TheTrinity Posted June 17, 2008 Author Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 Apparently, I'm even newbier than I thought, and I messed up that last topic. Here, let's try it again.Tell me what you guys think of these. All opinions welcome.Thanks,TheTrinity *disclaimer: I don't own the artwork to any of these cards. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TheTrinity Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 Apparently, I'm even newbier than I thought, and I messed up that last topic. Here, let's try it again.Tell me what you guys think of these. All opinions welcome.Thanks,TheTrinity *disclaimer: I don't own the artwork to any of these cards. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
N00B Hunter Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 "Thirsty Girl" and "Tiresome Fiend" are overpowered.. the rest are alright... I like the idea you have for your vanilla monster... maybe if you made two or three, and had "Uncertain Road" be able to tribute any of them (tribute, not remove from play... your cards aren't that important). BTW, it looks like your results of "Uncertain Road" are both females, so you can get rid of the "they" in your flavor text, and put "she" instead. "Thisty Girl" not only has high ATK power, but you get LP when you destroy certain cards. Not only that, but it comes back for 2000 LP. This makes it a good Aggro and Perfect Circle, too strong. "Tiresome Fiend" has can destroy 2 monsters, of any kind, with its 2 tokens. This means if your opponent attacks with anything, their monster is gone (aside from cards like "Exodia Necross", and "Vennominaga", which hardly get played anyway). Because of this, your opponent won't want to attack. So, while "Tiresome" is on the field, your opponetn won't attack. This makes the card stall and field control. Again, overpowered for such an easy summon. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
N00B Hunter Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 "Thirsty Girl" and "Tiresome Fiend" are overpowered.. the rest are alright... I like the idea you have for your vanilla monster... maybe if you made two or three, and had "Uncertain Road" be able to tribute any of them (tribute, not remove from play... your cards aren't that important). BTW, it looks like your results of "Uncertain Road" are both females, so you can get rid of the "they" in your flavor text, and put "she" instead. "Thisty Girl" not only has high ATK power, but you get LP when you destroy certain cards. Not only that, but it comes back for 2000 LP. This makes it a good Aggro and Perfect Circle, too strong. "Tiresome Fiend" has can destroy 2 monsters, of any kind, with its 2 tokens. This means if your opponent attacks with anything, their monster is gone (aside from cards like "Exodia Necross", and "Vennominaga", which hardly get played anyway). Because of this, your opponent won't want to attack. So, while "Tiresome" is on the field, your opponetn won't attack. This makes the card stall and field control. Again, overpowered for such an easy summon. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TheTrinity Posted June 17, 2008 Author Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 Thanks for your thoughts. First, to address the 'overpowered' cards. Thirsty Girl is in no way overpowered. Removed from play means just that. It doesn't mean destroyed, it means removed from play. i.e by the effect of Dimensional Prison, Chaos Magician, etc. So i see no reason why she is overpowered. (And who really runs that many Water/Aqua monsters unless they run that sort of deck?) As for Tiresome Fiend, again, not really that overpowered. It can easily be destroyed by any card effect, by it's own card effect (they can throw weak monsters its way to get rid of it), and once it's gone, it can't be re-summoned. I'd say Spirit Reaper is more broken. The idea behind Uncertain Road removing Let Me Be from play is that you can't abuse Generous Lady's effect. And does it really matter whether or not it says 'they' or 'she' in the flavor text? I personally like a little mystery. The point is you're not supposed to know until later. Again, thanks for your thoughts, but I'd pretty much anticipated those things already. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TheTrinity Posted June 17, 2008 Author Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 Thanks for your thoughts. First, to address the 'overpowered' cards. Thirsty Girl is in no way overpowered. Removed from play means just that. It doesn't mean destroyed, it means removed from play. i.e by the effect of Dimensional Prison, Chaos Magician, etc. So i see no reason why she is overpowered. (And who really runs that many Water/Aqua monsters unless they run that sort of deck?) As for Tiresome Fiend, again, not really that overpowered. It can easily be destroyed by any card effect, by it's own card effect (they can throw weak monsters its way to get rid of it), and once it's gone, it can't be re-summoned. I'd say Spirit Reaper is more broken. The idea behind Uncertain Road removing Let Me Be from play is that you can't abuse Generous Lady's effect. And does it really matter whether or not it says 'they' or 'she' in the flavor text? I personally like a little mystery. The point is you're not supposed to know until later. Again, thanks for your thoughts, but I'd pretty much anticipated those things already. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
