Monster Reborn? Monster Reincarnation? NO!! It's Monster Rejuvenation!!

[WhoAreYou?]

Tribute 1 monster on your side of the field to activate this card. Special Summon 1 monster in your Graveyard except the Tributed monster in Attack Position.

[archie17]

I like it, its similar but different.

 

10/10

 

Can you send me the pic by the way?

[ragnarok1945]

Monster Reborn is still better, and maybe even Premature Burial as well

 

still, it's a nice card to have so I'll give this 9/10

[archie17]

You should add:

 

OCG Fix:

Tribute 1 monster you control to activate this card. Special Summon 1 monster in your Graveyard except the Tributed monster in face-up Attack or Defense Position.

 

Because that's really how Monster Reborn/Reincarnation work. They both give you a chose of what position you want your monster re-summoned.

[WhoAreYou?]

You should add:

 

OCG Fix:

Tribute 1 monster you control to activate this card. Special Summon 1 monster in your Graveyard except the Tributed monster in face-up Attack or Defense Position.

 

Because that's really how Monster Reborn/Reincarnation work. They both give you a chose of what position you want your monster re-summoned.

 

"Monster Reborn/Reincarnation work. They both give you a chose of what position you want your monster re-summoned"

actually it works with only Reborn, Reincarnation adds the monster to your hand =(

but hey, thnx for the advice =D

[Jazin Kay]

You don't need to specify attack or defense positions.

 

If you don't, you imply either can be selected.

[archie17]

You should add:

 

OCG Fix:

Tribute 1 monster (except Token monsters) you control to activate this card. Special Summon 1 monster in your Graveyard except the Tributed monster in face-up Attack or Defense Position.

 

Because that's really how Monster Reborn/Reincarnation work. They both give you a chose of what position you want your monster re-summoned.

 

"Monster Reborn/Reincarnation work. They both give you a chose of what position you want your monster re-summoned"

actually it works with only Reborn' date=' Reincarnation adds the monster to your hand =(

but hey, thnx for the advice =D

[/quote']

 

Oh yeah I forgot about the difference between field and hand concerning those 2 cards. Then you should keep it the way you had it with ATK position only that way it sets itself apart from Reborn yet similar too.

 

OCG Fix:

Tribute 1 monster you control to activate this card. Special Summon 1 monster in your Graveyard except the Tributed monster in Attack Position.

 

P.S. Can you let me know where you got the pic, I want to try to photoshop this pic.

[Chaos Flame]

I like it. A not broken version Monster Reborn. I would love it in my zombie deck. 9.5/10

[archie17]

Re-corrected the OCG again made sure to note Tokens to avoid a cheap Special Summons:

 

OCG Fix:

Tribute 1 monster (except Token monsters) that you control to activate this card. Special Summon 1 monster in your Graveyard except the Tributed monster in Attack Position.

[Wrathos]

This card would still be forbidden in advanced format.

[Chaos Flame]

I also like it being quick play, It would give you an extra attack or protect your monster from something that targets it.

[WhoAreYou?]

This card would still be forbidden in advanced format.

 

no it wouldn't it would be limited to 1, if it were real.

reason: you have to tribute to play this card, and then special summon a monster from your graveyard, so it's basically like switching spots with the graveyard/field.

 

monster reborn is banned because you don't have to pay anything and can get a monster from either player's graveyard, that's why it's the best.

 

premature burial is banned because even though you pay 800 life points to get the monster, it's a spell card and you can play it on your turn, not being fair to your opponent and overrunning him with your ace or w/e useful.

 

call of the haunted is the third one i know that's limited, because it's a trap card, having to wait until your opponent's turn to activate it or your next turn. so waiting makes things slower, and easier for your opponent to counter.

 

that in mind, this card would be limited to one for the offering of a monster, knowing that each card (except monster reborn) has a cost.

[EHN.]

*facepalm* *call of the haunted*

You n00bs Monster Reborn is forbidden so this is actually an awesome card.

 

9.5/10

[DarkSigner32]

Brilliant, a good idea

10/10

[Alexis Rhodes]

*facepalm* *call of the haunted*

You n00bs Monster Reborn is forbidden so this is actually an awesome card.

 

9.5/10

 

Yes and i imagine this would be forbidden aswell

 

 

OK picture sounds too much like monster reborn

 

7/10

[Sephiroth_The_Legend]

this would be the limited version of Monster Reborn

 

OCG FIX:

 

Tribute 1 monster you control. Special Summon 1 monster from your Graveyard, except the Tributed monster.

 

simple but effective.

it's sort of balanced but easily abusable.

i.e. tribute sangan, treeborn or someother card that belongs in the grave and get a free SS.

 

8/10

[WhoAreYou?]

*facepalm* *call of the haunted*

You n00bs Monster Reborn is forbidden so this is actually an awesome card.

 

9.5/10

 

Yes and i imagine this would be forbidden aswell

 

 

OK picture sounds too much like monster reborn

 

7/10

 

nah this wouldn't be forbidden, but limited to one at most. just like call of the haunted, it needs a drawback (CotH's drawback being a trap card, while this card's cost is tributing a monster to get a monster)

[Lord Smeagle]

Let's not forget it's also great for getting rid of a monster you don't want - I.E. your opponent's Lava Golem or your Jinzo that's locking down a trap you want to activate. And then it replaces itself.

[Mindscatter]

Underpowered.

[Silas Angel]

Monster Reborn is still better' date=' and maybe even Premature Burial as well

 

still, it's a nice card to have so I'll give this 9/10

[/quote']

 

Why compare this to two cards that are both broken and banned rightly? =/ It's almost like saying, "Well, Lightning Vortex is ok, but Raigeki and Dark Hole do a better job at it"

 

Anyways, a balanced Monster Reborn is nice =) I like this

---

Underpowered.

 

If it were any stronger, it'd be Monster Reborn. And we all know what happened to that, now don't we?

[Cloister]

Damn, I have always wanted to make a "Monster Reborn" lookalike card like this :)

 

but this is a really cool card! 9/10 (pic isn't the best but must have been hard to find a good one)

[Lord Smeagle]

I mean really, there are just so many ways to get around the restriction. Scapegoat/Fires of Doomsday are good fodder for this card.