Gravekeeper's Peacemaker & Gravekeeper's Judgment

[GKforever]

Check out my cards that I would like Konami to make. Makes the deck faster, give's them an extra boost they need.

[img]http://oi43.tinypic.com/200r5ok.jpg[/img]

Once per turn while "Necrovalley" is on the field: Select one "Gravekeeper's" monster in your Graveyard and detach 1 Xyz Material from this card; Special Summon that monster in face-up Defense Position or face-down Defense Position. This effect cannot be negated by the effect of "Necrovalley".

[img]http://oi42.tinypic.com/n6yvsh.jpg[/img]

This card cannot be added from your Deck or Graveyard to your hand by a card effect. If you control a face-up "Gravekeeper's" monster, you can Special Summon this card from your hand. If this card is Tributed by a card effect: Add 1 "Gravekeeper's" monster from your Deck to your hand.


[img]http://oi43.tinypic.com/ap24y.jpg[/img]

Each time a "Gravekeeper's" monster(s) is tributed, place 1 Offering Counter on this card (max. 2). You can send this card to the Graveyard to draw 1 card for each Offering Counter on this card.

[TheKaitoKid]

Peacemaker has a pretty cool effect, but 1000 more ATK & DEF points wouldn't hurt. That or reduce it's Level.

[GKforever]

[quote name='TheKaitoKid' timestamp='1328675513' post='5803828']
Peacemaker has a pretty cool effect, but 1000 more ATK & DEF points wouldn't hurt. That or reduce it's Level.
[/quote]

im not trying to make it to OP but I guess you are right. I based it off of Kizan (also the trap is after Magatama) plus the eff to add any Gravkeeper is a huge plus. Being able to fetch Spy is kind of not fair in a way.

[Menace13]

I have a few problems with these.
The spell and trap are copies of Six Samurai United and Musakani Magatama, respectively.
The monster has an entirely different problem: Tribute 1, search another, special it, tribute it, search another, special it, tribute it, search any other GK. Loop, loop, and more loop. It makes Stele destroy 2 and search 2. It is very broken. Needs to have a drawback (The effect of "Gravekeeper's Peacemaker" can only be activated once per turn.) or not be as good (drop one of the effects).

Also, don't upload attachments, and especially not as thumbnails. It's much easier to read them if you upload them as images to Imgur or somewhere and then post them here using the Image button.

[Blake]

[quote name='Menace13' timestamp='1328677271' post='5803900']
I have a few problems with these.
The spell and trap are copies of Six Samurai United and Musakani Magatama, respectively.
The monster has an entirely different problem: Tribute 1, search another, special it, tribute it, search another, special it, tribute it, search any other GK. Loop, loop, and more loop. It makes Stele destroy 2 and search 2. It is very broken. Needs to have a drawback (The effect of "Gravekeeper's Peacemaker" can only be activated once per turn.) or not be as good (drop one of the effects).

Also, don't upload attachments, and especially not as thumbnails. It's much easier to read them if you upload them as images to Imgur or somewhere and then post them here using the Image button.
[/quote]
This

You're just turning Sam support into G-K support, and breaking them beyond all reason ._.

Peacekeeper is damn broken considering the facts of Recruiter and Descendant. It basically turns Recruiter into a not-Once per turn Inzektor Centipede, which certainly isn't balanced in the slightest.

And offering is nothign but a +1 WIN MOAR card that works with the archetype's main gimmick. Six Sam United, anyone? ._.

If you're going to use existing ideas to make cards, don't take ALL of them from the same archetype's cards and support =/

The Xyz is actually a nice change, in that sense, though... It's broken ._. It's a +0 Xyz, minimum. Getting Valley out isn't difficult at all, so, again, a WIN MOAR card. Dunno if it would actually be played, but bad card design.

And why are you using pics from the Anime...?

EDIT: change the card pic for Peacekeeper, I didn't see the edit.

Still just screams "+1 off of me", but at least it can't loop =/

[GKforever]

[quote name='Relius Clover' timestamp='1328683270' post='5804045']
This

You're just turning Sam support into G-K support, and breaking them beyond all reason ._.

Peacekeeper is damn broken considering the facts of Recruiter and Descendant. It basically turns Recruiter into a not-Once per turn Inzektor Centipede, which certainly isn't balanced in the slightest.

And offering is nothign but a +1 WIN MOAR card that works with the archetype's main gimmick. Six Sam United, anyone? ._.

If you're going to use existing ideas to make cards, don't take ALL of them from the same archetype's cards and support =/

The Xyz is actually a nice change, in that sense, though... It's broken ._. It's a +0 Xyz, minimum. Getting Valley out isn't difficult at all, so, again, a WIN MOAR card. Dunno if it would actually be played, but bad card design.

And why are you using pics from the Anime...?

EDIT: change the card pic for Peacekeeper, I didn't see the edit.

Still just screams "+1 off of me", but at least it can't loop =/
[/quote]

Peacekeeper cannot be added to your hand by card effect. GK are so slow now. If you don't set up with a spy first turn your chances of winning are very much decreased. I think peacekeeper is a balanced card because it can't be added to hand. Royal Offering could take up to 2 turns to accomplish and by that time your opponent could mst it. Increasing the draw power of the deck would make them top again.

[Blake]

I edited because I noticed you changed it =T

You realize Peacekeeper is nothing but a walking +1? Summon descendant, automatically search and destroy. Recruiter exists so why give more fire power to it, searchable or not, that's basically the same but quicker?

Offering is broken because it's their ENTIRE GIMMICK. Arguing that it can be MSTd is dumb because Quasar dies to Solemn Warning and Wind-Up loop dies to Maxx "C".