Jump to content

Killian, The Young Warrior of The Shadow


Captain C

Recommended Posts

Please stop putting "monster/spell/trap" thats bad ocg anyways ok pic though it doesnt fit the cards name.

 

also some improper wording and OCG errors. This card needs another effect this one is still dull.

 

6/10

 

(BTW: You need to start looking at the comments of you posted cards because it seems like you arent since you continue to make a lot of the same mistakes)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The pic is great, the effect is a little dull and the name fits the pic perfectly.

OCG needs work, here is an edit:

When this card is destroyed by a card effect, Special Summon 1 Level 4 or lower Warrior-Type monster from your hand or deck.

(the bold bit can be changed to Graveyard or wherever you want, I just put anything because you didn't specify where the monster would be summoned from).

 

Overall 6.5/10 nice try but effect could be a little more original though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please stop putting "monster/spell/trap" thats bad ocg anyways ok pic though it doesnt fit the cards name.

 

also some improper wording and OCG errors. This card needs another effect this one is still dull.

 

6/10

 

I will be more specific "Spell, Monster, Trap", the order doesnt matter. He is fighting something that matches the shadows, therefor it kinda messes with his name.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please stop putting "monster/spell/trap" thats bad ocg anyways ok pic though it doesnt fit the cards name.

 

also some improper wording and OCG errors. This card needs another effect this one is still dull.

 

6/10

 

(BTW: You need to start looking at the comments of you posted cards because it seems like you arent since you continue to make a lot of the same mistakes)

 

Please stop being so harsh on new members.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All those being evil and harsh give him a break. He's new so he wont know all the OCG fixs and may make mistaks. I still make mistakes.

We all made mistaks like him and people made fun of us, thats why you do it to them.

So give him a chance.

OCG is ok and pic is Fine.

i give it a 9/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quite Dull, as its been pointed out there is OCG (Original Card Grammar) errors. Also id make it a 6 star for having 2100/2100 and an effect. Its decent for a start, but you really should work on more intresting effects. Normally try not to post cards with bland effects alone, rather try to make a set that has a common theme, this makes bland effects a bit more acceptable (I mean having a few bland effects, not all bland)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Again, I am not being harsh. I have not scolded him on his OCG I merely advised him to check his comments to see how he can fix his repeated OCG errors. And yes we all make mistakes I merely tell him the mistakes. If I dont say it is a Lovey Dovey tone that doesnt mean im being harsh. And please do not give them pity rates. Giving them real honest rates are what they need to get them to realize their mistakes. If you have 9/10 up there meaning he has 1 mistake away from 10/10 then ok ignore the above sentence but if you mean 9/10 is your highest rate then that isnt altogether a full honest rate. Also do not tell him his OCG is fine if it is not. If you do he will continue to make this mistake and be burned for it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...