Jump to content

Tiny Contest --- Completed


Recommended Posts

COMPLETED. RESULTS ARE BELOW.

 

 

So. Everyone loves the 4-star and up monsters. Why? Cause they're awesome....or so everyone thinks. Now, here's the contest. Make the best 3-star and under monsters and you can. You are allowed to make a set of up to, and no more than 5 cards. Please put all cards in one post. You may add Spell and Trap cards, but no Rituals or Fusions.

 

There can be any amount of contestants, but please post all cards on one post. If they are not, I will judge the post with the most cards.

 

This contest will end on 4-16-08 (3 days from today.)

 

Prizes:

 

 

These cards will be graded on the following scale:

 

OCG - 20%

Originality - 30%

Picture - 10%

My Personal Rating - 10%

Effect - 20%

Follows a Theme - 5%

Name - 5%

 

 

List of Entrants

1.god_splice

 

OCG - 0%

Originality - 0%

Picture - 0%

My Personal Rating - 0%

Effect - 0%

Follows a Theme - 0%

Name - 0%

Unless I'm mistaken, you did not post a single card. I am disappointed.

 

2.Frlf

 

OCG - 16% - a few grammatical errors, misspellings, otherwise pretty good

Originality - 24% - while no one else makes "Giant Titans" you make a lot. I'm not saying they are bad, I'm just saying you should think of other ideas.

Picture - 10% - I don't seem them everyday. :)

My Personal Rating - 7% - I like the pictures, but Frody is a little underpowered. 3 tributes for 1500 ATK?

Effect - 15% - Not bad, but not the best in the world.

Follows a Theme - 5%. Self-Explanatory.

Name - 4% - Self-Explanatory.

 

Total - 81%

 

3.hunterb

 

OCG - 20% - Self-Explanatory.

Originality - 27% - Based off of an older card.

Picture - 8% - Well-suited, but not nice to my eyes.

My Personal Rating - 3% - The card is nice, but you only made 1.

Effect - 13% - Overpowered.

Follows a Theme - 0% - Self-Explanatory.

Name - 2% - Based off of an older card.

 

Total - 73% (you should have made more cards...)

 

4.SKO5000

 

OCG - 0% - makes no sense whatsoever

Originality - 0% - I do not understand your card...

Picture - 7% - I'll give you that...

My Personal Rating - 0% - I do not understand...

Effect - 0% - do I have to repeat myself?

Follows a Theme - 0%

Name - 0%

 

Total - 7%

(I need to hurry, so at this point, if there is nothing really important, I will just leave the score blank.)

5.Kiosken

 

OCG - 17% - Capitalization errors here and there.

Originality - 30%.

Picture - 10%

My Personal Rating - 8%

Effect - 15% - What is "Kilala - Transform"?

Follows a Theme - 5%

Name - 5%

 

Total - 90%

6.devil_chronos_dj

 

OCG - 14% - Incorrect grammar

Originality - 30%

Picture - 10%

My Personal Rating - 4%

Effect - 17% - do you mean "500" because 150 is almost underpowered

Follows a Theme - 0% - ...you people don't understand do you...

Name - 5%

 

Total - 80%

(If you have any questions, just PM me and I will explain it to you.)

7.joemilk

 

OCG - 14%

Originality - 28%

Picture - 10%

My Personal Rating - 8%

Effect - 14% - I kinda don't understand some of it...

Follows a Theme - 0%

Name - 5%

 

Total - 79%

8.kingoffrogs

 

OCG - 16% - Errors.

Originality - 30%

Picture - 10%

My Personal Rating - 4%...meh. I don't like.

Effect - 0%. This is realistic cards section, and we are way too overpowered here.

Follows a Theme - 0%

Name - 5% - Unique... I guess.

 

Total - 65%

 

9.alvarosv

 

(i'll go with buggy)

OCG - 14% - capitalization, mostly.

Originality - 20% - off of a show.

Picture - 9% - decent, but not the best.

My Personal Rating - 7%

Effect - 18% - A little confusing

Follows a Theme - 5%

Name - 5%

 

Total - 78%

10.schyshter

 

OCG - 20%

Originality - 30% - WOW.

Picture - 10%

My Personal Rating - 10% - Me like!

Effect - 20%

Follows a Theme - 0% - I hate to ruin the perfectionism, but... they don't really follow one...

Name - 5%

 

Total - 95%

11. Poke123

 

 

OCG - 10% - not good grammar

Originality - 17% - off of a game

Picture - 7% - an okay picture

My Personal Rating - 6%

Effect - 13%

Follows a Theme - 5%

Name - 5%

 

Total - 63%

1st place - 20 points, and 3 reps. And the winner is...

 

SCHYSTER!!

 

2nd place - 10 points, and 2 reps. And the winner is...

 

KIOSKEN!!

 

3rd place - 1 rep. And the winner is...

 

FRLF!!

 

Anything else = nothing.

 

Congrats to all who won, and good job for everyone else.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@ King of Frogs > No, I can't. :) But, you can set your options so that when you get a PM, you will get an email.

 

@ Everyone > Remember, this is a SET-based contest. When this contest is over, and I find that you have posted only one card, you will probably get some pretty low personal ratings/originality ratings, as well as a 0% for theme rating. Just warning you...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...