Jump to content

My attempt to get into Scratch Works


Yondaime

Recommended Posts

[align=center]Well I have 3 new tags. I was hoping they would get me in, but idk. Here they are =P

 

[spoiler=Kaien Tag]

[spoiler=V.1]

Kaien3.png

 

 

[spoiler=V.2]

Kaien4.png

 

 

 

[spoiler=Cloud Tag]

[spoiler=V.1]

Cloud-5.png

 

 

[spoiler=V.2]

Cloud3.png

 

 

[spoiler=V.3]

Cloud2.png

 

 

[spoiler=V.4]

Cloud4.png

 

 

 

[spoiler=Neliel Tag]

Neliel.png

 

 

 

 

CnC

[/align]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That C4D on screen in the cloud one is horrible.

 

The first is way too simple. Effective' date=' a bit.

 

And there is no blending on the Neliel one.

 

 

Good luck all the same ^-^

[/quote']

 

I couldn't just leave it with cloud on the stock >.>

Yea, the first on was from a simple Psd.

I just followed the Psd =P

 

Thank you ^-^

 

Doesn't look so good though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That C4D on screen in the cloud one is horrible.

 

The first is way too simple. Effective' date=' a bit.

 

And there is no blending on the Neliel one.

 

 

Good luck all the same ^-^

[/quote']

 

I couldn't just leave it with cloud on the stock >.>

Yea, the first on was from a simple Psd.

I just followed the Psd =P

 

Thank you ^-^

 

Doesn't look so good though.

 

I'd happily vouch for you D: But I can't. Not enough authority

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Attempt some of my tutorials in the Tut section> I can a' date='lso gibe you the PSD's to help

[/quote']

 

That will help =D

 

These are pretty good for first time Yondaime. I think you already pasted me. :( We should GFX battle when I get a sig done I'm working on.

 

Sounds fun =D

Doesn't look like I'm getting in this time though D:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Poor attempt at getting in seeing as how there weren't any BJs being given

 

Anyways

Kaien:

Focal is low quality

Background is an empty blur

No lighting

The little specks are too numerous for this little amount of light

The blue c4d effects don't really add much and seem rather unnecessary

The blue glow around the color is too weak to be necessary and would mess up the lighting

Blending is meh

Can't really say anything about depth with this one

This style doesn't require flow

B&W version doesn't have enough contrast

 

Cloud:

Border is unnecessary, especially since it's already long and semi-narrow (lol)

C4ds bring about a chaos that kills flow

They cause overcontrasting where they meet with the lighter colors

C4ds don't really make sense in their addition, seem almost like space filler

Focal is kind of low quality

No lighting, depth, or much blending

V2 with the texture set to lighten or screen just kills it

 

Neliel:

Her outline is too strong to properly put herself in this vector setting

Scanlines don't work with this, also hurts blending

Green color is too vibrant to go with her

You have flow at the bottom, but then the upper half is just vector shapes to fill up space

Background is uninteresting and lacking in vector artistical direction

Text is lackluster and boring, seems too wide and pixelly

 

I've run out of things to critique :/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Poor attempt at getting in seeing as how there weren't any BJs being given

 

Anyways

Kaien:

Focal is low quality

Background is an empty blur

No lighting

The little specks are too numerous for this little amount of light

The blue c4d effects don't really add much and seem rather unnecessary

The blue glow around the color is too weak to be necessary and would mess up the lighting

Blending is meh

Can't really say anything about depth with this one

This style doesn't require flow

B&W version doesn't have enough contrast

 

Cloud:

Border is unnecessary' date=' especially since it's already long and semi-narrow (lol)

C4ds bring about a chaos that kills flow

They cause overcontrasting where they meet with the lighter colors

C4ds don't really make sense in their addition, seem almost like space filler

Focal is kind of low quality

No lighting, depth, or much blending

V2 with the texture set to lighten or screen just kills it

 

Neliel:

Her outline is too strong to properly put herself in this vector setting

Scanlines don't work with this, also hurts blending

Green color is too vibrant to go with her

You have flow at the bottom, but then the upper half is just vector shapes to fill up space

Background is uninteresting and lacking in vector artistical direction

Text is lackluster and boring, seems too wide and pixelly

 

I've run out of things to critique :/

[/quote']

 

BJ?

Kaien:

It's a stock, so I can't change it.

Not very good at adding lighting =P

I like the specks.

They weren't meant to add much.

I thought that looked good =P I thought there was no lighting.

I'll work on it.

 

Cloud:

I think the border looks great.

I couldn't leave it without C4ds.

W/e

They pretty much are =P

I don't think so.

It looks exactly the same when it's on normal.

 

Neliel:

I know =P

W/e

Really?

Lol, I know.

Ok =P

I didn't like it either.

 

I have no idea what scratch works is' date=' but nice pics.

[/quote']

 

It is a club here that I'm trying to get in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...