Dragon of Ice

[Mcjimbob]

 

 

This is my first realistic so dont expect too much

[ragnarok1945]

bad OCG, you need to look at the OCG thread

 

besides, without a max attack limit, it'll get OPed very quickly

 

needs another effect than just gain atk, as well as specific summoning requirements

 

2/10

[Susie]

bad OCG' date=' you need to look at the OCG thread

 

besides, without a max attack limit, it'll get OPed very quickly

 

needs another effect than just gain atk, as well as specific summoning requirements

 

2/10

[/quote']

 

Agreeing with that post

[Raphidra]

Way too high level! Make it level 4 or 5, 5 might be better since the effect is powerful. I think pic is not yugioh style, mostly because of the poor bg.

[-Griffin]

besides' date=' without a max attack limit, it'll get OPed very quickly

 

needs another effect than just gain atk, as well as specific summoning requirements

 

2/10

[/quote']

 

Agreeing with that post

 

Disagreeing with these points.

 

The first point isn't at all a problem, it wouldn't be OP'd to lose field advantage for a mediocre or even strong beatstick, especially without an easy Summoning method. Currently, the only serious application would be tributing tokens and such from Scapegoat. It might seem OP'd to add 6000 ATK, but Scapegoat does that to a lot of things and really deserves to be banned anyway, so try not to build around it.

 

And Ragna, stop passing around the fallacy that cards need more than 1 effect or need complex effects. The simplest cards are often the best with the longest life spans for use. This card is fine after minor things such as OCG and the image are fixed up.

[ragnarok1945]

you get off my back, Griffin

 

when you have you seen a lv9 monster with that simple of an effect?

[Mcjimbob]

I will find another image

[Guest JoshIcy]

you get off my back' date=' Griffin

 

when you have you seen a lv9 monster with that simple of an effect?

[/quote']

 

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Ally_of_Justice_Field_Marshall

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/B._Skull_Dragon

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Moisture_Creature

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Trishula,_Dragon_of_the_Ice_Barrier

[MarbleZone]

you get off my back' date=' Griffin

 

when you have you seen a lv9 monster with that simple of an effect?

[/quote']

 

 

EDIT: Sarnathed. -.-

[-Griffin]

you get off my back' date=' Griffin

 

when you have you seen a lv9 monster with that simple of an effect?

[/quote']

 

When has level ever mattered at how complicated a card's effect should be? Stop bringing up fallacies of card design which you've propagated around here.

 

Side note:

Here's a list of level 9 monster's with single, simple effects:

XX-Saber Gattoms

Mist Worm

Naturia Gaodrake

Master of Oz

Real Genex Kurokishian

Red-Eyes Darkness Dragon

What Icy posted

 

By the way, Trish, Gattoms, Mist Worm, Oz and Kurokishian are all also runnable.