Jump to content

Pokevolution Contest 2 *Become Part Of History* - NO MORE ENTRIES


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 98
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Okay, here we go the voting for Pokevolution's 2nd Contest has now begun, James shall be assisting me with the prizes for this contest.

 

Windfang

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 28/45

 

The only thing I'll add is that if Salamence had a no-op monsters equal no attack for Salamence, then it would be perfect.

 

middletond

Card Name 1/5

Card Uniqueness 8/10

Card OCG 3.5/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 29.5/45

 

I really did like these, problem was Omastar's effect had some major OCG issues regarding certain effects, such as the flipping over effect.

 

.:True Destiny:.

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 5/10

Card OCG 2.5/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 23.5/45

 

I have to say I'm sorry but the cards were quite OP'd ATK/DEF wise to be honest, x.x

 

gustavosuarez

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 6/10

Card OCG 2.5/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 26.5/45

 

Point to this is, there was some major OCG issues, and the effects were seemingly a bit too much.

 

|Lost Reptilian Soul|

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 8/10

Total 31/45

 

These care were great, but the whole Ekans can inflict more damamge than an Arbok confused me.

 

Random King

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 29/45

 

Really did like these cards RK, but there was something I couldn't put my finger on.

 

Corporal Atlas

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 30/45

 

Problem here is simple, the effects and everything are great but due to the low levels it makes the effects OP'd.

 

LostLetter227

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 9/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 8/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 34/45

 

Absolutely excellent cards, no wonder I had my eye on you. The usability though was quite bad considering, mainly with Noctowl easily gaining ATK, and Itemfinder allowing you to gain one of your opponent's cards.

 

Elemental user W

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 4/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 8/10

Total 27/45

 

The usability and OCG were outstanding, however the real issue with these was the blandness(sp?) of these cards as a whole.

 

Marly

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 6/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 3.5/5

Card Usage 4/10

Total 24.5/45

 

A little dissappointed here Marly, the effects were somewhat OP'd on Slowpoke, and Slowbro's effect literally makes it's DEF 2100 and it's ATK overpoweringly high.

 

rodri666

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 6/10

Card OCG 2.5/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 23.5/45

 

Card usage here is a lil on the low side, there were a few OCG errors still in the cards amongst other things.

 

Griffinsusername™

Card Name 3/5

Card Uniqueness 8/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 4.5/5

Card Usage 5.5/10

Total 31/45

 

Some superb cards and a lil image bonus because of the spell card, however my problem was with the OCG not being completely PKEV style, and maybe a tiny bit overpowered on Venasaur.

 

Assegai

Card Name 3/5

Card Uniqueness 6/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 3.5/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 27.5/45

 

My problems were with the effects and ATK/DEF not matching the LV powering, but otherwise good cards.

 

HoboJoe

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 6/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 2/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 26/45

 

The effects seemed a little bland to be honest, and Luxray seemed a lil overpowering as well.

 

Lord_Charmander

Card Name 3.5/5

Card Uniqueness 8/10

Card OCG 3.5/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 5/5

Card Usage 7/10

Total 34/45

 

Excellent cards as always, the effects are excellent but OCG needs some work in some places.

 

jacoby746

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 4/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 4/10

Card Image 2/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 21/45

 

An okay attempt, but there was major issues all over except with the usage, but the other things brought that down.

 

sasukechidori58

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 8/10

Card OCG 3.5/5

Card Effect 8/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 7/10

Total 34.5/45

 

Some good cards overall as well as being very balanced, some tiny little OCG errors but nothing to worry about.

 

Overall some pretty decent entries, I think we may extend the acceptance into PKEV to more than just first place due to some people getting very close totals, but it's all up to what James, Crystal, and Hunter are happy with.

 

Sushi's 1st Place Vote: SasukeChidori58

Sushi's 2nd Place Vote: LostLetter227, Lord Charmander

Sushi's 3rd Place Vote: Griffinsusername, |Lost Reptilian Soul|

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...