Jump to content

Black-Winged Dragon [The argument]


Recommended Posts

[quote name='The blazing MARS' timestamp='1307916784' post='5278541']
YES. This should have been the 5th signer dragon... but who would be the signer for it?
[/quote]
[s]Me...duh[/s]
not Sorw...that's for sure.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 54
  • Created
  • Last Reply
[quote name='The blazing MARS' timestamp='1307916784' post='5278541']
YES. This should have been the 5th signer dragon... but who would be the signer for it?
[/quote]
That's my point. They would've had to introduce a new kickass character. [size="1"]Or give it to Kiryu for lulz[/size]
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='sleepy' timestamp='1307916119' post='5278506']
There is a Signer Dragon for each Attribute except for WATER. This not only breaks the 5-Dragons rule that made the name of the series, but it also unnecessarily repeats DARK, already taken by Red Dragon Archfiend.
[/quote]

[img]http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110416062732/yugioh/images/d/dc/No17ReviseDragonGENF-JP-UR.jpg[/img]

Should've been this. And seeing Shark on a D-Wheel (?) makes me wonder how awesome 5Ds would've been if Shark replaced Crow.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Legend Zero' timestamp='1307917018' post='5278550']
That's my point. They would've had to introduce a new kickass character. [size="1"]Or give it to Kiryu for lulz[/size]
[/quote]

YES!
The only member of Team Satisfaction that did not receive a Signer Dragon. Also, the former leader, so it should have the best Dragon especially made for him + 3 Trishulas instead. =P
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='The Despair Uranus' timestamp='1307919209' post='5278655']
[img]http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_jalnyM25gq0/TKyyaieRSSI/AAAAAAAADqk/cfNzssXVhsc/s1600/Kiryu+is+owning+Yusei.jpg[/img]
[/quote]

if Trishula is a Signer dragon and Kiryu is a Signer he will play it far too well :), it would be cool if he can wield 3 of Trishula it's like facing 3 BEUD <3 9 heads is better than 3 lol

if he wasn't limited then it's be cool

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='sleepy' timestamp='1307916119' post='5278506']
There is a Signer Dragon for each Attribute except for WATER. This not only breaks the 5-Dragons rule that made the name of the series, but it also unnecessarily repeats DARK, already taken by Red Dragon Archfiend.
[/quote]

Better idea:
RDA ---> Fire (Burning Soul)
Black Rose ---> Water (plants)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='demonelfxx' timestamp='1307930603' post='5279100']
so much hostility against a card. i personally like the card and i think it is a good asset to my deck. :)
[/quote]

Well, here's the thing: It's not so much that Blackfeather's the worst card to ever exist. Its problem is it has only 1 application: Anti-Burn. This effect carries the risk of lowering its own ATK, bringing its respectable 2800 down to a paltry 2100, 1400, 700, or 0, depending how many counters it gets.

Problem 2: Burn is very rarely played in the metagame, meaning its effect will almost never be used.

Problem 3: It's a level 8 generic Dragon Synchro. But so is Stardust. So is RDA. So is Scrap Dragon. Other level 8 generics include Colossal Fighter and Thought Ruler Archfiend, both of which are much better.

So, it's a subpar card in a game where Extra Deck space is limited to the best cards. Blackfeather doesn't make the cut.

Oh, and people think it's evidence that Crow (a character with a sizeable hatedom) was forcing his way unneeded into the show/main cast by retconning that Blackfeather is a Signer Dragon. Even Rua ended up getting a previously established Signer Dragon even though he wasn't originally a Signer. So Blackfeather Dragon is a weak card, with a BS plot status thrown onto it, for a character who didn't need it (HE RAN BLACKWINGS!), in a game with limited space already consumed by similar cards that have much more application.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='evilfusion' timestamp='1307931077' post='5279122']
Well, here's the thing: It's not so much that Blackfeather's the worst card to ever exist. Its problem is it has only 1 application: Anti-Burn. This effect carries the risk of lowering its own ATK, bringing its respectable 2800 down to a paltry 2100, 1400, 700, or 0, depending how many counters it gets.

Problem 2: Burn is very rarely played in the [b]metagame[/b], meaning its effect will almost never be used.


[/quote]

I never played by meta standards and i will never do(I like my decks as non microwavable as possible if I were to enter a tourny so i can have fun and not worry about having to win right now. Better to enjoy a duel rather than finish it up all at once.)
It is understandable that this cards effect would be near to completly unusable against non-burn decks since it is considered anti-burn. I hardly known a card that I think is bad because to me every single card that konami makes has a purpose in a deck in there own right.

my2c
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='demonelfxx' timestamp='1307931674' post='5279155']
I never played by meta standards and i will never do(I like my decks as non microwavable as possible if I were to enter a tourny so i can have fun and not worry about having to win right now. Better to enjoy a duel rather than finish it up all at once.)
[/quote]
Just gonna say this now, but to most people here, having fun=winning.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='demonelfxx' timestamp='1307931674' post='5279155']
I never played by meta standards and i will never do(I like my decks as non microwavable as possible if I were to enter a tourny so i can have fun and not worry about having to win right now. Better to enjoy a duel rather than finish it up all at once.)
It is understandable that this cards effect would be near to completly unusable against non-burn decks since it is considered anti-burn. I hardly known a card that I think is bad because to me every single card that konami makes has a purpose in a deck in there own right.

my2c
[/quote]

And you're fully entitled to your opinions. I merely explained why the card is disliked: Burn isn't used much, this is an anti-burn card, and there are plenty of excellent substitutes that don't rely on you being attacked with Burn damage.

Most cards do have a purpose in a deck, but you also need to remember that some cards are strictly inferior to other possibilities, whether competitive or not.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='The blazing MARS' timestamp='1307903401' post='5277878'][img]http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20080831190733/yugioh/images/thumb/0/0a/RedDragonArchfiendCT05-EN-ScR-LE.png/300px-RedDragonArchfiendCT05-EN-ScR-LE.png[/img]
[img]http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20080904035447/yugioh/images/thumb/6/62/ThoughtRulerArchfiendTDGS-EN-UR-1E.png/300px-ThoughtRulerArchfiendTDGS-EN-UR-1E.png[/img][/quote]
lol
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...