Jump to content

Pokevolution Contest *Become Part of History!*


J-Max

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 182
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Judging Results - SushiTheLegend's Judging

 

 

The Wolf

-Metagross: Name is too basic and not all that fancy, image is fairly decent and works well,

the OCG is not so good as it doesn't follow the Pokevolution evolution OCG. The card isn't

all that unique aside from the use of tributing a monster that's been on the field for

4 turns similar to Cacoon of Evolution. With that said, the effect itself is quite overpowering

when you consider the star level, ATK and DEF. Finally the usage does have a slight balance

but once it's on the field it'll be hard to remove.

 

-Flygon: Name again is too basic, image again is quite nice, the OCG yet again doesn't follow

our specific OCG. The uniqueness follows that of Metagross which isn't really all that unique.

The effect has little to no relevence to anything about Flygon or any of his moves. The usage

is pretty horrid as it is overpowering with little drawback.

 

-Dragon Fang: Name is somewhat kinda cool, image is a little weird and non-pokemon related, the

OCG seems to be fairly decent but still doesn't relate to our OCG because it isn't pokemon specific.

The uniqueness is pretty nice though as it's a good support toward any dragon types. The effect in terms

of that support makes it ideal and quite good for weaker monsters. The usage of the card works well

because there tend to be quite a deal of weak dragons that this can work with.

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 3/10

Card OCG 2/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 22/45

 

~TwIsTeD~

-Haunter: Name is kinda basic, image however actually seems kinda cool though, the OCG is a little off on the evolution

thing but for the most part it seems fairly good. The uniqueness to the card isn't much but it still pulls off a good

ghost like effect, the effect of course is quite splendid and really works well with Haunter, finally the usage seems quite

workable too.

 

-Smeargle: Name again is basic, image is a little ewww, the OCG is the same as with Haunter, the uniqueness is fairly okay

for the most part. The effect is again pretty okay but I don't quite understand it's relevance to Smeargle, lol. Finally

the usability seems to be pretty darn good.

 

-Ghostly Absorbtion: The name on this one is a little better, the image is just full of lulz, the OCG is very good this time

around and the uniqueness is quite good on this one as well and it really hits the name. The effect I am absolutely loving,

and finally the usability seems to work good.

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 26/45

 

Shradow

-Riolu & Trainer:

-Lucario & Trainer:

-Aura Storm:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 4/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 2/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 21/45

 

bradthecanivingfootlicker

-Buizel:

-Raichu:

-Evolution:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 2/10

Card OCG 2/5

Card Effect 2/10

Card Image 1/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 14/45

 

Choke

-Lugia Charge:

-Dark Lugia Charge:

-Revolution of Lugia:

-Squirtoise Torpedo:

-Aipom the Deceiving Monkey:

 

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 5/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 31/45

 

ohgodwhy!

-Entei:

-Scyther:

-Hyper Beam:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 28/45

 

sasukechidori58

-Origin Giratina:

-Shiny Mew, the Hidden Psychic:

-Roar of Titans:

 

Card Name 3/5

Card Uniqueness 8/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 31/45

 

X-31 Fighter

-Electabuzz - Savior of Thunder:

-Lapras - The Guardian of the Sea:

-Trainer Trap:

 

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 5/10

Card OCG 2/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 5/10

Total 24/45

 

Aximil

-Life-Long Feud:

-Seviper:

-Zangoose:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 6/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 26/45

 

BenTennyson

-Bulbasaur:

-Ivysaur:

-Venasaur:

-Razor Leaf:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 5/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 7/10

Total 27/45

 

Hunter

-Swinub:

-Piloswine:

-Mamoswine:

-Failed Attempt at Learning Surf:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 3.5/5

Card Effect 8/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 8/10

Total 31.5/45

 

Crystal Beast user J

-Deoxys, the Transforming Virus:

-Palkia, Silent Beast of Space:

-Target Practice:

 

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 3.5/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 4/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 31.5/45

 

Master Red

-Plusle:

-Minum:

-Helping Hand:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 4/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 2/5

Card Usage 8/10

Total 25/45

 

rodri666

-Rapidash:

-Breloom:

-Triple Finish:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 4/10

Card OCG 2/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 24/45

 

shanster211

-Feraligatr:

-Charizard:

-Pokeball:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 2/10

Card OCG 1/5

Card Effect 3/10

Card Image 2/5

Card Usage 3/10

Total 13/45

 

Lord_Charmander

-Unknown Squall:

-Substitute Shade:

-Moltres Shade - Diety of Fire:

 

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 6/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 6/10

Total 30/45

 

middletond

-Kabuto:

-Kabutops:

-Mysterious Fossil:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 7/10

Card OCG 3.5/5

Card Effect 8/10

Card Image 2/5

Card Usage 8/10

Total 30.5/45

 

null_ptr∮

-Suicune, Incarnation of Northern Wind:

-Dragonair:

-Unforeseen Waxing Crescent:

 

Card Name 4/5

Card Uniqueness 8/10

Card OCG 2/5

Card Effect 7/10

Card Image 5/5

Card Usage 4/10

Total 30/45

 

Griffinsusername™

-Seviper:

-Zangoose:

-An Unending Rivalry:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 5/10

Card OCG 4/5

Card Effect 5/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 7/10

Total 26/45

 

Whitey

-Tyranitar:

-Flygon:

-Flygon's Fury:

 

Card Name 2/5

Card Uniqueness 6/10

Card OCG 3/5

Card Effect 6/10

Card Image 3/5

Card Usage 7/10

Total 27/45

 

Sushi's 1st Place Vote: Crystal Beast user J, Hunter

Sushi's 2nd Place Vote: sasukechidori58, Choke

Sushi's 3rd Place Vote: middletond, null_ptr∮, Lord_Charmander

 

Since Jacoby's cards are no longer there he will not be judged. I will be adding the rest of the crit later, figured I may as well get the ratings up now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

238550j.jpg

During stand-by phase tribute this card to Special summon Croconaw. This card gains 100 attack pionts for every water monster on the feild excluding himself

 

238550e.jpg

During End phase in which this card has attacked your oppents life pionts directly tribute this card to Special summon Feraligator. This card gains 200 attack pionts for every water monster on the feild excluding himself

 

 

238550.jpg

This card cannot be special summoned or set expect by the effect of Croconaw. This card gains 400 attack pionts for every water monster on the feild excluding

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So it comes down to who i want to work with us to decide the Rankings? Yeah I can do that.

 

 

1st Place: Crystal Beast user J (Hunter would be more then welcome anyway)

2nd Place: sasukechidori58

3rd Place:Lord_Charmander

 

I will also be rewarding the Points to the other Top 3 People. Congrats guys.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I personally felt Hunter would of been the better choice considering I hardly see Crystal. Sasuke and Choke were fairly equal so either works for me, and for the last one...Null did do the epic win with images, but his OCG and usage were terrible as they were overpowered, middletond certainly had the best result of 3rd place by 0.5, but Charmander's were very interesting...so third place wise either middletond or Charmander, or we could go with whatever you want James.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...