Overcritical Reviewers[aka Mods]

[Kōsuke Ueki]

Do you hate it when someone reviews a fan fic that you made and doesn't give you advice to improve on? I do. I had to go through that with one of the mods last year. Has that ever happened to you?

 

Discuss criticisms that never help you.

[Eury]

Realistic Cards section.

 

/topic

[Headmaster Monokuma]

Realistic Cards section.

 

/topic

 

Gah' date=' most of them don't review. They say,

 

good card

bad ocg

6/10

 

I've been getting lucky lately though, people actually say something about the card. So yes, [/topic']

[-Griffin]

Written Cards doesn't have this :D

[Cin]

Its not just the mods who do this you know, its normal members. I wouldn't know about the fanfics, too tame for me.

[Womi]

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

[Wuu.]

I'm pretty sure i always CnC on RC.

 

You know, you should put it in your signature that you need people to CnC or you'll rape them, like me.

[Raylen]

Written Cards doesn't have this :D

 

Written Cards are for people who are too smart for their own good. They think they're smarter than the n00bs that flood RC, so quite obviously.

[CrabHelmet]

The review that double_c4 is complaining about is, specifically, this one. Anyone sufficiently fluent in the English language to read it will probably find that it is rather more constructive than double_c4 believes.

 

The best part is that double_c4 is himself an attempted reviewer - except only half of what he says is actual advice, and when he does give actual advice, it's generally bad advice that, if followed, would make the story worse.

[Wuu.]

The review that double_c4 is complaining about is' date=' specifically, this one. Anyone sufficiently fluent in the English language to read it will probably find that it is rather more constructive than double_c4 believes.

 

The best part is that double_c4 is himself an attempted reviewer - except only half of what he says is actual advice, and when he does give actual advice, it's generally bad advice that, if followed, would make the story worse.

 

C4 Shouldn't even have the right to speak, because everything Crab Helmet does comes with an extremely good reason.

[Womi]

C-4's words were so touching, I cried the whole night. ;_;

[Kitty]

Realistic Cards section.

 

/topic

 

Gah' date=' most of them don't review. They say,

 

good card

bad ocg

6/10

 

I've been getting lucky lately though, people actually say something about the card. So yes, [/topic']

 

That is because Icy has been stricter.

 

OT: I've never had that happen to me. xD

[Guest Merciful Idiot]

They do help you improve, however, this:

The fact that whenever you see criticism to your work' date=' you go into a Roaring Rage Of Rampage type of thing, and then you become blind and can only see the criticism to your work, you don't see how it might it be useful. You would think that this person is just trying to screw you. Granted, he might actually really be trying to do that, but at least that person gave you lots of help.

Let's say this, for example:

[b']Insert story here[/b]

Insert complaints and random jokes about description here

Insert well-explained 'u think this is prob? dis is gewd' here

And then one would get blinded. And stuff.

 

So yeah, go figure.

[Guest JoshIcy]

Realistic Cards section.

 

/topic

 

Gah' date=' most of them don't review. They say,

 

good card

bad ocg

6/10

 

I've been getting lucky lately though, people actually say something about the card. So yes, [/topic']

 

http://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/thread-213340.html

[Grunt Issun]

inb4lock

 

Wow...this is hillarious!

you are so whiney! no review can be over critical, according to the jack witt clause! only if they insult the user in a very personal way, like, you are a worthless peice of crap

[Headmaster Monokuma]

Realistic Cards section.

 

/topic

 

Gah' date=' most of them don't review. They say,

 

good card

bad ocg

6/10

 

I've been getting lucky lately though, people actually say something about the card. So yes, [/topic']

 

http://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/thread-213340.html

 

If I was more active in that section, I would comment there, but sadly I only have a few posts in that section. That's why I'm slowly working my way into it.

[Mehmani]

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

[Lonk]

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

 

I love Parakoopas

[Hollow Ichigo!]

Well sure that has happened to everyone. I guess in a way it's a mods job to annoy the hell out of you. But regardless complaining is solving nothing.

[Lonk]

You helped create a new YCM meme with your review being reviewed by crab. You should feel honored that you are helping to create a meme. The moar you poast about your review being heavily critisized, the more you make

 

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

 

more popular

[Nnoitra Jiruga]

I hardly even make threads so...yeah

[Raylen]

You should see my editors, they're quite harsh. Especially after 25 hours of reworking like 4,000 words of my novel, they come back only to trash it again.

[Godot]

Do you hate it when someone reviews a fan fic that you made and doesn't give you advice to improve on? I do. I had to go through that with one of the mods last year. Has that ever happened to you?

 

Aww, is somebody mad at Crab?

[Headmaster Monokuma]

Do you hate it when someone reviews a fan fic that you made and doesn't give you advice to improve on? I do. I had to go through that with one of the mods last year. Has that ever happened to you?

 

Aww' date=' is somebody mad at Crab?

[/quote']

 

Am I the only subtle person here anymore?

[Grunt Issun]

Subtle? isnt that a fancy word for lying?