Jump to content

Prove to me that Magical Scientist should be banned.


Recommended Posts

Guest PikaPerson01

As a Dark, Level 1 300 attack 300 defense spellcasters, he's got a plethora of means of special summoning.

 

Limit Reverse, Graceful Revival, Apprentice Magician and Mystic Tomato, and with a lot more set-up, Escape From the Dark Dimension and if you REALLY wanna get picky about it, Magician's Circle and Magical Dimension, but the last 3 would probably not see much play, Nevertheless, it illistrates that bringing this card onto the field does not have to come at the cost of a normal summon.

 

However merely being having the above does not a banworthy card make. The key part rests entirely in this dude's effect. Turning your entire Extra Deck (or parts of it, if you still wanna run Synchros) into a toolbox where every single piece can come out at any number until you get bored of it.

 

tl;dr version: Book of Eclipse

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I think Magical Scientist isn't ban worthy. The reasons is that its weak and will usually get pummeled after the turn its summoned for its effect. Not only that, but alot of those combo's that involve him that are "cheap" usually have other cards that should be banned. I think it should be limited, but thats only me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't believe that versatility IS a crime.

I believe that when a card steps beyong versatility and becomes overpowered and able to OTK with multiple different card combinations easily' date=' that is when the card should be banned, as is the case with Magical Scientist.

[/quote']

 

Magical Scientist's only notable OTK has been with Catapult Turtle.

 

This card can be a quick Synchro.

Bad.

 

Until they make low-level Fusion Monsters that are also Tuners' date=' this card can only generate Synchro Monsters if you can Summon both this and a Tuner. A Synchro Summon that relies on independently Summoning a non-Tuner and a Tuner is hardly irregular.

[/quote']

Double Summon+This+Any Level 6 or lower Fusion Monster+Tuner

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't believe that versatility IS a crime.

I believe that when a card steps beyong versatility and becomes overpowered and able to OTK with multiple different card combinations easily' date=' that is when the card should be banned, as is the case with Magical Scientist.

[/quote']

 

Magical Scientist's only notable OTK has been with Catapult Turtle.

 

This card can be a quick Synchro.

Bad.

 

Until they make low-level Fusion Monsters that are also Tuners' date=' this card can only generate Synchro Monsters if you can Summon both this and a Tuner. A Synchro Summon that relies on independently Summoning a non-Tuner and a Tuner is hardly irregular.

[/quote']

Double Summon+This+Any Level 6 or lower Fusion Monster+Tuner

 

Double Summon + Tuner + non-Tuner = Synchro Monster regardless of whether you use Magical Scientist or Gene-Warped Warwolf. In fact, that's not even an efficient way of Synchro Summoning; it would be cheaper just to use something like Vice Dragon or Instant Fusion alongside a Tuner, thus preventing you from needing a Double Summon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest PikaPerson01

Magical Scientist+Emergency Teleport=Stardust Dragon' date=' amirite?

[/quote']

 

Summon Priest + (Any Spell Card and a level 4 Tuner in Deck) = Stardust Dragon, amirite?

 

Fusilier Dragon the Dual Mode Beast + Emergency Teleport (With Mind Master) = Stardust Dragon, amirite?

 

Big Piece Golem + Emergeny Teleport (With Psychic Commander) = Stardust Dragon, amirite?

 

Cyber Dragon + Emergency Teleport = Stardust Dragon, amirite?

 

Vice Dragon + Emergency Teleport = Stardust Dragon, amirite?

 

Malicious in Grave + Plaguespreader Zombie = Stardust Dragon, amirite?

 

Alien-Monite (with a Level 4 in grave) (Synchro for any random level 5) + Emergency Teleport = Stardust Dragon, amirite?

 

(Use a card like Monster Reborn to special summon) Black Wing - Blizzard of the North Pole + Black Wing - Elfen of the Pitch Black = Stardust Dragon, amirite?

 

And on and on and on and on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest PikaPerson01

- Emergency Teleport

 

+ Monster Reborn (with whatever level tuner you happen to need in either you or your opponent's graveyard)

 

= Stardust Dragon, amirite?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You only lose 1 card and 1000LP with scientist and he gives you the option of brigning out any synchro (provided you have the proper tuner for it). It's far better than Instant Fusion and all of the example given by PikaPerson01.

 

Some people seem to think cheap synchro is okay for the game. It would be if you would bring out crap like gaia knight or natural gaodrake but when you have access to stardust dragon and brionac, dragon of the ice boundary it starts to be a big problem.

 

And also DARK STRIKE FIGHTER (who should definatly be ban but we should talk about him in another topic)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest PikaPerson01

You only lose 1 card and 1000LP with scientist and he gives you the option of brigning out any synchro (provided you have the proper tuner for it). It's far better than Instant Fusion and all of the example given by PikaPerson01.

 

Summon Priest, Rescue Cat and Malicious + E-Tele/Plaguespreader Zombie are all better ways to Synchro then what you just said, and don't have a detriment of filling your extra deck with unusable cards.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You only lose 1 card and 1000LP with scientist and he gives you the option of brigning out any synchro (provided you have the proper tuner for it). It's far better than Instant Fusion and all of the example given by PikaPerson01.

 

Summon Priest' date=' Rescue Cat and Malicious + E-Tele/Plaguespreader Zombie are all better ways to Synchro then what you just said, and don't have a detriment of filling your extra deck with unusable cards.

[/quote']

 

They aren't better ways while scientist requires some extra deck space summon priest and rescue cat require deck space with crappy beast type monsters. And if you use priest/cat you are using OCG cards and have access to dark dive bomber and scientist is an FTK with that (FTK > not FTK). Without him summon priest still uses a spell and is limited to lv 4 to 7 synchro while scientist can even bring out the lv9. They are all very good ways to synchro and depending on your strategy you can adjust your extra deck. Malicious is another thing though I would run him with scientist, malicious is probably the best way to synchro.

 

Extra deck for scientist would look like one of those 2 :

 

FTK

2 dark dive bomber

2 fusions for DDB

11 fusions to FTK

(mabe cut some cards for black rose and stardust)

 

All around

1 red dragon archfiend

1 colossal fighter

1 thought ruler archfiend

1 stardust dragon

1 dark end dragon

1 black rose dragon

1 dark dive bomber

1 goyo guardian

1 brionac

2 ryu senshi

2 dark balter the terrible

1 dark fire dragon

1 flame ghost

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...