Jump to content

Aqua Girl vs Aqua Master!(Finnished

Aqua Girl

By Aqua Girl
in Finished Contests

Recommended Posts

Aqua Girl Newbie

Aqua Girl

Posted
Posted

Rules

 

1:Make a monster that has an effect that deals with with Black Rose Dragon.

 

2: When you vote give a reson, If your going to say the OCG is bad post the fix.(you can coppy someones post and use that If you find nothing else)

 

3: No spam/Flame.

 

4: The contest will begin when you PM me your card.(first to PM me gets the spot.)

 

5: The first to 5 wins Loser gives winner 2 +Reps

 

 

 

 

 

 

Aqua Master's Card.

297612.jpg

1 Plant Tuner monster + 1 or more non Tuner Plant monster

When this card is Synchro Summoned, destroy 1 monster your opponent controls. You can send this card to the Graveyard to Special Summon 1 "Black Rose Dragon from your Extra Deck in face-up attack position. If you do, "Black Rose Dragon" cannot attack this turn.

 

Aqua Girl's Card/

331987.jpg

You can remove from play 2 Plant-type monsters in your Graveyard to put 1 Rose Counter on this card (Max. 5). Once per turn you can remove 5 counters from this card to Special Summon 1 "Black Rose Dragon" from your Graveyard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
DL  Contributor

DL 

Posted
Posted

Aqua Master's effect has an OCG error, (which Kailyn pointed out) and another one (attack position = Attack Position)

Ultra Rose Demon makes Summoning synchroes even easier...

Aqua Girl's card balances out, since it's 2 plant type monsters from the graveyard, which just happens to be where Black Rose is summoned from due to GotBG's counter effect.

 

Aqua Girl gets my vote.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Shadow Zero Newbie

Shadow Zero

Posted
Posted

i vote aqua master for the following reasons.

 

1: even though his card has ocg errors, his effect makes it easier to summon BRD, meaning that it helps a lot with when you need to turn the duel around while using a plant type deck.

2: aqua girls card has you removing 2 plant type monsters from play in order to to put a counter on it and you need 5 counters to summon BRD from the grave. so basically you have to rfg 10 monsters for just 1 to return from the graveyard? i'm sorry, but that just sounds to up'd.

3: i can get why its rfg from the graveyard, but unless you can make a deck that can get monsters into the graveyard quickly for this effect to take place and still be able to have the deck do what it needs to do, it just won't work.

 

sorry aqua, but right now i just feel that voting for your card would be a biased vote.

 

so unless i am miscounting, my vote makes it 2-4 Aqua Girl, right?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nexev Newbie

Nexev

Posted
Posted

Sorry but gotta go with the MAster.

 

Though the monster should be called "Black Rose Impachi" It's effect seems more... Black Rosier.

 

Girl's card's effect only really works if the dragon died. Which isn't something you want. It seems a bit annoying to me. You need ten dead plants to revive one dead flower. It just seems like a bad choice. I'd rather just synchro summon a second copy.

 

Master's card doesn't have that problem, it is awesome on it's own but can also be usen as a shortcut to getting Black Rose out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Sploda Newbie

Sploda

Posted
Posted

Because nobody really likes plant decks.

 

Anyway I have to vote for Aqua here because it is much more balanced than a Summon and remove in the same turn summon of BRD.

That is just way OPed, whereas for Aqua you have to wait 5 turns (meaning keep the card in play) which balances out his effect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...