New card

[beefman]

The OCG probably sucks on this, because I've never seen a card with an effect like this.

[img]http://img340.imageshack.us/img340/8794/226908v.jpg[/img]
Lore: This card can attack one of your own monsters. If this card were to deal battle damage to a player, it is treated as gaining Life Points instead.

Rate and hate. But please rate.

[♥Łövëły-Ċħän♥]

Did you mean to double post?

As Chill said (I didn't even think of this) Good for Token Spam. You can also use this to trigger effects that activate when the monster is destroyed by battle. Definitly original though, I'm not sure I can see this being played much.

[.Nu-13]

OCG Fix:
[i]This card can select a monster you control as an attack target. If this card would inflict Battle Damage to a player, that player gains the same amount of Life Points instead.[/i]

Otherwise, card is quite original. It could be nice in token-spamming decks, as most tokens have 0 ATK. Combine it with some card that allows multiple attack, and... nice

[beefman]

Thanks for the good comments, and I did not mean to double post. It must have been an accident.

Also: gee, I'm a 3 star and I already have 2 6 stars commenting on this! Shveet.

[claude_c_kenny]

you should change it so it says to select a non-token monster, otherwise it is overpowered. also, perhaps effects that would activate when a monster is destroyed in battle should be negated.

[beefman]

[quote name='claude_c_kenny' timestamp='1293658741' post='4894041']
you should change it so it says to selcet a non-token monster, otherwise it is overpowered. also, perhaps effects that would activate when a monster is destroyed in battle should be negated.
[/quote]

Maybe not OP too much, I still think it could be dangerous if you attack an opponent's monster.

[CDDRodrigo]

It's not OP'd, in fact I quite like it.

This + that monster who deals damage when you gain LP, if someone knows its name, tell me please + Stray Lambs = 5200 LP gain, and 1000 or so of damage to the opponent.

[beefman]

[quote name='CDDRodrigo' timestamp='1293660787' post='4894131']
It's not OP'd, in fact I quite like it.

This + that monster who deals damage when you gain LP, if someone knows its name, tell me please + Stray Lambs = 5200 LP gain, and 1000 or so of damage to the opponent.
[/quote]

I think that would be fire princess.

[War Chess]

[quote name='Chillaccino' timestamp='1293654521' post='4893803']
OCG Fix:
[i]This card can select a monster you control as an attack target. If this card would inflict Battle Damage to a player, that player gains the same amount of Life Points instead.[/i]

Yeah, I think this ^ is the right OCG.
I would suggest something else but OK.

I liked the card, but in a combo like It + Marshmallow OR Spirit Reaper OR Cloudians is quite OP for me.
But I liked it !

8.8/10
^Because of the OP thing.

[beefman]

[quote name='War Chess' timestamp='1293667816' post='4894522']
[quote name='Chillaccino' timestamp='1293654521' post='4893803']
OCG Fix:
[i]This card can select a monster you control as an attack target. If this card would inflict Battle Damage to a player, that player gains the same amount of Life Points instead.[/i][/quote]

Yeah, I think this ^ is the right OCG.
I would suggest something else but OK.

I liked the card, but in a combo like It + Marshmallow OR Spirit Reaper OR Cloudians is quite OP for me.
But I liked it !

8.8/10
^Because of the OP thing.
[/quote]

Say your opponent had bad reaction to simochi...

But that would be rare, of course

[War Chess]

[quote name='Sanphred' timestamp='1293668015' post='4894527']
Say your opponent had bad reaction to simochi...

But that would be rare, of course
[/quote]

Not that rare, but I didn't think about it.
Still, this card is a little OP. What if you have a [url="http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Fire_Princess"]fire pricess[/url] with 3 [url="http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Dark_Room_of_Nightmare"]dark rooms of nightmare[/url].

For me, its not that rare you get burned.

[beefman]

[quote name='War Chess' timestamp='1293670708' post='4894651']
Not that rare, but I didn't think about it.
Still, this card is a little OP. What if you have a [url="http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Fire_Princess"]fire pricess[/url] with 3 [url="http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Dark_Room_of_Nightmare"]dark rooms of nightmare[/url].

For me, its not that rare you get burned.
[/quote]

Say you had 3 fire princesses instead of 1.
2400 damage per attack!
Yeah, I see your point. However, it's a bit weak when it comes to atk.

[claude_c_kenny]

Im not sure how to quote people yet, so please excuse me. what war chess mentioned, as far as spirit reaper and marshmallon, is part of the reason why I said it should negate monster effects. you can use blessful witch to get a quick LP fix, but at the cost of one of your better defenders.


then again, maybe im thinking about it all wrong. I do think it is a unique effect, that I personally have never seen before. I give it 8/10 (if allowed to rate).

[beefman]

[quote name='claude_c_kenny' timestamp='1293671944' post='4894705']
Im not sure how to quote people yet, so please excuse me. what war chess mentioned, as far as spirit reaper and marshmallon, is part of the reason why I said it should negate monster effects. you can use blessful witch to get a quick LP fix, but at the cost of one of your better defenders.


then again, maybe im thinking about it all wrong. I do think it is a unique effect, that I personally have never seen before. I give it 8/10 (if allowed to rate).
[/quote]

Of course you're allowed to rate! Thanks. And, to quote, press "reply" in the bottom right of someone's post (the one you want to quote)

[beefman]

bbuummpp

[Y.M.R.creator]

nice card
I like the effect and the picture,but OCG is less
anyway, great job!

9.5/10

[Shadow-Master]

8/10

It's pretty good, minus the OCG errors and the picture.

The picture is good and all, but I don't see how a rope protruding from a Witch's genital area provides that kind of a good picture.
Other than that, a completely original idea and not OP at all.

Reasons it is not OP:

You cannot attack your opponent, fearing they might get higher life points
One of your monsters are being destroyed in the progress.

Reasons it is OP:

You can gain life points a lot quicker
Token-based decks support this card a lot

So I guess it balances out and it is not UP, nor OP.

[beefman]

[quote name='Shadow-Master' timestamp='1294092266' post='4909477']
8/10

It's pretty good, minus the OCG errors and the picture.

The picture is good and all, but I don't see how a rope protruding from a Witch's genital area provides that kind of a good picture.
Other than that, a completely original idea and not OP at all.

Reasons it is not OP:

You cannot attack your opponent, fearing they might get higher life points
One of your monsters are being destroyed in the progress.

Reasons it is OP:

You can gain life points a lot quicker
Token-based decks support this card a lot

So I guess it balances out and it is not UP, nor OP.
[/quote]

Thanks. And on the pic, either you can't see the rope thing's end, and it's just floating, or it's coming out of her leg.