Nightmarian Posted March 16, 2009 Report Share Posted March 16, 2009 I was challenged, so here it is...we need to make any card.. Rules for voters: 1) You need to vote following template or your vote will not count.2) 3 voters total that will give best voting explanations and follow template obviously will get 1 REP each. Template : Picture /5OCG /5Balance /10Creativity /10Total /30 Person with bigger total ( which is picture+ocg+balance+creativity together) will get 1 vote. Maximum 1 vote can be get from 1 voter. Rewards : -loser will give 3 REPs to winner and loser will get 1 REP CARDS : -names of creators will not be known until end so u need to vote for card A or card B.... CARD A CREDIT : MTG CARD B CREDIT : Eniotna Good luck!!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lelouch_Vi_Britannia Posted March 16, 2009 Report Share Posted March 16, 2009 People keep this in mind Kirby is just ment to get out his other forms like Fire Kirby, Spark Kirby, Beam Kirby, etc. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
☨βlack☨ Posted March 16, 2009 Report Share Posted March 16, 2009 Card B gets my vote. [spoiler=Card A]5 / 5 ; I can't really say anything about this picture it's not a bad one and it goes with the Name. So I'll give you a perfect score on it. 2 / 5 ; I give this card this low of a score because I saw 3 OCG errors. One of which was very minor. In the "Yu-Gi-Oh! Trading Card Game" when putting an effect, you MUST put "his/her". In your effect it says, "2 cards in his deck". Making it a -1. In the same sentence, you forgot to put the word "the". Your sentence says, deck that have ____ same type. The blank space is where the word "the" should be placed. Right after that comes another missing "the". It says, "same Type as ___ Type. Once more, the blank spot is where the word "the" should be. 9 / 10 ; All and all, the effect seems pretty balanced. 0 / 10 ; I'm sorry to say this, but if you ask me.. ALL REAPER CARDS ARE UNCREATIVE! That's only my personal opinion because everyone tries making Reaper cards. So in MY opinion only, this gets a 0. After analysis, card A get's a 16 / 30! ---------------------------------------------------------[spoiler=Card B]5 / 5 ; I see nothing wrong with this picture either. It is obviously Kirby. O.o 4 / 5 ; I can't really explain why, this card just seems worded funny. OCG is correct, just the wording of it needs worked on. 7 / 10 ; The card seems a little Over Powered. But that is basically because you can absorb 2 monsters on the field. There is no limit to it. If the Kirby card is used for summoning the other Kirby's, then the card should use the card it absorbs attribute to special summon the attribute of the Kirby you wish to summon. 7 / 10 ; This is actually the first Kirby card I have seen. So I have to give you credit. Card B's score is 23 / 30! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rei_hunter Posted March 16, 2009 Report Share Posted March 16, 2009 Deck ReaperPicture 5/5 - Awesome. D: Spirit Reaper~OCG 4/5 - It's missing a 'the' o-o "have 'the' same Type"Balance 7/10 - Well it's pretty straight forward in what it does... though 2 cards... this and zombie mill would kill opponents almost instantly :oCreativity 7/10 - It's why Vampire Lord and Genesis are high levels. but since this guy has less attack... it's good.Total 23/30 KirbyPicture 4/5 - A better pic would work xD but it's good thoughOCG 4/5 - could be better worded.Balance 9/10 - till i see the 'forms' i guess the card itself is 'good'. Although, it's a bit underpowered for a standalone card....Creativity 5/10 - Yeah well, Kirby is trade-marked already... sadly... but tuning him into Yugioh is kinda neat.Overall 22/30 so it's Deck Reaper for points. although it's 'quite' broke.... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sonicwolf Posted March 16, 2009 Report Share Posted March 16, 2009 Card A:5/5 I think it is a very good picture...one of the best pictures of a grim reaper for a while. 3/5 good ocg just a couple of errors. 10/10 The effect is very well balanced...i personally think. 8/10 good creativity with the different picture of the grim reaper......the best picture of the grim reaper i have seen. 27/30 for an overall excellent Card B: 4/5 a good picture but i personally think it looks a bit like a toon. 5/5 very good ocg i reckon...not really much more to say. 8/10 a well balanced effect. But how can you equip a monster card to a monster card? 10/10 very good creativity, i have never seen a Kirby before. 25/30 for a great overall SO:Card A gets my vote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nightmarian Posted March 16, 2009 Author Report Share Posted March 16, 2009 Uh, sorry but u should delete that post...only cards posted in first post matters...there should be only 1 card for this contest, not whole collection, sorry...:) They are cool though... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Morgan LeFlay Posted March 17, 2009 Report Share Posted March 17, 2009 Card A (winner)Picture 5/5OCG 2/5 (I'm not gonna type them all out right now.)Balance 10/10Creativity 8/10Total 25/30 Picture 2.5/5OCG 5/5Balance 8/10Creativity 9/10Total 24.5/30 (This actually came up tied, so I took half a point for Kirby's picture since I didn't really like it.) By the way, it's obvious whose card is whose. >_> Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nightmarian Posted March 24, 2009 Author Report Share Posted March 24, 2009 3:1 for me <<...1 week passed..so i win...but, we really got low number of votes...:( Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.