Let's see how smart YCM is shall we?

[Guest]

 

Now there is a few main problems with this tag, the point of the thread is to see if any of you are actually skilled enough to point them out.

 

GO!

[-DG-]

No blending, or lighting. Flow is bad. too plain. colors don't mix. BG is too simple as it's just a c4d.

 

 

How'd I do?

[Guest]

1/12

[Skyfi]

No Lighting, Render is still, Flow does not exist, Looks like Copy Paste, Colors don't go together.

[Guest]

1/12

[/성成현賢/.led]

Bad Compo

No Blending

No Lighting

Bad Flow

LQ Render

Lighting in BG is wrong

[Guest]

1/12, you got a different one then the first two, kudos however I'm not suprised no one can get more then one

[+Jono]

No light source, strange lighting on C4Ds (looks like it's coming from different spots), Colour pallet from the render does not match that of the C4D, C4D is whored everywhere, No Flow, Depth is meh because of the render, Render does not blend, Apart from C4Ds it's just a black background, render looks like it's just randomly copy-pasted in, render contrasts too much because it belongs in a light sig whereas this is a dark sig, XxShadiusxX needs to spend his/her time doing something more productive than testing the IQ of people obviously more intelligent than him/her.

[Guest]

Sir you do realize that if i posted one of my real tags it would be better then most of what the idiots here could produce right?

 

Anyways 2/12 oh and learn your place before I actually slap you -_-

[Mister Sir]

Sir you do realize that if i posted one of my real tags it would be better then most of what the idiots here could produce right?

 

Anyways 2/12 oh and learn your place before I actually slap you -_-

 

E-slapping? lawl.

 

Not a lot of depth.

 

Yeah, I know I'm bad :P

[Adama.]

Shadius, if I may, it seems that insulting people's knowledge and intelligence will not get you good results, and putting people "in their place" is certainly not your right. It doesn't matter if you are better at graphic design than everyone on this site, for as long as you continue to flash it in their faces they will not respect you as much. You have more experience than most people here, and possibly more talent, but expecting them to know things they simply do not know, and insulting them for not knowing it, is not productive. Certainly, this could be an interesting exercise in good cnc, and you could help many people here with your criticism, but instead you simply act like everyone here is inferior, and as long as you do that, the only inferior one will be you.

~{Adama}

[Guest]

0/12, one more person can go before i edit in stuff

 

 

Edit: Adama you don't see the actual thing im trying to do here so i won't spoil the suprise... yet

[+Jono]

Sir you do realize that if i posted one of my real tags it would be better then most of what the idiots here could produce right?

 

Anyways 2/12 oh and learn your place before I actually slap you -_-

 

I was joking, cry me a river. Intelligence isn't determined by the skill level of your tag making. What makes you better than me? You can make better tags, congratulations. I don't give a sh*t. I don't have to learn my place, I already know what it is. Learn to take a joke.

 

 

OT:

2/12 =D

[LiAM]

Just looks like a render on a c4d.

 

Mistakes as pointed out above.

 

In fact, there's nothing else to point out.

 

How can there be 10 more things?

[♥ ЅϯᵲåώӀӞ℮ᴙʀɣ−ɴɨɨ−ƈħåɴ ♥]

He's simply trying to test your knowledge of REAL art conventions.

 

Rule of Thirds has been missed by a bit.

 

There is no movement or rhythm.

 

Heck, there's no balance, both symmetrically and asymmetrically.

 

There's more, but I'd just be copying off a list.

[Sparta™]

Sir you do realize that if i posted one of my real tags it would be better then most of what the idiots here could produce right?

 

Anyways 2/12 oh and learn your place before I actually slap you -_-

 

I was joking' date=' cry me a river. Intelligence isn't determined by the skill level of your tag making. What makes you better than me? You can make better tags, congratulations. I don't give a sh*t. I don't have to learn my place, I already know what it is. Learn to take a joke.

 

 

OT:

2/12 =D

[/quote']

 

 

 

On topic:

 

No light source, strange lighting on C4Ds (looks like it's coming from different spots), Colour pallet from the render does not match that of the C4D, C4D is whored everywhere, No Flow, Depth is meh because of the render, Render does not blend, Apart from C4Ds it's just a black background, render looks like it's just randomly copy-pasted in, render contrasts too much because it belongs in a light sig whereas this is a dark sig, XxShadiusxX needs to spend his/her time doing something more productive than testing the IQ of people obviously more intelligent than him/her.

 

To sum it up,

 

Bad Compo

No Blending

No Lighting

Bad Flow

LQ Render

Lighting in BG is wrong

 

(and yes, I just did teh copy paste)

[Maliki]

It has negative ground and it has no effort in it?

[Guest KAJN]

Not a good tag. The focal is LQ for starters. There are many lightnings, however, it seems that the render is left alone with it own lightning & not edited to achieve a lightning blend. Colours are terrible. The signature is so flat. The sig should be 3:1 plain, it is actually the opposite. Try to add some of your main ideas into it. I know it's just for cncing, though I'm just telling you.