Jump to content

ISmesh Vs Yankee ~ iSmech Wins


Yankee

Vote for the winner!  

17 members have voted

  1. 1. iSmesh of Yankee



Recommended Posts

ISmesh has challenged me to a 1 on 1

 

The rules are simple,

 

1. Must be an effect monster

2. The ATK can be a minimum of 3000, and a maximum of 4000

3. The effect must have something to do with the graveyard

4. Only votes with clear detail as to why they are voting for who they are shall be counted. All spam votes, and others shall be deleted on the spot.

5. First to 5 votes wins

6. All other YCM rules apply

 

iSmesh:

221030n.jpg

 

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by removing 3 DARK monsters in your Graveyard from play. When this card is Summoned' date=' select 1 monster your opponent controls. Each time a DARK monster you control is sent to the Graveyard, place 1 Spell Counter on the selected monster. When the monster is destroyed, inflict damage to your opponent equal to the amount of Spell Counters on the monster x 300. You can then Special Summon 1 DARK monster from your Graveyard whose Level is equal to the Level of the monster destroyed by this card's effect.[/quote']

 

Yankee:

11496.jpg

 

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card cannot be Special Summoned except by having exactly 4 DARK monsters in your Graveyard. During battle between this attacking card and opponent's monster whose DEF lower than this cards ATK' date=' inflict the difference Battle Damage to your opponent. When this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle, you can send 1 DARK monster you control to the Graveyard OR remove 1 DARK monster in your Graveyard from play. If there are more than 4 DARK monsters in your Graveyard, this card cannot declare an attack. If there are less than 4 DARK monsters in your Graveyard, this card loses ATK equal to (4 - the number of DARK monsters in your Graveyard) x 1000. During your Standby Phase, remove 1 DARK monster in your Graveyard from play. If there are no DARK monsters in your Graveyard, this card is destroyed. [/quote']

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmmmm

Well i think iSmesh!'s card is Too easy to summon but Yankee's is too hard.(If your running them in dark decks of course) So they even out there

Both names are equally awsome...

I Like iSmesh!'s Picture a bit more

Both effects are intresting...

Im not sure about balance....

Hmmmm

Waka

Waka

Waka

......

iSmesh!

Both are good but his is a tad better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice matchup. ;D

 

Imo, Yankee has the better card. No mod bias or crap, I know both of you are great card makers. I don't feel like taking ocg into account at the moment, I'm pretty much considering the effects.

 

Smesh's looks a bit overpowered from my standpoint. With quite an easy summon, it wouldn't be hard to Special Summon a 4K beatstick, with no drawbacks except the removing from play of course, which can be turned into a situational advantage. Yankee's card asks for a specific number for the summoning making it much harder to summon.

 

In addition, Smesh has an extra summon effect + burn damage with the counters. Albeit the effect was creative, it seems a bit overpowered.

Yankee's from first glance imo, seemed a bit up'ed. With the summoning conditions, and drawbacks, it seemed worthy of a 1 turn attack, but that's just what I got from it. But still, it's drawbacks balanced a little bit more with the 4K atk. All my opinion/perspective though.

 

 

Tldr; Yankee gmv.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice matchup. ;D

 

Imo, Yankee has the better card. No mod bias or crap, I know both of you are great card makers. I don't feel like taking ocg into account at the moment, I'm pretty much considering the effects.

 

Smesh's looks a bit overpowered from my standpoint. With quite an easy summon, it wouldn't be hard to Special Summon a 4K beatstick, with no drawbacks except the removing from play of course, which can be turned into a situational advantage. Yankee's card asks for a specific number for the summoning making it much harder to summon.

 

In addition, Smesh has an extra summon effect + burn damage with the counters. Albeit the effect was creative, it seems a bit overpowered.

Yankee's from first glance imo, seemed a bit up'ed. With the summoning conditions, and drawbacks, it seemed worthy of a 1 turn attack, but that's just what I got from it. But still, it's drawbacks balanced a little bit more with the 4K atk. All my opinion/perspective though.

 

 

Tldr; Yankee gmv.

 

Understood. Thank you for voting. 2-1 Smesh

Link to comment
Share on other sites

iSmesh:

-Better Name

-Better Picture

-Easier to use

 

Yankee:

-Better Effect

-More balance

 

Both:

-Great OCG

-Good cards

 

---------------------------------------

 

It was a pretty hard choice but I'm gonna go with Yankee. His card was really creative. Smesh's card was creative too but I think that Yankee's card was hard to summon and the effect could help the card or pull the card down. Sorry iSmesh, but I really do like your card ^_^

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Both:

Great names

Great pics

Great OCG

Great effects

 

Smesh:

- more usable

its a bit op, not a whole lot of drawbacks, and making it a semi-nomi adds to it.

