Criticism

[Twig]

Title is self explanatory.

 

Discuss criticism in Card-Making, Showcase, Fan-fic, or in real life. How would you take criticism?

 

For me, as long as it's constructive, I won't get mad.

[~/Coolio Prime\~]

I like criticism with no constructive elements incorporated in it.

[deathghost101]

I don't care much about criticism. Constructive criticism, I'll learn from..........anything else can die, like everyone I hate should.

[Black★Star]

Is this contructive ?

This Thread is dumb, like you

 

Most of the time, i dont get mad...

[chairman ali]

In showcase people need to grow some balls and accept the fact that they're artworks are not perfect.

[Twig]

I like criticism with no constructive elements incorporated in it.

 

May I ask why?

 

 

 

I wish we had a lie detector to see who's lying.

 

Edit:

 

@Black Star: No.

[~ P O L A R I S ~]

In showcase people need to grow some balls and accept the fact that they're artworks are not perfect.

 

Define "perfection" and tell me why I can't label all artwork in Showcase "perfect".

[chairman ali]

In showcase people need to grow some balls and accept the fact that they're artworks are not perfect.

 

tell me why I can't label all artwork in Showcase "perfect".

 

I could careless about the first part because I'm too lazy to define it.

Why they can't be label perfect:

Most tags on YCM lack the basic fundamentals of Graphic design (Good colours, depth, flow, etc).

That's pretty much why they are not perfect.

[JadenxAtemYAOI]

In showcase people need to grow some balls and accept the fact that they're artworks are not perfect.

 

tell me why I can't label all artwork in Showcase "perfect".

 

I could careless about the first part because I'm too lazy to define it.

Why they can't be label perfect:

Most tags on YCM lack the basic fundamentals of Graphic design (Good colours' date=' depth, flow, etc).

That's pretty much why they are not perfect.

[/quote']

Not to forget that everyone has their own view of "perfect" I see a bright sunny for the beach as perfect but my bf will see a dark and rainy day as a perfect day.

[~ P O L A R I S ~]

In showcase people need to grow some balls and accept the fact that they're artworks are not perfect.

 

tell me why I can't label all artwork in Showcase "perfect".

 

I could careless about the first part because I'm too lazy to define it.

Why they can't be label perfect:

Most tags on YCM lack the basic fundamentals of Graphic design (Good colours' date=' depth, flow, etc).

That's pretty much why they are not perfect.

[/quote']

 

Maybe all the colours, depth flow, etc is too complex. Maybe simplicity is perfection. Or maybe all YCM artwork incorporates each in perfect harmony. JUST SADDAM HUSAYIN'.

[chairman ali]

Using two selective colours is now too complex? C'MON SON.

[~/Coolio Prime\~]

I like criticism with no constructive elements incorporated in it.

 

May I ask why?

 

Because constructive criticism helps an inferior being. Flat out insults amuse many.

 

Using two selective colours is now too complex? C'MON SON.

It's too much for me to take in at once.

[Quicksilver]

I don't care for criticism, period.

[Guest JoshIcy]

Using two selective colours is now too complex? C'MON SON.

It's too much for me to take in at once.

 

We better not get into why most Super Heroes outfits contain 3 colors, we don't wanna hurt someone.

 

Oh, and Criticism does not Equal insult. Otherwise, I leave and let die.

[Death Metal]

I don't care about criticism from other people, constructive or otherwise. I make my own criticism.

[Raylen]

I've taken some pretty harsh criticism, as far as writing goes.

 

This was from an editor from a professional agency:

This is one of those rare instance where I'm not going to suggest cutting the prologue. We can get along without it' date=' but it really gives us some insight into Reilen's character. There are two issues - 1) Publishers like things in Times New Roman 12. 2) The prologue allows us to feel absolute no sympathy for Reilen, and that's an issue right off the bat. You don't want to be behind before we even hit the plot.

[/quote']

 

She stopped writing to me after that.

[Βyakuya]

I'm usually nice to people, but when I rate and stuff, I'm really honest toward whatever it is.

[Catman25]

I believe criticism is a good tool for learning, but when it's as unnecessarily harsh as it sometimes is, it's hard to listen to.

[~/Coolio Prime\~]

Using two selective colours is now too complex? C'MON SON.

It's too much for me to take in at once.

 

We better not get into why most Super Heroes outfits contain 3 colors' date=' we don't wanna hurt someone.

[/quote']

Okay.

 

Oh, and Criticism does not Equal insult. Otherwise, I leave and let die.

If it wasn't used to indicate harsh overviews than there wouldn't be the term "constructive criticism", since a large majority is just assaults.

[Guest JoshIcy]

Oh' date=' and Criticism does not Equal insult. Otherwise, I leave and let die.

[/quote']

If it wasn't used to indicate harsh overviews than there wouldn't be the term "constructive criticism", since a large majority is just assaults.

 

Insults aren't used in Constructive Criticism. Stating the Bad isn't negative either, or well that depends on your tone. Like...

"That's just bad, remove it and start over".

 

However, a slight edit will make it constructive like...

"I do not like the results you have [insert specific area that needs improvement]. When you look it over, you might wanna do [suggested improvements]."

 

You retain the negative aspects while not being insulting. THAT is constructive criticism.

[Shrekstasy]

Nobody posts in my threads so I wouldn't know about it.

 

;D

[Gascan]

Nobody posts in my threads so I wouldn't know about it.

Amen.

 

In showcase people need to grow some balls and accept the fact that they're artworks are not perfect.

 

I would agree with this if it weren't for the fact that the only comments anyone posts in that forum is one or more of the phrases "Renders suck, colors are awful, whole thing fails, read sume tuts, scrap it and start over." No one actually criticises there, they just insult.

 

Criticism involves saying what you like and what you don't like, say what could be improved and how it could be improved - not just pointing out what you hate in two sentences and leaving at that. There's nothing useful or constructive about "Your renders suck."

[EHN.]

Eh, you need to work on how to make a good thread that can

...jk

 

Criticism is OK, I don't get annoyed..mostly.

[Pikachu]

I find it hard to accept most criticisms from my friends, because they either say 'it's cool' or 'that's gay'.

 

Usually I have to tell them the criticisms MYSELF.

[~/Coolio Prime\~]

Oh' date=' and Criticism does not Equal insult. Otherwise, I leave and let die.

[/quote']

If it wasn't used to indicate harsh overviews than there wouldn't be the term "constructive criticism", since a large majority is just assaults.

 

Insults aren't used in Constructive Criticism. Stating the Bad isn't negative either, or well that depends on your tone. Like...

"That's just bad, remove it and start over".

 

However, a slight edit will make it constructive like...

"I do not like the results you have [insert specific area that needs improvement]. When you look it over, you might wanna do [suggested improvements]."

 

You retain the negative aspects while not being insulting. THAT is constructive criticism.

Which is why I referred to regular criticism as the insulting one, since it typically us.