Jump to content

Meti's Card Review Thread (Reviewers Found no more applications.)

Careless Whisper

By Careless Whisper
in Realistic Cards

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 112
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Guest JoshIcy

Guest JoshIcy

Posted
Posted

I'm not the reviewer type lol, as im not hypocritical etc.... But i would love for you to do a review on the card in the following thread, (its effect is basically a wall of text so its up to you whether or not to copy the info...)

http://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/showthread.php?tid=48773

 

Those who I've asked give mixed opinions lol, and yours is one I respect so ya :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest JoshIcy

Guest JoshIcy

Posted
Posted

I'm not the reviewer type lol, as im not hypocritical etc.... But i would love for you to do a review on the card in the following thread, (its effect is basically a wall of text so its up to you whether or not to copy the info...)

http://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/showthread.php?tid=48773

 

Those who I've asked give mixed opinions lol, and yours is one I respect so ya :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest JoshIcy

Guest JoshIcy

Posted
Posted

I'm not the reviewer type lol, as im not hypocritical etc.... But i would love for you to do a review on the card in the following thread, (its effect is basically a wall of text so its up to you whether or not to copy the info...)

http://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/showthread.php?tid=48773

 

Those who I've asked give mixed opinions lol, and yours is one I respect so ya :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Careless Whisper Newbie

Careless Whisper

Posted
  • Author
Posted
benevolentseal.jpg

All Spell and Trap Card Zones are also treated as Monster Card Zones and all Monster Card Zones are also treated as Spell and Trap Card Zones. As long as this card remains face-up on the field' date=' all Monsters you control are treated as Spell and Trap Cards, (they are still treated as monsters). In addition as long as this card remains face-up on the field, all Spell and Trap Cards are treated as monsters, (Spellcaster/LIGHT/Level 1/ATK 0/DEF 0) in Attack Position during the Damage Step only, (they are still treated as Spell or Trap Cards). When this card is removed from the field, all Spell and Trap Cards outside the Spell and Trap Card Zone are treated as (Spellcaster/Level 1/ATK 0/DEF 0) and are considered in attack position, (Their positions cannot be changed). This effect cannot be negated. When this card is removed from the field any Monster Cards outside the Monster Card Zone are treated as Continuous Spell and Trap Cards that have no effect, (They are considered both Spell and Trap Cards). This effect cannot be negated.[/i']

 

Ah yes. Icyblue's latest Single card. As usual, I'm already syked about this. Given Icyblue's history as an unexpected Card Maker in all areas, but that will not give him extra points.

 

Now to start off, with the name:

 

Benevolent Seal....Very interesting, very unique, but not quite as subtle as the cards he has made in his past.

 

The picture:

It has a rather original picture, it fits the card very well, and it also gives an aura of happiness, as usual, it always does for me.

 

But the effect:

Oh...where to start, now Icy has a history of having extremely unpredictable and complicated effects, though his imagination may run alittle rampant and cause alittle bit overbalance. But this card can make your Spell/Trap card zone be treated as the monster card zone, allowing more monsters onto the field, so this would be really good if you used United We Stand on Maha Vailo with a full zone. But you can also use your Monster card Zone as a Spell/Trap Card Zone, allowing you more protection and security for your other cards. But with a very bad drawback, it can allow Heavy Storm to effect your monster card zone, or just deserts being a rather ultimate burn card. But to top it all off, it can't be negated, but when it's removed from the field, any monsters out of place are treated as continuous spell cards, but are useless. You're pretty much in a very tight situation if this card is ever removed from the field, because you have monster cards clogging up your spell/trap zone. So understandably, this card is perfectly balanced and has great OCG, but would be unwise to use incase of severe cards to remove from the field at the presice time.

 

Rating::::

Name: 2/2 (Very interesting and make me want to see more of the card)

Picture: 2/2 (Allows me to think about what the card might do, and it fits the card really well.)

