Jump to content

LOCK DeMeNTeD win


Carbon V3

Who has better card  

1 member has voted

  1. 1. Who has better card

    • DeMeNTeD
      17
    • Megadriver
      13


Recommended Posts

This is 1 on 1 contest and members are me and DeMeNTeD.Winner will get 3 reps.This contest is over 27.1.09. at 12.00 in London.

My card is:

195303jk9.jpg

Lore:

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by discarding 5 Fiend-Type monsters from your hand.When this card attacks, pay 1000 Life Points. This card cannot be targeted by Spell and Trap Cards. When this card attacks, your opponent cannot activate any Spell or Trap Cards. Once per turn, you can Special Summon 1 Fiend-Type monster from your Graveyard. This monster cannot be selected as an attack target from a Fiend-Type monster.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 56
  • Created
  • Last Reply

[align=center]>>>>Azrael, the Angelic Death<<<<

 

79521pu5.jpg[/align]

 

Effect:

This card can only be Summoned by removing from play 2 DARK monsters you control. This card is also treated as a Spellcaster-Type monster if it is targeted by a card effect controlled by your opponent. You can skip your Draw Phase and pay Life Points equal to the number of cards in your hand x 100 to add 1 Spell or Trap Card from your Deck to your hand. Your Deck is then shuffled. If this effect is negated by a card effect controlled by your opponent, you can destroy 1 face-up Effect Monster your opponent controls. If you do, this card cannot attack during your next Battle Phase.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Demented :

 

This card can only be Summoned by removing from play 2 DARK monsters you control. This card is also treated as a Spellcaster-Type monster if it is targeted by a card effect controlled by your opponent. You can skip your Draw Phase and pay Life Points equal to the number of cards in your hand x 100 to add 1 Spell or Trap Card from your Deck to your hand. Your Deck is then shuffled. If this effect is negated by a card effect controlled by your opponent, you can destroy 1 face-up Effect Monster your opponent controls. If you do, this card cannot attack during your next Battle Phase.

 

-it is really broken that u can add any Spell or Trap from your Deck to hand..summoning condition of this card is too easy..

-there is no way opponent can negate that effect..if he use Skill Drain for example he will negate other effects too...

 

Creativity : 5/10 (there is nothing special in this card except it add spells/traps from deck to hand (which is new) but it is new only because Konami didn't do it because it would be broken

Balance : 6/10 have some parts of effects that doesn't work, stuff that u need to wait for your Draw Phase to get Spells/Traps balance this card a lot..but still, with Solemns, stall etc..i don't like this card, it is too abusable...

Wording : neutral (i am not wording freak so both cards seems fine..i will edit this probably after i will talk with few wording medics)

 

TOTAL : 11/20

 

 

 

Megadriver

 

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by discarding 5 Fiend-Type monsters from your hand.When this card attacks, pay 1000 Life Points. This card cannot be targeted by Spell and Trap Cards. When this card attacks, your opponent cannot activate any Spell or Trap Cards. Once per turn, you can Special Summon 1 Fiend-Type monster from your Graveyard. This monster cannot be selected as an attack target from a Fiend-Type monster.

 

-really hard summoning condition oo ..but!! this is possible to do with Demon Roar Gods deck

-last effect is kinda pointless

 

Creativity : 8/10 Summoning condition is something new but still my creativity standards are really high so..this is what u get

Balance : 8/10hard summoning condition, but not bad card when it comes to field i guess..possible for OTK..but i doubt this card would work.so it is not overpowered but it is underpowered (that is why u lose points)

Wording : neutral (i am not wording freak so both cards seems fine..i will edit this probably after i will talk with few wording medics)

 

TOTAL : 16/20

 

Megadriver gets my vote... and this is totally honest i hope my comments prove it...

please people, don't vote for cards that was made by people that have high number of stars, more reps etc., that doesn't really matter and its frustrates other people..

Read cards carefully and judge honestly.

I wish u both luck..bye!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nightmarian, your comments suck, no offense. are you maybe friends or bribed?

 

DeMeNTeD, you get my vote.

Megadriver, your card is pretty much an overpowered beatstick. Yeah, it's hard to Summon, hmmmmm I know, I'll have only Fiends in my DECK!!! Then it'd be to easy... Overall-8/10 for trying

 

DeMeNTeD, your card has a great pic and holo, and it's NOT an OPd beatstick. Has a long, but not OPd effect. Overall: 9.6/10.........Yeah, no 10/10. I feel something missing. I dunno what lol.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Megadriver's pic made the card, the level, effect, name, and stats were a bit overboard though. The game isn't all about battle. A lesson great cardmakers must learn early on.

 

6.9/10

 

Demented had a decent card. Usual Demented with 1 effect and a bunch of ways to stop the card from being negated. No suprises. I can tell that Demented didn't go all out for this. He didn't have to.

 

8/10

 

DeMeNTeD.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nightmarian' date=' your comments suck, no offense. are you maybe friends or bribed?

 

DeMeNTeD, you get my vote.

Megadriver, your card is pretty much an overpowered beatstick. Yeah, it's hard to Summon, hmmmmm I know, I'll have only Fiends in my DECK!!! Then it'd be to easy... Overall-8/10 for trying

 

DeMeNTeD, your card has a great pic and holo, and it's NOT an OPd beatstick. Has a long, but not OPd effect. Overall: 9.6/10.........Yeah, no 10/10. I feel something missing. I dunno what lol.

 

I am not his frend..and please next time when u tell to someone that his comment sucks give him then explanation that beats his..

Only thing u told is that u don't know how to play Yugioh..do u play it irl??

His card is not overpowered, i don't know who would use it , ever :

1) u will probably never have 5 Fiends Type monsters in hand (u must have 6 actually)..u just cannot in competitive match save your hand so long + what is best stuff is that u will lose WHOLE HAND TO SUMMON THIS CARD so you will not have probably any other option to do ... opponent can get rid of this card with solemns,mirror etc..

It is really underpowered card, i would better use Raziel :/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nightmarian' date=' your comments suck, no offense. are you maybe friends or bribed?

 

DeMeNTeD, you get my vote.

Megadriver, your card is pretty much an overpowered beatstick. Yeah, it's hard to Summon, hmmmmm I know, I'll have only Fiends in my DECK!!! Then it'd be to easy... Overall-8/10 for trying

 

DeMeNTeD, your card has a great pic and holo, and it's NOT an OPd beatstick. Has a long, but not OPd effect. Overall: 9.6/10.........Yeah, no 10/10. I feel something missing. I dunno what lol.

 

I am not his frend..and please next time when u tell to someone that his comment sucks give him then explanation that beats his..

Only thing u told is that u don't know how to play Yugioh..do u play it irl??

His card is not overpowered, i don't know who would use it , ever :

1) u will probably never have 5 Fiends Type monsters in hand (u must have 6 actually)..u just cannot in competitive match save your hand so long + what is best stuff is that u will lose WHOLE HAND TO SUMMON THIS CARD so you will not have probably any other option to do ... opponent can get rid of this card with solemns,mirror etc..

It is really underpowered card, i would better use Raziel :/

 

So, so, negative reply, your treating me like dEMONIa treats n00bs. I do play Yu-Gi-Oh. His card, in MY OPINION, is an OPd beat stick.


No' date='DeMeNTeD has littel longer effect.

[/quote']

 

Hmm your right. I dislike 12 star monsters, as they don't even exist in real, other than the God Cards, which can't even be used, so in some wierd twisted way, yours actually is unrealistic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...