Jump to content

Rep Complaint Thread


Frunk

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 3.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

erm' date=' is this my 1st time here? XD

 

But, I got an neg rep from CardCapter saying: ''Curssing.I hate it when people do that and they dont censor it''

 

Funny thing is that, I haven't cursed on this site once..................

 

Please remove it

[/quote']

 

Tkill, can you do anything about my neg rep?

 

And can you say, is ''HELLZ'' considered as cursing?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

giving away pointless positives is rep spam. and that's against the rules. so all 3 of those -reps should be removed.

 

I agree 100%. I still need my poinless neg rep removed. YCM should make a reputation filter or something that would stop pointless reps. It would eliminate the need of this thread.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A: If you deleted the rep system= you wouldn't be able to tell if one is a good or bad member. The prizes in contests would be smaller. No one that is only a good member because of the system will be bad. Everyone will go crazy, leading to the ultimate destruction of the site.

 

B: If you didn't= rep scam, spam, abuse of the system, pointless reps, unneccesary revenge, and everyone will go crazy, leading to the ultimate destruction of the site.

 

I'm not sure which to vote for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A: If you deleted the rep system= you wouldn't be able to tell if one is a good or bad member.

 

While the rep system makes it easier to tell at first glance if someone is a good member' date=' it doesn't mean having a bunch of reps makes someone a good member. Look at all the pointless positives like "booster shot", "you need more reps", "canceling out the neg", etc.

 

The prizes in contests would be smaller. No one that is only a good member because of the system will be bad.

 

Last time I checked, being decent at card making doesn't make you good and nice member.

 

Everyone will go crazy, leading to the ultimate destruction of the site.

 

 

Sure it may take some getting used to, but the site won't die. There are plenty of good forums out there without a rep system.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was overeacting on the last one. Anyway, on the contest one, you can see the reason for the rep.

 

While the rep system makes it easier to tell at first glance if someone is a good member, it doesn't mean having a bunch of reps makes someone a good member. Look at all the pointless positives like "booster shot", "you need more reps", "canceling out the neg", etc.

 

Without the rep system, there wouldn't be any pointless reps. With the rep system, there would be pointless reps. This makes the rep system bad(#1). However, people who gained fame through bad thing #1 would be "uncovered" and could not be trusted(#2a). People who had negative reputation could actually be good people, but still couldn't be trusted (#2b). This continues in a infinite loop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I actually just remembered something. When I first became a member about 11 months ago, your reputation was shown with two numbers (positives and negs), not just both of them combined. So say you had 20 positives and 5 negs. It would come up as 20/5 instead of just 15. If that were to come back, that would be pretty cool. Then at least you can see how many positives and negs they have instead of just a sum of both of them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...