[ JG WINS, LOCK]

[JG.]

[align=center]Yeah so bla bla, I lost the last match, so I wanted a rematch with my criteria. So we did. Here was the criteria:

 

Make a monster card, any level, but make the effect as unique as possible. As you may know, I'm a sore loser, (xD) so I picked my area of expertise xD

 

First to 5, 3 reps to winner. You must also provoide a good reason for your vote.

 

JG's Card

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by returning 5 of your opponents removed from play monsters to their Graveyard. Once per turn, during your Standby Phase, select 1 of your opponents removed from play monsters and return it to their Deck. If this card destroys a monster by battle, you can select 1 card in your opponents Deck and add it to your Graveyard. Pay 500 Life Points during each of your Standby Phases while your opponents monster is in your Graveyard. If you cannot, return the monster to your opponents hand. You can only have 1 of your opponents monsters in your Graveyard at a time.

 

Deustodo's Card

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by the effect of "Independent LV4". This card negate the effect of all Trap Cards on the field. This card gains 250 ATK for each Spellcaster-Type monster on the field (excluding this card). If this card's ATK is 2800 or higher, it cannot attack Life Points directly. On each of your Standby Phase, Special Summon 1 "Dependent" Token (Spellcaster-Type/EARTH/Level 2/ATK 0 /DEF 0) in Attack Position. If this card is the only monster that you control, you may remove from play this card and "Independent LV4" from you Graveyard to H.S. Summon to your side of the field "Independent LV13" in Attack Position.[/align]

[→мαthєus.]

I vote Deustodo for having better effect and being lvl Up card (i like this type of card ^^)

 

but what in the world is H.S.???

[JG.]

YCM doesn't rate OCG errors I see. But whatever.

 

0-1

[Blablafodfpå]

I vote for JG because of i think it's a more creative Idea and I like Dimansion monsters.

[JG.]

1-1

[DL]

woah... tough decision... JG has minor spelling errors (opponents is opponent's. 2 times), yet deustodo has some gramatical errors as well... I like both pics, and both effects are creative, but I like tokens, LVs, and claws, so vote goes to:

Deustodo. close match.

[~Wright~]

I think it's a cool idea to have an opponent's monster in your Graveyard. I don't quite understand the point of it though.

 

On the other hand, Independent's effect is cool as well, but I don't understand what an HS summon is, or how you can have a lv 13 monster.

 

so, my vote goes to JG.

[Sploda]

I vote Deustodo because the effect isn't as taxing and it doesn't slowly rebuild your opponent's deck.

[Caine Ghest]

Deus gets my vote, I personally like LV monsters and the effect could prove quite useful, as opposed to the rebuilding your opponent's deck effect of JG's card.

[JG.]

Alright, 2-4 this time. And this time it seems to be rather fair, although I do have my objections....

 

And also, may I point out, Deck-thinning is good (for oneself), so Deck-thickening (which is wahts happening is bad for your opponent.)

 

EDIT: And Darklink401, there is no apostrohe in "opponents", so I am right, you are wrong.

[JG.]

A few more votes, and this is over...

[Chaos Flame]

I vote JG, they both are really unique, have good pics, minor OCG errors, but I like Dimension monsters. Also the independent one says it summons a Lvl 13 monster. I have only seen one of those, and it was a japanese exodia with infinite attack and I'm not even sure it was real.

[Dark Mousy]

I'll take JG, slightly better pic, effects are about equal.

 

Deus, you need to PM me your card for round 1.

[hollowblade]

OMG, this is very hard. deustodo, I still am not sure what H.S. is, and minor OCG error. JG, effect is unique and balanced, but rebuilding your opponent's deck isn't something I'd like to do. So my vote...the deciding vote.

[spoiler=vote]JG. sorry deus, but I like the originality in JG's card.

 

[Lost Soul]

I vote for JG's card. It has an awesome effect, it is kind of hard to Summon unless you have a remove from play deck. Deustodo's Card doesnt just grab my interest, although it has a decent effect.

[DL]

so it's 6-4 in favor of JG, if I'm correct. So JG's the winner with 1 to spare.

[JG.]

EVERYBODY DO THE LIVERPOOL!!! Lol, when stuff like this happens, I always think of the Champions League 2005 Final. Anyways, good match bud ;D