Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 3 weeks later...

[quote name='jabber2033' timestamp='1345206109' post='6009102']
I saw "Water Dragon" there in your list. That card already exists.

[img]http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20071031194125/yugioh/images/thumb/a/a3/WaterDragon-MF02-EN-NPR-LE.jpg/300px-WaterDragon-MF02-EN-NPR-LE.jpg[/img]
[/quote]It will become Aqua dragon then! :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

...Wh...

Why... Why are these in "Realistic" cards...?

I'm not trying to be offensive or anything, but it was painful to read through some of those. I can only say that you're a novice. There were a few that I liked, though, such as "The Reaper". It was a simple Ritual monster with decent beef and a drawing effect.

The rest of the cards were pretty bland and weak. I can see what you were trying to do, matching some of them together, but others were just... Wha?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Pepperyena' timestamp='1351394478' post='6055374']
...Wh...

Why... Why are these in "Realistic" cards...?

I'm not trying to be offensive or anything, but it was painful to read through some of those. I can only say that you're a novice. There were a few that I liked, though, such as "The Reaper". It was a simple Ritual monster with decent beef and a drawing effect.

The rest of the cards were pretty bland and weak. I can see what you were trying to do, matching some of them together, but others were just... Wha?
[/quote]

Some the text is small, just because website makes it so small, like on toon luster soldier, its just a regular toon monster's effect. Most of the cards, I tried to match together in some way like through fusions, spells, traps, or synchros, but then some of the cards I just left alone. I left some of them alone because I had just watched the original yugioh and I had some nostalgia from that so I made cards that would have been used back then. Any other cards, I made for fun.

Also I'm gonna be adding more cards, and fixing card effects.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

These cards belong in the first generation. We're not in first gen, we're in 5th gen, arguably 6th. Therefore, I will not give these cards comprehensive individual reviews, just a generalization: get yo ass on duelingnetwork.com, duel a bit, and see what kinds of cards are used. Then, come back and make cards on YCM. Warning; prepare to get your ass beaten by some of the duelists there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Archlord Sora' timestamp='1351441236' post='6055621']
These cards belong in the first generation. We're not in first gen, we're in 5th gen, arguably 6th. Therefore, I will not give these cards comprehensive individual reviews, just a generalization: get yo ass on duelingnetwork.com, duel a bit, and see what kinds of cards are used. Then, come back and make cards on YCM. Warning; prepare to get your ass beaten by some of the duelists there.
[/quote]

Because these cards are clearly so bad that you can't say anything about them, right? Oh wait, there's nothing wrong with the cards. Sure, some of them are underpowered, but that doesn't mean that the cards are so bad that you cannot post anything. So yeah, don't post a comment like this if all you're going to say is "I'm not going to comment".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Archlord Sora' timestamp='1351441929' post='6055634']
@ Zanda
I was telling him how to become a better card maker, which is valuable by definition. RC is a place for hypothetical, creative, contemporary cards to be discussed, edited, and shared. These can't do any of the above, as they're too basic for deep discussion.
[/quote]

RC is a place for realistic and balanced cards, not over the top creative cards. So the cards aren't creative enough, you deem them worthless to discuss over? This kind of mentality is one of the reasons why RC is a shithole. ONE reason.

And no, you weren't telling him how to become a better card maker. Your post had nothing indicating on how to be a better card maker, nor a better player at YuGiOh. So yeah, all you did was tell him that his cards aren't worth discussion because you deem them to be too basic and that automatically makes him a bad card maker.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Archlord Sora' timestamp='1351441236' post='6055621']
These cards belong in the first generation. We're not in first gen, we're in 5th gen, arguably 6th. Therefore, I will not give these cards comprehensive individual reviews, just a generalization: get yo ass on duelingnetwork.com, duel a bit, and see what kinds of cards are used. Then, come back and make cards on YCM. Warning; prepare to get your ass beaten by some of the duelists there.
[/quote]
I am aready on dueling network =_=. Also most of these cards were created by me for fun.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

These are fairly good, especially from a beginner. Obviously I can't review all the cards individually, but here's some tips:

* You weren't always consistent on capitalizing every word in the card name. It makes the card look more official if you do.
* Give your fusion monsters effects. It's a little more lenient on the normal monsters because you have some support for them. But there's no excuse not to give the fusion monsters effects.
* Some effects like Melzar the Tree Spirit and Lightning Golem have situational effects in this meta. Feel free to give them more ATK/DEF to make up for it, or another effect or something.
* Photon Cyber Dragon already exists in the TCG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='seattleite' timestamp='1351443032' post='6055652']
These are fairly good, especially from a beginner. Obviously I can't review all the cards individually, but here's some tips:

* You weren't always consistent on capitalizing every word in the card name. It makes the card look more official if you do.
* Give your fusion monsters effects. It's a little more lenient on the normal monsters because you have some support for them. But there's no excuse not to give the fusion monsters effects.
* Some effects like Melzar the Tree Spirit and Lightning Golem have situational effects in this meta. Feel free to give them more ATK/DEF to make up for it, or another effect or something.
* Photon Cyber Dragon already exists in the TCG
[/quote]

Thank you for the advise. Though, there is no photon cyber dragon in the TCG (i just checked), are you refering to proto-cyber dragon or cyber laser dragon?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 6 months later...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...