An Immortal Xyz, Take 2 (Xyz Daily) (Day 22)

[宇佐見 蓮子@C94]

Yes, it's the start of the third week of Xyz Daily! *confetti+fireworks* And today I'll have a throw-back at the idea of an Immortal Xyz, which I first made during the end of the "Zero" week of Xyz Daily. (Zero Week refers to the first 7 cards in the Xyz Daily series, they are pretty broken IIRC.)

[img]http://i46.tinypic.com/2w3t1rd.jpg[/img]

[spoiler=Get a free Apple iPad! ...Not really, this is just the effect.]

2 Level 4 Effect Monsters

When this card leaves the field by your opponent card's effect or by battle: you can Special Summon it from your Graveyard during your next Standby Phase. Once per turn, you can target 1 Monster you control; attach it to this card as Xyz Material. You can detach 1 Xyz Material from this card to place 1 Phoenix Counter on a card on the field. When this card is Special Summoned by it's own effect, return all cards on the field with a Phoenix Counter on it to the owner's deck.
[/spoiler]

So, rate, fix if broken and CnC is always welcome.

EDIT: I figured the effect is broken 5 minutes after release... Fixed.

[Nathanael D. Striker]

[i]2 Level 4 Effect Monsters

When this card leaves the field: You can Special Summon it from your Graveyard during your next Standby Phase. Once per turn: You can target 1 monster you control; attach it to this card as Xyz Material. You can detach 1 Xyz Material from this card; place 1 Phoenix Counter on a card on the field. When this card is Special Summoned by it's own effect: Return all cards on the field with a Phoenix Counter on it to their owner's Deck.[/i]

OK then, I have some problems with this. Constant Tribute Fooder. It's Phoenix Counters make that even more powerful, but limited by your ability to produce Xyz Materials. I'd be concerned about this card.

[Aerion Brightflame]

Yeah... It's a monarchs dream. Better than Treeborn, since it doesn't care about getting banished or spells and traps. And it can beat down things. I would change it to be rank 6. So it is a monarchs deck card, and justifies the effect more so. I would have it when it leaves the field as a result of your opponents card. That way its not dark hole, monarch, and most other things abusable.

[Barian Warlord]

I agree that making it rank 6 would balance it out otherwise you get an immortal monster that can continuously return your opponent's monsters to their deck and is super easy to get out, maybe limit it so that it can only special summon itself if it had at least 1 Xyz when it gets taken out that way you need to be more careful when using it.