Commander Tim VS Demodude08

[Deustodo]

This 1 on 1 is part of the Machine Contest V, I'm just hosting the thread.

The first to get 3 votes win.

The task was to make a monster whose effect involve face-down monsters.

 

Commander Tim Card:

[spoiler=Card]

 

 

This card can't be normal summoned or set. This card can only be special summoned by removing from play a face down monster on your side of the field. This card's attribute is treated as the attribute of the tributed monster. By removing from play a monster in your graveyard increase this card's ATK by 300. As long as this card is face up on your side of the field lower your life points by 500 for each monster removed from play by this card's effect.

 

 

Demodude08 Card:

[spoiler=Card]

 

1 Rock Type monster + 2 Machine Type monsters

 

FLIP: Flip one face down card face up without activating it's effect. During your standby phase, you may flip this card face down. When this card attacks a face down monster card, it's flip effects are not activated. If this card is destroyed in battle, flip all face up cards face down, and all face down cards face up, without activating their flip effects.

 

 

[Deustodo]

bump;

[Spoon]

Vote goes to Commander Tim.

 

A well thought out card with strengths and drawbacks. The picture is nice, the name sucks (in a positive way) and I like the overall idea. Well done! Demodude's card is okay, I like the effect though it seems a bit overloaded just to fit the requirements in more than just one point. The picture is... meh, not very YGOish, and not very appealing overall.

 

So long,

 

Spoon