Fearless or Earless?

[XrayPeregrine]

 

When an Elemental Hero you control is destroyed in battle, immediately Special Summon another Elemental Hero of any level from your deck or hand.

[Flash Flyer - Sakura]

This is essentially a better Hero Signal for lack of a better word.

Yeah, just no.

 

Granted, the strongest HERO you can play with this is Bladedge (or Neos), but there's a reason why Hero Signal has that Level 4 or lower restriction.

Summoning from the Deck is something that should be avoided, UNLESS there are sizable drawbacks to doing so.

 

Getting a free high-Level beatstick off a smaller HERO is not good design.

Yes, this requires an Elemental HERO to die, but you get the point.

 

 

Also, Quick-Play Traps don't exist.

Fix this.

[XrayPeregrine]

You are way too serious about this.  I'm not going to fix it, and your comments are so harsh and your restrictions are so tyrannical that a new person like me (a person who JUST saw this site today and has only heard of Yugioh cards one week ago) is inclined not to return to this site, at least the forums section.  I'm pretty sure the moderator's job is to enhance the experience here and create an open environment, especially in a forum labeled as "CASUAL."  Instead, you've turned my first couple of minutes on this forum as distasteful.  Power corrupts.

[Trebuchet MS]

If you took a moment to read the rules over what goes where...

[Flash Flyer - Sakura]

If he had taken a moment to read the section rules, he would've known that by posting content in Custom Cards; you agree to have your craft critiqued.

Additionally, he would've also known what's allowed here and what should be placed elsewhere.

 

If you don't read the rules, then it's no one's fault but your own if things happen.

 

----

 

That being said, my review was perfectly civil, and addressed everything that the Advanced Clause dictates that I need to do.

All I said is that his card is a stronger Hero Signal, and it is true.

 

Additionally, I told him to fix the Quick-Play Trap thing, because that doesn't exist.

 

If you want to see a harsher review, go look at one of Black's older ones.

 

---

Then again, if he doesn't want to fix it, then he has no one to blame but himself when other members start telling him the same thing.

Casual is a lighter area, but you still need to factor in proper balance in design.

 

 

And for the record, you are allowed to use Advanced level CnC in this section, if you deem it appropriate for the matter.