Effect: 5/6 (It has great OCG, great balance, but inwise to use)

 

Overall: 9/10 *Highest Score Yet and only my second rating* (Alot of effort was put into this card, the OCG is perfect, the creativity is great, but the risk of using this card, despite it's perfect balance, is just too great that it is rendered foolish to use in a real match.)

 

Enjoy

 

~Meti

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Careless Whisper Newbie

Careless Whisper

Posted
  • Author
Posted
benevolentseal.jpg

All Spell and Trap Card Zones are also treated as Monster Card Zones and all Monster Card Zones are also treated as Spell and Trap Card Zones. As long as this card remains face-up on the field' date=' all Monsters you control are treated as Spell and Trap Cards, (they are still treated as monsters). In addition as long as this card remains face-up on the field, all Spell and Trap Cards are treated as monsters, (Spellcaster/LIGHT/Level 1/ATK 0/DEF 0) in Attack Position during the Damage Step only, (they are still treated as Spell or Trap Cards). When this card is removed from the field, all Spell and Trap Cards outside the Spell and Trap Card Zone are treated as (Spellcaster/Level 1/ATK 0/DEF 0) and are considered in attack position, (Their positions cannot be changed). This effect cannot be negated. When this card is removed from the field any Monster Cards outside the Monster Card Zone are treated as Continuous Spell and Trap Cards that have no effect, (They are considered both Spell and Trap Cards). This effect cannot be negated.[/i']

 

Ah yes. Icyblue's latest Single card. As usual, I'm already syked about this. Given Icyblue's history as an unexpected Card Maker in all areas, but that will not give him extra points.

 

Now to start off, with the name:

 

Benevolent Seal....Very interesting, very unique, but not quite as subtle as the cards he has made in his past.

 

The picture:

It has a rather original picture, it fits the card very well, and it also gives an aura of happiness, as usual, it always does for me.

 

But the effect:

Oh...where to start, now Icy has a history of having extremely unpredictable and complicated effects, though his imagination may run alittle rampant and cause alittle bit overbalance. But this card can make your Spell/Trap card zone be treated as the monster card zone, allowing more monsters onto the field, so this would be really good if you used United We Stand on Maha Vailo with a full zone. But you can also use your Monster card Zone as a Spell/Trap Card Zone, allowing you more protection and security for your other cards. But with a very bad drawback, it can allow Heavy Storm to effect your monster card zone, or just deserts being a rather ultimate burn card. But to top it all off, it can't be negated, but when it's removed from the field, any monsters out of place are treated as continuous spell cards, but are useless. You're pretty much in a very tight situation if this card is ever removed from the field, because you have monster cards clogging up your spell/trap zone. So understandably, this card is perfectly balanced and has great OCG, but would be unwise to use incase of severe cards to remove from the field at the presice time.

 

Rating::::

Name: 2/2 (Very interesting and make me want to see more of the card)

Picture: 2/2 (Allows me to think about what the card might do, and it fits the card really well.)

Effect: 5/6 (It has great OCG, great balance, but inwise to use)

 

Overall: 9/10 *Highest Score Yet and only my second rating* (Alot of effort was put into this card, the OCG is perfect, the creativity is great, but the risk of using this card, despite it's perfect balance, is just too great that it is rendered foolish to use in a real match.)

 

Enjoy

 

~Meti

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Careless Whisper Newbie

Careless Whisper

Posted
  • Author
Posted
benevolentseal.jpg

All Spell and Trap Card Zones are also treated as Monster Card Zones and all Monster Card Zones are also treated as Spell and Trap Card Zones. As long as this card remains face-up on the field' date=' all Monsters you control are treated as Spell and Trap Cards, (they are still treated as monsters). In addition as long as this card remains face-up on the field, all Spell and Trap Cards are treated as monsters, (Spellcaster/LIGHT/Level 1/ATK 0/DEF 0) in Attack Position during the Damage Step only, (they are still treated as Spell or Trap Cards). When this card is removed from the field, all Spell and Trap Cards outside the Spell and Trap Card Zone are treated as (Spellcaster/Level 1/ATK 0/DEF 0) and are considered in attack position, (Their positions cannot be changed). This effect cannot be negated. When this card is removed from the field any Monster Cards outside the Monster Card Zone are treated as Continuous Spell and Trap Cards that have no effect, (They are considered both Spell and Trap Cards). This effect cannot be negated.[/i']

 

Ah yes. Icyblue's latest Single card. As usual, I'm already syked about this. Given Icyblue's history as an unexpected Card Maker in all areas, but that will not give him extra points.

