[LiAM] Aggrothor Lich

[LiAM]

[b][color="#800080"]Second thoughts... Limited? As it brings back Chaos food and generally gives a +1.[/color][/b]
[center][img]http://i56.tinypic.com/bfjce0.jpg[/img]
[color="#4B0082"]You can Special Summon this card from your hand by returning 5 of your removed from play
monsters to your Graveyard. While this card is face-up, all monsters in your Graveyard have
their Attributes treated as LIGHT and DARK. When this card is removed from play, select 1
of your removed from play monsters and add it to your hand.[/color][/center]

[Anbu-of-Sand]

[color=blue][b]Aggoroth Lich[/b][/color]

[b]OCG / Common Sense:[/b]
OCG is flawless. No errors whatsoever.

[b]Effect / Originality:[/b]
Yes. It does give Chaos monsters -cough- Chaos Sorcerer -cough- food. But, it also works with cards such as Dark Armed Dragon. Having monsters in your Graveyard treated as LIGHT / DARK also benefits monsters such as well, Chaos Sorcerer and Dark Armed Dragon. It's nice how when this card is removed from play, through an effect from the hand, the field, etc., you get a free monster that was removed from play back to your hand. Also, by the way you wrote it, you can select this as an option to return to your hand as well. It's also epic being a Level 3 Tuner.

[b]Usefulness / Balance:[/b]
I'd use it in my Chaos Decks. Works great in oh so many ways. It makes fodder and can be used as fodder with that little loop it has. Balance on the other hand, seems to make this OP'd. Seeing it's a Tuner with such an epic / big effect. I don't get why you didn't put Chaos in it's name though it seems fitting. On the other hand, you did mention about it being Limited, which I totally agree with. But just saying, maybe reduce the 5 to a 4? This will still make it OP'd, but 5 seems to be far to many.

[b]Ratings:[/b]
OCG / Common Sense: 2/2
Effect / Originality: 4/4
Usefulness / Balance: 3.7/4
[b]Overall: 9.7/10[/b]

[Buttercup]

Dimensional Alchemist is an unbroken version of this. D.D. can loop this card at 2 and free +1s for Summoning a Chaos Monster/ using Dark Creator's/ Dark Armed Dragon's effect aren't balanced. A Special Summon only restriction would be nice. I wouldn't like to see this at 1, 2 or 3.

4/10 OPD

[LiAM]

Thanks for the reply.

I'd rather keep it at 5 really, so you can't abuse it repeatedly,
as unless you have 10 removed monsters, it's useless XD

But no Chaos in its name so you can use it in other Decks, if it's useful.