Elements of Earth

[Vailan]

REMOVED EVERYTHING

[Zauls]

If they had effects.... Pics aren't brill.... They are really quite boring....

[Kitty]

lolnewbie =D

 

Tinypic.com or one of those

 

u can crop ur Images...

 

to get rid of the sigs and the border on ur spell..

 

Vanilla (normal Monsters) aren't really like but I think they're cool and all the lores are just about the same D= no fun...

but it won't hurt my judgement

 

meh 8/10 they're good but effect mosnter would rock..

[PANDORUM™]

Every pic here needs croping.

All the monster pics are overused.

Idea unoriginal.

Spell is a combination of Underpowered and Overpowered.

 

3/10

[Vailan]

@TheWorm:

The reason why I did not give them an effect, is because the other combinations (Ojama and People) also have no effects.

And what kind of effects should I give these cards? ;).

Boring, you say? Hm, well, I think they're cool 8).

 

And I'm a newbie, hey ;), so don't be too strict.

 

@Kitty princess:

Thanks for your judgement :). I still think that these monsters won't need an effect.

 

@Kieran Morris:

Well, another opinion has been added to this thread 8O.

It's a pity that you are not really fond of them :(

[Phanax Leminer]

Aiku: ... No. That's not a powerful combo.

 

OCG: Only last card OCG can be corrected.

-on your side of the field = control.

-Destroy all cards on your opponents side of the field, = Destroy all cards your opponent controls,

 

Effect: Even if you want to used the Spell Card, the combo isn't there at all. Why 5 stars when you can put 4? Why Normal Monsters, when you can create Effect Monsters? I don't have something against Normal Monsters, but I find them useless if you can't summon them like swarm.

Name and Image: Choose other pictures, they are blame and boring to look at.

 

Overall: 4.3/10

[PANDORUM™]

i'm not saying i don't like them actually now that i think about it carefuly, i forgot how much i like monsters bassed around elements.

 

well vanilla monsters don't need effects aslong as they have decent support and it's a good idea, been done befor but do them the right way and you could make the idea your own.

 

3/10->6/10

[Vailan]

@Phanax Leminer:

It isn't? The Ojamas etc are much much weaker than these fellows ;). And these cards can last much longer, so that is what makes them more powerful in my opinion.

5 stars makes it harder to summon them ;). And the pictures? To be honest, they were the best I could find ;). Of course, there are dozens of pics, but these are, in my opinion, the best.

 

@Kieran:

Never act, than think ;). It must be otherwise. Perhaps it's better that you first take a good look at the cards, before you place a comment ;).

Decent support? The cards are quite powerful (especially the Air Elemental). Give them some nice equip cards and they become even more powerful.

Cards like Jinzo (equipped with Amplefier) or Cold Wave can also help them ;).

[ragnarok1945]

boring pics, without effects they're too weak anyway

 

4/10

[.GhostRyder]

Look dude i also like elemental cards but with no effects there just bland and ugly. But if you insist i cant stop you but at least make support cards. But with effects they will be loads better.

[Vailan]

@Ragnarok:

What makes these pics boring? You are not the only one with that opinion :O.

Weak? There are much weaker cards without effects (such as Metal Fish, Gadget Soldier or Shapesnatch).

 

These pics were the best I could find, but If you have better pics, show them to me ;), I'm quite interested in what YOU see as a nice pic, instead of these 'boring' ones.

 

@Lonewolf:

What kind of effects would suit these cards? Giving some suggestions and ideas along with the rating is better than the rating alone ;).

If you have a good idea for an effect, please let me know ;)

[UltimaAku]

i cant believe people are putting this card down because it doesnt have an effect... i personally like the pictures, they suit its purpouse and are very inventative. If all monsters were supposed to haveeffects you may aswell throw curse of anubis and Justi-break out the window. i would put these cards in my elemental deck n an instant, very nice work. 10 / 10

[AbbatonStrikes]

I can see what your going for E-Heros kind of Im thinking. Maybe you could change the text to make em all read different, that the nice things about vanillas the interesting text under em...so go mad and make em sound wicked mate!! You should make a few more Spell/Trap card, or even effect monsters before you post too many normal cards as the higher level people get all pissy about it for some bizzare and strange reason!! Good start keep working on em, refine em and if you can some more intersting pics may help 7/10

[Vailan]

@UltimaAku:

I'm glad that somebody appreciates these cards :D. It is true that these cards are better off without effects. Like I said before, combination sets like 'Ojama Green, Black, Yellow' and 'People Running About, Oppressed People, United Resistance' also have no effects.

There is no reason why they should have them. By giving them supporting effects, it becomes easier to keep them on the field, which will make it easier to complete the combination.

 

And if one has the proper cards, these elementals can survive on the field :).

Would you like to see the Fusion Monster by the way? ;)

 

@AbbatonStrikes:

I think they allready sound quite wicked ;). And the same text under each card (almost the same, only the elemental names are different in the lore ofcourse), shows that they belong to each other.

If you take a look at the Ojama cards, you see that the lores are absolutely the same ;). If you take a look at the People cards, you see that their lores also match (but not as much as the Ojama trio) ;).

I have already created cards like that (check my introduction thread ;), there you can see an enumeration of my creations) ;). But I don't know wether I'm going to post them or not...

 

Thanks for your judgement :D