 

Now to start off, with the name:

 

Benevolent Seal....Very interesting, very unique, but not quite as subtle as the cards he has made in his past.

 

The picture:

It has a rather original picture, it fits the card very well, and it also gives an aura of happiness, as usual, it always does for me.

 

But the effect:

Oh...where to start, now Icy has a history of having extremely unpredictable and complicated effects, though his imagination may run alittle rampant and cause alittle bit overbalance. But this card can make your Spell/Trap card zone be treated as the monster card zone, allowing more monsters onto the field, so this would be really good if you used United We Stand on Maha Vailo with a full zone. But you can also use your Monster card Zone as a Spell/Trap Card Zone, allowing you more protection and security for your other cards. But with a very bad drawback, it can allow Heavy Storm to effect your monster card zone, or just deserts being a rather ultimate burn card. But to top it all off, it can't be negated, but when it's removed from the field, any monsters out of place are treated as continuous spell cards, but are useless. You're pretty much in a very tight situation if this card is ever removed from the field, because you have monster cards clogging up your spell/trap zone. So understandably, this card is perfectly balanced and has great OCG, but would be unwise to use incase of severe cards to remove from the field at the presice time.

 

Rating::::

Name: 2/2 (Very interesting and make me want to see more of the card)

Picture: 2/2 (Allows me to think about what the card might do, and it fits the card really well.)

Effect: 5/6 (It has great OCG, great balance, but inwise to use)

 

Overall: 9/10 *Highest Score Yet and only my second rating* (Alot of effort was put into this card, the OCG is perfect, the creativity is great, but the risk of using this card, despite it's perfect balance, is just too great that it is rendered foolish to use in a real match.)

 

Enjoy

 

~Meti

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest JoshIcy

Guest JoshIcy

Posted
Posted

Lol thanks Meti ^_^ it means alot that you gave such a great review for such an experimental card :D

 

Oh and as for the subtlety, i couldnt due to possible overpoweredness... and as such, the text had to say what would happen and when so that this card does not just become another Seal Of Orihalcos....

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest JoshIcy

Guest JoshIcy

Posted
Posted

Lol thanks Meti ^_^ it means alot that you gave such a great review for such an experimental card :D

 

Oh and as for the subtlety, i couldnt due to possible overpoweredness... and as such, the text had to say what would happen and when so that this card does not just become another Seal Of Orihalcos....

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest JoshIcy

Guest JoshIcy

Posted
Posted

Lol thanks Meti ^_^ it means alot that you gave such a great review for such an experimental card :D

 

Oh and as for the subtlety, i couldnt due to possible overpoweredness... and as such, the text had to say what would happen and when so that this card does not just become another Seal Of Orihalcos....

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Careless Whisper Newbie

Careless Whisper

Posted
  • Author
Posted

...Alright, I shall review tomorrow, apparently Stephanie wants me to go to bed, sense I have a big day tomorrow...Promotion at work..lol I work at a Ponce De Leon Music Center. but that's off-topic, I'll get the next review tomorrow after work. Please, let's see if I can have a sort of competition for the next review.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Careless Whisper Newbie

Careless Whisper

Posted
  • Author
Posted

...Alright, I shall review tomorrow, apparently Stephanie wants me to go to bed, sense I have a big day tomorrow...Promotion at work..lol I work at a Ponce De Leon Music Center. but that's off-topic, I'll get the next review tomorrow after work. Please, let's see if I can have a sort of competition for the next review.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...