N00B Hunter Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 Thirty Girl -- 2450 ATK for a single tribute is really good... one would think she's a normal monster... but she's not, and she has no downfall effects. If you play a WATER deck, Aqua and Fish-Types will definitely be in there with Sea Serpents and whatnot (the deck's pretty popular at Gameking right now...). I didn't see the RFP part of her effect, though, so I'll admit that she just gives you Life Points in some situations, can come back in some situations (thinking the monarch structure deck... Dimensional Fissure, Banisher of the Radiance, etc.), and has a load of ATK... without a downside effect (and the tribute requirement is not a downside effect, just a summong requirement which isn't enough) the card is still overpowered. Tiresome Fiend -- How many decks just have weak mosnters to throw away? None, if you're playing competitive dueling. You should also remember that you didn't specify what kind of counters are needed, and if there's a maximum (without those, any counters will work and there's no maximum amount of counters). So you could play a Spell Counter deck and just keep filling your card up with counters, an impenetrable defense. Alone, she fends off 2 monsters... and, yes, she's at a risk from S & T. However, her ATK and DEF are both low, so "Hammer Shot" won't work, while "Smashing Ground" might have a chance (if it's even in their deck), most decks don't pack "Fissure", and "Shield Crush" would be useless because you could place her in Attack Position because she doesn't fight in battle anyway... remember, "Alien Counters", "Spell Counters" any of those things work, so her effect can get out of hand easily. You do what you want about "Let Me Be". I just find that if the only results are female, then the beginning must be female (unless your lost child card change its organs...) You anticipated my argument? Then you should have been better prepared... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
N00B Hunter Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 Thirty Girl -- 2450 ATK for a single tribute is really good... one would think she's a normal monster... but she's not, and she has no downfall effects. If you play a WATER deck, Aqua and Fish-Types will definitely be in there with Sea Serpents and whatnot (the deck's pretty popular at Gameking right now...). I didn't see the RFP part of her effect, though, so I'll admit that she just gives you Life Points in some situations, can come back in some situations (thinking the monarch structure deck... Dimensional Fissure, Banisher of the Radiance, etc.), and has a load of ATK... without a downside effect (and the tribute requirement is not a downside effect, just a summong requirement which isn't enough) the card is still overpowered. Tiresome Fiend -- How many decks just have weak mosnters to throw away? None, if you're playing competitive dueling. You should also remember that you didn't specify what kind of counters are needed, and if there's a maximum (without those, any counters will work and there's no maximum amount of counters). So you could play a Spell Counter deck and just keep filling your card up with counters, an impenetrable defense. Alone, she fends off 2 monsters... and, yes, she's at a risk from S & T. However, her ATK and DEF are both low, so "Hammer Shot" won't work, while "Smashing Ground" might have a chance (if it's even in their deck), most decks don't pack "Fissure", and "Shield Crush" would be useless because you could place her in Attack Position because she doesn't fight in battle anyway... remember, "Alien Counters", "Spell Counters" any of those things work, so her effect can get out of hand easily. You do what you want about "Let Me Be". I just find that if the only results are female, then the beginning must be female (unless your lost child card change its organs...) You anticipated my argument? Then you should have been better prepared... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bahumut Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 there are slight ocg errors. and i dont see why you would trubute a monster to special summon a level 4 monster. i dont see the point but good effort. 8/10 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bahumut Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 there are slight ocg errors. and i dont see why you would trubute a monster to special summon a level 4 monster. i dont see the point but good effort. 8/10 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
╬「Selatcia」╬ Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 I like the pics. :) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
╬「Selatcia」╬ Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 I like the pics. :) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.