Jump to content

Hockey Cards


Hockeygoalie1

Recommended Posts

It's a noob fest and Jolta.

 

They're very bad. Types make no sense, effects are dumb and do nothing, pics aren't too bad though.

 

My advice, make real effects and lower their stats. Make sure the types make sense and if they have a sub-type like 'Toon', make sure they have a Toon Monster's effect.

 

And waffleman123, it is AGAINST THE RULES to post your cards in another's thread (I should report you but I won't).

 

I'm not rating these for your sake.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It doesn't matter if people know about hockey or not. We're rating your cards as cards, not as people. They're much better now they are all vanillas and there are no stupid effects and subtypes, although there are still types that don't make sense. Here's your next tip, don't EVER make Divine monsters or in this case, Divine monsters. And please lower their stats!

 

I have to give you credit though, most noobs can't make spoilers or edit their posts, and you can do both. Edit your title now though, because you also have Joe DiMaggio.

 

Still not rating these yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Destron has a point, it doesn't really matter if we know about hockey or not, but you need to bring down your card's ATK and DEF before we can rate them seriously. I think you've made their Types like their position, but DO NOT make ANY Divine cards, so you need to change Jason Blake. And you might want to take out Joe DiMaggio, because this thread is called "Hockey cards" not "Baseball Cards". If you need hlep with anything about making cards, PM me and I'll try to explain it. Take our constructive criticizm and improve!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ummm this is original but Wayne Gretzhy wasn't a goal scorer he never fought. He was an assist monger but yeah Op'd a bit. P.S Gretzky was nothing ompared to Mario Lemeiux and Bobby Orr also Gordie Howe.

EDIT: Like dude you could never make a deck out of these cards just putting all these in is suicide. Toronto sucks. Also the goalie sucks that you put in make a variety of players from hockey teams. P.S.S Ken Dryden is the ultimate goalie. Also make the flavour text well more flavourful.

EDIT #2: 3/10.

EDIT #3: Wow that was retarded Sidney Crosby in a tootoo that card is a joke card. Also I don't see more team variety listen to team variety I don't see rangers, calgary, islanders, sharks, kings, boston, detroit well you get the point if you don't know any hockey teams I advise going to a hockey site. And no this is not advertising.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ummm this is original but Wayne Gretzhy wasn't a goal scorer he never fought. He was an assist monger but yeah Op'd a bit. P.S Gretzky was nothing ompared to Mario Lemeiux and Bobby Orr also Gordie Howe.

EDIT: Like dude you could never make a deck out of these cards just putting all these in is suicide. Toronto sucks. Also the goalie sucks that you put in make a variety of players from hockey teams. P.S.S Ken Dryden is the ultimate goalie. Also make the flavour text well more flavourful.\

EDIT #2: 3/10.

 

Sorry, so true. But still, just bring down ATK and DEF, make flavor text better, include more players from teams, and your Ok. Remeber I showed you how to update and post cards?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice idea going with Hockey. A few problems though that can be easily changed.

 

The types are all far too random and non-existent. I think it would help the cards and the realism if you made them "Warrior"s, a real type with support and group consistency to boot. Then the Attributes would work more if they were all EARTH. If you wanted though, you could make the one you have labeled as "DIVINE" a "FIRE" monster, to represent him being a star player, on fire, etcetera.

 

Then their stats are all overpowered by regular standards. Try lowering their ATK/DEF around the 2500 range, and their stars to 7 and 8. Then bring some monsters down to the Level 5 and 6 range, and decrease their stats to around 2200. And finally bring some of them to around level 4 and base their stats somewhere around 1500 and you're golden.

 

Finally, you should aim to give them all some relevant and useful effects. For example, an offensive player should have a destructive effect, while the goalie should have a defensive one. Players that work together on the field should help each other with their effects, and your star player should be special summoned by tributing some of the other players? See what I mean? Expand upon that!

 

As of now you have a 6/10 for the idea and the effort, let's see you work on the details now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...