Jump to content

Ralph kept blowing until every boy on the island came.


Shrekstasy

Recommended Posts

Something about Golding's writing style feels odd to me, but it is definitely an excellent read.

 

Battle royal did it better.

 

Good joke.

 

Battle Royal couldn't get the kids to start killing each other without forcing them into an absurdly artificial situation where no other option was available - they were told to kill each other and handed weapons' date=' they were told that if they didn't kill each other quick enough then the people running the game would kill them off themselves, and they were told that the only way to escape alive was to be the last man standing. That the kids turned on each other in those conditions is utterly meaningless - of course they did! They were forced to! But that proves nothing about human nature - or, indeed, about anything at all. [i']Lord of the Flies[/i] simply has them on an island together, with nobody arming them or telling them to kill each other or killing them off or promising an escape to the last man standing; the events that occurred under those conditions have actual meaning.

 

tl;dr: Being Japanese and more bloody does not make Battle Royal superior.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...