said Angel Of Deaths Image Looks More Like A Symbol While I Think DeMeNTeD's Image Is Very Well Chosen And A Great Image. - DeMeNTeD

Atk/Def To Level Balance: Almost A Tie But I Think Angel Of Death's Should Be 1-2 Levels Higher Most Likely 1 If That. - DeMeNTeD

 

Clealy DeMeNTeD Gets My Vote

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...