Jump to content

Primal Release vs DeViLQ8


Monkey

Whose is better?  

1 member has voted

  1. 1. Whose is better?

    • Primal Release
      14
    • DeViLQ8
      5


Recommended Posts

Terms:

1. No DARK Monsters

2. Must be an underused Type

 

Prize:

3 reps to winner

 

Polls close in 2 days from the time of this post

 

[align=center]

[spoiler=Primal Release's Card]

2cf86kk.jpg

When this card is destroyed by battle, you can place this card face-down in your opponent's Spell & Trap Card Zone as a Continuous Trap Card instead of sending it to the Graveyard. After 3 Standby Phases, force the activation of this card. As long as this card remains face-up on the field, all monsters on your opponent's field are treated as Aqua-Type WATER monsters. Decrease the ATK of all monsters on your opponent's field by 200 points. Once per turn, during your Standby Phase, place the top card of your opponent's Deck to the bottom of his/her Deck and place 1 Level 3 monster on the top of your Deck. Once per turn, during your opponent's Standby Phase, randomly select 1 card in your opponent's Deck and switch it with a card in your opponent's hand. When this card is removed from the field while it is a Continuous Trap Card, switch the Battle Position of all monsters on your opponent's field.

 

 

[spoiler=DeViLQ8's Card]

190835ek3.jpg

 

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by Tributing 4 monsters you control. This card cannot attack. This card is unaffected by Card effects. Monsters with lower ATK than this card are not destroyed by battle when attacking this card (damage calculation is applied normally). Each time this card is attacked, decrease its ATK by 500 and Special Summon 1 "Organic Beast Token" (Fiend-Type/ EARTH/ Level 1/ ATK 500/ DEF 0) to your field. You can Tribute 3 "Organic Beast Tokens" to increase the ATK of this card by 2000. When this card is destroyed, remove it from play.

[/align]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

PR:

All monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK.

Once per turn, during your opponent's Standby Phase, randomly select 1 card in your opponent's Deck and switch it with a card in your opponent's hand - which card? You must state whether it is randomly selected or...

 

My opinion: You overdid it, dude! There is no such card that has this many effects! Even the most powerful REAL Yu - Gi - Oh cards have 2, max. 3 effects. It looks like you wanted it to be original, but this is just too much for a Level 3 monster.

 

 

Q8:

This card is unaffected by card effects.

Any monster battling this card isn't destroyed by battle (damage calculation is applied normally).

 

My opinion: Well... Sure it has 4000 ATK, but it needs to be Tributed for 4 monsters. Let's see - it can't attack, but it's not affected by card effects. Monsters that attack it aren't destroyed if their ATK is less than 4000 - are they destroyed if their ATK is 4100? So, it's just enough to say that any monster battling this card isn't destroyed - just to make it simple, although you didn't really make a mistake. When it's attacked, it loses 500 ATK and Sp. Summons a 500 ATK / 0 DEF Token that your opponent can easily destroy. So, this card isn't OP - ed, it is just a temporal wall, defense...

 

I don't like the pictures you two have chosen, but I guess Q8 has a better holo.

ID's of both cards could be better.

 

I'll vote for Demon Q8.

@ Demented: OCG mistakes : 2 - 2

Link to comment
Share on other sites

PR:

All monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK.

Once per turn' date=' during your opponent's Standby Phase, randomly select 1 card in your opponent's Deck and switch it with a card in your opponent's hand - which card? You must state whether it is randomly selected or...

 

Q8:

This card is unaffected by card effects.

A[b']ll[/b] monsters that battle with this card are not destroyed by battle

(Damage Calculation is applied normally).

attacked = selected as an attack target

 

OCG mistakes : 2 - 7 --> In favor of Primal Release

 

Fixed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

PR:

All monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK.

Once per turn' date=' during your opponent's Standby Phase, randomly select 1 card in your opponent's Deck and switch it with a card in your opponent's hand - which card? You must state whether it is randomly selected or...

 

Q8:

This card is unaffected by card effects.

A[b']ll[/b] monsters that battle with this card are not destroyed by battle

(Damage Calculation is applied normally).

attacked = selected as an attack target

 

OCG mistakes : 2 - 7 --> In favor of Primal Release

 

Fixed.

 

Damage Calculation = damage calculation

attacked is diffrenet than selected as an attack target, attacked means after damage calculation, selected as attack target is before damage calculation. the effect is activated after the card is attacked, If I wrote selected as attack target then the effect will activate before the opponent complete his attack, It will summon the organic beast, which means the opponent must cancel the attack and select the attack target once again. << Correct me if Im wrong <,<

Link to comment
Share on other sites

PR:

All monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK.

Once per turn' date=' during your opponent's Standby Phase, randomly select 1 card in your opponent's Deck and switch it with a card in your opponent's hand - which card? You must state whether it is randomly selected or...

 

Q8:

This card is unaffected by card effects.