 

Yankee:

- more creative

its a bit up, good for 1 attack, hard summoning conditions, and even harder to maintain its strength. most other piercing monsters would work better than this one.

 

 

smesh gmv because of the usability

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Both:

Great names

Great pics

Great OCG

Great effects

 

Smesh:

- more usable

its a bit op, not a whole lot of drawbacks, and making it a semi-nomi adds to it.

 

Yankee:

- more creative

its a bit up, good for 1 attack, hard summoning conditions, and even harder to maintain its strength. most other piercing monsters would work better than this one.

 

 

smesh gmv because of the usability

 

You hit the nail on the head. This is exactly the reason why I was going to vote for Smesh, so there was no point repeating it. Smesh's card, while being slightly OP, it a lot more splashable and useable in the real game. Yankee's is like one of thsoe cards released in Secret Rare in a pack but nobody uses it because it just isn't useable enough. Smesh gets my vote.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So far, so good Smesh ;)

 

It's strange how nobody has taken into account that my 4k beater can inflict piercing damage...on an attack position monster.

So not only do you get normal battle damage, but you'd get exra.

So if it attacks BEWD, not only would the opponent lose 1000 for the normal battle damage, they would lose an extra 1500 because of piercing.

 

Is it worth the hard summoning conditions NOW? ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

¡Smesh!'s Effect:

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by removing 3 DARK monsters in your Graveyard from play. When this card is Summoned, select 1 monster your opponent controls. Each time a DARK monster you control is sent to the Graveyard, place 1 Spell Counter on the selected monster. When the monster is destroyed, inflict damage to your opponent equal to the amount of Spell Counters on the monster x 300. You can then Special Summon 1 DARK monster from your Graveyard whose Level is equal to the Level of the monster destroyed by this card's effect.

 

 

really I love DARK type **Both of you have one so bonus rate**, but that's not very valid. I like the way the effect uses both counters ands exceeds the standards of this 1v1 and the OCG seems very spot on with IMO, a very nice effect.

 

Rating: 9.6/10 ::RATING WILL DETERMINE WHO GETS MY VOTE::

 

 

 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

 

Yankee's Effect:

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card cannot be Special Summoned except by having exactly 4 DARK monsters in your Graveyard. During battle between this attacking card and opponent's monster whose DEF lower than this cards ATK, inflict the difference Battle Damage to your opponent. When this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle, you can send 1 DARK monster you control to the Graveyard OR remove 1 DARK monster in your Graveyard from play. If there are more than 4 DARK monsters in your Graveyard, this card cannot declare an attack. If there are less than 4 DARK monsters in your Graveyard, this card loses ATK equal to (4 - the number of DARK monsters in your Graveyard) x 1000. During your Standby Phase, remove 1 DARK monster in your Graveyard from play. If there are no DARK monsters in your Graveyard, this card is destroyed.

 

The effect seems balanced, and I don't see any errors on the OCG, but some flaws that IMO, don't like about it and still a close call for the image **It's blurry a bit**. Still a great job from both of you and my rating for Yankee is:

 

9.7/10

 

A very close call, but Yankee is just more of the vote taker. Good job Yankee!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I gave constructive criticism on both cards, explaining the problems. Apparently, trying to help both members improve and ending with a joke is worth a post delete.

 

Luckily, I predicted that your blimp-ego would delete it and saved my post, so I'll follow Josh's advice and post an edited version that fits your horrible requirements.

 

Vote:

-------------

 

Both are 4K beatsticks for nearly no cost and no serious drawback on either (come on, DARKs control the Graveyard like media controls people's world views).

 

Really, I don't think I can consider either balanced. iSmesh's doesn't actually work, since the effect doesn't destroy anything so the last effect won't trigger, but I'll assume it's the selected monster. 4000 ATK beatstick with burn and then another positive effect is just making the game bad with more OTKs. Yankee's also hurts the game by letting you throw a 4000 beatstick out and not even hurting your setup, so you could throw 3 out at once if you'd luck-drawn into that kinda of setup - and the card is largely about luck. Too early or late in the game and it ruins you, right time and it's just silly.

 

One promotes silly OTKs. The other promotes luck. Neither is good for the game and neither should ever be printed. I would prefer to vote for a nothing than either because they're terrible, but I'll vote for iSmesh because it's less likely to OTK without having an effect to inflict ~4000 damage most of the time even when attacking a monster and you can't drop all of them from your hand at once.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...