X-31 Fighter vs. Fayaz Rahaman!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[.Requiem]

X-31 Fighter VS. Fayaz Rahaman

 

This is a 1 on. 1 contest which will determine the better card maker here. It is Fayaz Rahaman and I in this one on one. please use the judging rubric when judging.

 

Prizes: The Winner Gets three rep from the Loser.

 

[align=center][spoiler=Rubric]

OCG 0/10

Picture 0/5

Balanced 0/10

Creativity 0/5

 

[/align]

 

[align=center][spoiler=X-31 Fighter Card]

 

[spoiler=Card Lore]

When this card is Special Summoned to your field in face-up Attack Position, you can discard 2 cards from your hand to your Graveyard and send this card to your opponent's side of the field in face-up Attack Position. This card cannot be Released to Advance Summon any Monster level 6 or higher. Send this card to the Graveyard during the End Phase of the turn it is Summoned and deal 1000 damage to the owner of this card.

 

 

 

[/align]

 

[align=center][spoiler=Fayaz Rahaman Card]

 

[spoiler=Card Lore]

If this card is Special Summoned, you can pay 1000 Life Points to destroy all cards on your opponents side of the field. This card cannot attack if you control any other cards. You can remove this face-up card from play to Special Summon 3 cards that include "Demon" in its card name from either players Graveyard.

 

 

 

[/align]

[Fizzy™]

You forgot to put up a poll.

Could you put one up please to keep track of how many votes we have.

Thanks.

[.Requiem]

There is a poll.

[Fizzy™]

Oh and I am going on holidays from this monday so this has to end tomorrow.

I cannot give out reps if you win until I return on the 11th of January.

Give me a reminder PM of the result when I return.

[.Requiem]

You don't have to give me rep only if you lose.

[Fizzy™]

There is a poll.

Oh sorry I didn't see it.

[.Requiem]

We need people to rate our cards.

[iKiller]

I have.

The Weeping Fairy has some OCG errors, but is also more realistic. Simple as.

[.Requiem]

Can you use the rubric.

 

Also what OCG errors?

[master2]

We need people to rate our cards.

OK then I will.:)

 

X-31 Fighter:

OCG 7/10

Picture 3/5

Balanced 10/10

Creativity 5/5

Total = 25/30

 

Fayaz Rahaman:

OCG = 10/10

Picture = 4/5

Balanced = 8/10

Creativity = 4/5

Total = 26/30

I like the second card(Fayaz's) better.

I also agree with KillerxKid that X-31 Fighter's card may have won If there was a realisticness on the rubic.

<<< !!!!!!!!! Anyway Fayaz Rahaman wins !!!!!!!!! >>>

[.Requiem]

Master2

What is wrong with my OCG it is using the new OCG.

Fayan is using a lot of the old OCG

[K.B. strategist]

Going to be harsher in ratings...

 

X-31 Fighter

 

OCG 8/10

Picture 4.5/5

Balanced 6.5/10

Creativity 5/5

Total: 25/30

 

A few minor ocg problems that brought your mark down, and your card was also quite a bit underpowered.

 

Fayaz Rahaman

 

OCG 9.5/10

Picture 3.5/5

Balanced 4/10

Creativity 4/5

Total: 21/30

 

The balance issue killed you. It's a 1 card OTK.

 

X-31 Fighter wins.

[.Requiem]

Can people when they post please leave what OCG errors. I don't see any?

[K.B. strategist]

"send this card to your opponent's side of the field" is not right.

Monster = monster

Level

inflict, not deal.

[.Requiem]

No you got it wrong

monster=Monster

 

I did notice those, but it would be cheating if I post the fixes so.

 

Use this to check OCG

http://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/thread-51154.html

[K.B. strategist]

No, Monster Card takes caps. Just monster does not. That's 1 of the tricky rules of ocg.

[.Requiem]

Whatever does anyone else want to rate.

[Fizzy™]

K.B. strategist

What do you mean by the balance killed me?

My card is balanced enough.

It's ATK may be strong but it cant attack if you control any other cards at all.

So in order for it to attack you can't have anything on your field, not even vital spells or traps.

It's second effect only applys if you or your opponent is using "Demon" cards.

I'ts a strategy type card I created for my Demon deck and can only be very powerful if it is used in the right way.

But this is a 1 on 1 with only one card so it can't be that strong on it's own.

That is why I think my card is perfectly balenced for this 1 on 1.

[K.B. strategist]

Special Summon it through any of the countless cards that let you. Destroy all cards your opponent controls. Remove it from play to Special Summon 3 Demon monsters. Attack for win.

[Sleepy]

X-31 fighter

 

OCG:8/10

change this card to your oponent's side of the field = give control of this card to your oponent

..............deal = inflict .............(I think ^-^" ).

Pic:4/5

its good :)

Balance: 9/10

I think discarting 2 cards it kinda too much....you can basically attack..give it to your oponent and then its destroyed and he takes 1000 ...its good but I don't think good enough for 2 cards...maybe 1...

Creativity:5/5

overall: 26/30

 

Fayaz Rahaman

 

OCG:8/10

don't mind me but you kinda mixed old OCG with new OCG ^-^"

on your opponents side of the field. = old OCG in your card.for new = on your oponent's control

This card cannot attack if you control any other cards = new OCG in your card. for new =

This card cannot attack if you have any other card(s) on your side of the field (I think ^-^")

 

Pic:3/5

I can see the picture in the card of you oponent a little more clear.. and you don't have a background. its only black with the holo effect of the card making it less.... black....

and to be honest I don't like too much the image itself ^-^" sorry...

 

Balance:1/10

so you can Special Summon it and pay 1000 Life Points to destroy your oponent's field ONLY.

if it's destroyed you will be able to Special Summon 2 copies of the same monster from your Graveyard. or even other powerful monsters I know nothing about :(....the drawback is not enough

and I almost forgot to say that 2600 ATK for a Level 6 is kinda pushing the limits of a Level 6, just 100 more and you would have to make it a Level 7. + having a REALLY strong effect like this ...........

 

Creativity:4/5

somewhat creative :) overpowered but creative.

 

Overall:16/30

sorry, i didn't meant it to be so low :s

 

X-31 fighter wins according to me

[Death Bishop]

X31 Fighter > Fahaz Rahaman. X31 Fighter gets my vote! :P

[.Requiem]

Your an Elite Member and you can't give a good rating?

[Death Bishop]

Your an Elite Member and you can't give a good rating?

What?

[.Requiem]

Can you give a rating on the rubric above.

[Death Bishop]

Yes I just saw. Sorry Z-31 Fighter. Please forgive me.

FAHAZ RAHAMEN:

OCG = 7/10

Picture = 8.8/10

Balanced = 6.8/10

Creativity = 7.6/10

 

X=31 FIGHTER:

OCG = 9/10

Picture = 101/10

Balanced = 8.6/10

Creativity = 9.1/10