A[b']ll[/b] monsters that battle with this card are not destroyed by battle

(Damage Calculation is applied normally).

attacked = selected as an attack target

 

OCG mistakes : 2 - 7 --> In favor of Primal Release

 

Fixed.

 

Damage Calculation = damage calculation

attacked is diffrenet than selected as an attack target, attacked means after damage calculation, selected as attack target is before damage calculation. the effect is activated after the card is attacked, If I wrote selected as attack target then the effect will activate before the opponent complete his attack, It will summon the organic beast, which means the opponent must cancel the attack and select the attack target once again. << Correct me if Im wrong <,<

 

sorry DeMeNTeD but I have to say that's true, and attacked is not incorrrect

look for ANY gladiador beasts and you'll see everyone of them says "attacked"

^-^"

as for the cards.. I haven't actually seen the cards but I've seen the corrections and comments of everyone so... I already recognise 1 of the cards that I've seen before in other section ^-^ and read the other one..so .. I'll vote in a second

Link to comment
Share on other sites

PR:

All monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK.

Once per turn' date=' during your opponent's Standby Phase, randomly select 1 card in your opponent's Deck and switch it with a card in your opponent's hand - which card? You must state whether it is randomly selected or...

 

Q8:

This card is unaffected by card effects.

A[b']ll[/b] monsters that battle with this card are not destroyed by battle

(Damage Calculation is applied normally).

attacked = selected as an attack target

 

OCG mistakes : 2 - 7 --> In favor of Primal Release

 

Fixed.

 

Damage Calculation = damage calculation

attacked is diffrenet than selected as an attack target, attacked means after damage calculation, selected as attack target is before damage calculation. the effect is activated after the card is attacked, If I wrote selected as attack target then the effect will activate before the opponent complete his attack, It will summon the organic beast, which means the opponent must cancel the attack and select the attack target once again. << Correct me if Im wrong <,<

 

sorry DeMeNTeD but I have to say that's true, and attacked is not incorrrect

look for ANY gladiador beasts and you'll see everyone of them says "attacked"

^-^"

as for the cards.. I haven't actually seen the cards but I've seen the corrections and comments of everyone so... I already recognise 1 of the cards that I've seen before in other section ^-^ and read the other one..so .. I'll vote in a second

 

Whose card have you seen before? Who did you vote for?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sorry for the bother... here is my rate of the cards and my vote (note that I'm writing all I see regardless of if its already been commented or not in previews comments):

 

[spoiler=[b]Primal Release:[/b]]

-name is good

-Level is fine

-combination of gold stiker with Limited Edition circulation, good!

-Type, ATK & DEF: good!

-pic= awesome and you have the pic and name rendered .... another good point

-OCG, comments & suggestions (the good part):

 

When this card is destroyed by battle, you can place this card face-down in your opponent's Spell & Trap Card Zone as a Continuous Trap Card instead of sending it to the Graveyard. After 3 Standby Phases, force the activation of this card. As long as this card remains face-up on the field, all monsters on your opponent's field are treated as Aqua-Type WATER monsters. Decrease the ATK of all monsters on your opponent's field by 200 points. Once per turn, during your Standby Phase, place the top card of your opponent's Deck to the bottom of his/her Deck and place 1 Level 3 monster on the top of your Deck. Once per turn, during your opponent's Standby Phase, randomly select 1 card in your opponent's Deck and switch it with a card in your opponent's hand. When this card is removed from the field while it is a Continuous Trap Card, switch the Battle Position of all monsters on your opponent's field.

 

the underlined part:

All monster on your opponent's field become Aqua-Type WATER monsters and loose 200 ATK. (this would take less space and acording to my reference of "zombie world" in wikia, is correct OCG. also, I think 3 turns is too weak for this effect, it already has the thing that it has to be face down for an entire turn first for being a trap, and I believe that's enough.)

 

black section:

(I can't find much use in this effect. is most likely using extra space on the card, sorry)

 

Italic section:

(I can't see anything wrong with this part ;) )

 

this is a 9/10 card for me :D

 

 

[spoiler=[b]DeVil Q8:[/b]]

-name, good

-Level, good

-Type, ATK & DEF, good!

-pic= great and also holoed :D

-OCG, comments & suggestions:

This is the card I've seen before (realistic section), and I can't say I see anything wrong with it in the description since it has the "This card can only be Special Summoned by" part, that means it can be Special Summoned with monster reborn and other things if it was summoned properly first, it's a temporal shield that is very effective. not anyone can destroy this card by battle but I didn't noticed before that it could be destroyed that way.

I would first suggest 2 tokens instead of 3 but that would make it overpowered. so.. It's okay for me :)

 

this card gets a 9/10 from me too... (what can I say? both are good,)

 

 

[spoiler=[b] my vote:[/b]]

I see both cards as equals so, I'll just vote for the one with fewer votes to even it a little.

 

I vote for DeVil Q8. sorry Primal Release ^-^"

 

 

hope I didn't do anything wrong in this comment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...