Jump to content

Weak Monster Card Contest - Finished - LOCK~


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 137
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I'm sorry I've been having a LOT of things to do over the past week or so ((In real life)). I'll be posting the results soon. Sorry about the long delay. I hope I'll make it up to you guys some day.

 

Also I don't think I'll open another contest after this until I'm finished.


The results will be posted by June 10' date='

[/quote']

 

That was off. Any ways. Thank you everyone who entered. And thank you even more judges. Now everyone clap for our judges. *Claps* . Sorry for being so late (One Week Over) with results. Forgive me. Sorry if I seem mean-ish. Also good luck in the future and good luck contest winner!

 

[spoiler=RESULTS]

 

[spoiler=Mine [Dark-White-Dragon]

[spoiler=Pharaona]

8.jpg

 

Score: 68/100.

 

It seems a little Over Powered. Discard it to be able to Normal Summon 1 Level 8 monster.And then if that monster leaves the field this card is Special Summoned (Notice this monster is a Tuner), and gives your opponent 600 damage. It needs some kind of other restriction.

 

 

 

[spoiler=wolfman505]

148729.jpg

 

Score: 70/100

 

It has a nice effect. But it needs a cost Higher than 500. Alone this card isn’t as strong. But with a Strong card with it this card can help you do heavy damage.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Baragon]

305264x.jpg

 

Score: 82/100

 

An Overall actually nice card. It’s effects work nicely together. It’s not Over Powered. Nice stall card.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Mr. Ð]

88884.jpg

 

Score: 79/100

 

Another nice card. It is like a weaker version of “Needle Worm”. Your opponent gets to select their cards and it takes up 1 spot in your deck.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Anbu Leader]

001p001XA71.png

 

 

 

 

Score 71/10

 

An effect that could work. But effect 2 makes it just as bannable as Sinister Serpent. Mostly because it goes to field, serpent to hand, but this one has a VERY low cost. You could play this one turn, and unless your opponent uses a card effect to kill it, it returns, play another and same thing happens and you can easily play a level 7+.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Light Master XX]

Kiryun-ReaperofDeath-1.jpg

 

 

Score: 87/100

 

Not Over Powered. Only selecting monsters weaker than it to take. Also It can not be used for a Tribute summon, but it is a Tuner monster which gives your opponent a chance to Synchro Summon with it.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Thermatic]

LaylaOfTheSpring.jpg

 

 

Score: 69/100

 

This card is VERY confusing. It’s effect is very useless unless you have other cards in your deck that can allow you to attack it. But it can only be sent to the graveyard by a card effect. And if this card has no support. Your opponent will not bother with it and just have it using up 1 monster card space and summon. Sorry, if this contest gave you the ability to use cards to support it, it could have done better,

 

 

 

[spoiler=tommers2008]

88810.jpg

 

Score: 90/100

 

A very nice card! It’s not Over Powered. It can be destroyed by it’s own effect. 500 ATK decreased a turn. This card works very nicely.

 

 

 

[spoiler=TheShedinjA]

492161g.jpg

 

Score: 90/100

 

Wow. A Pokémon that is better in Yu-Gi-Oh than it is in Pokémon. Any ways it’s effect of needing to RFG a Nincada is a nice drawback. That and the targeted by a card effect destroys it, makes this card not Over Powered. And giving your opponent the damage works nicely. It could stall for a little bit of time, unless they target it with a card effect or attack it with a low ATK monster.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Rosuke]

537562g.jpg

 

Score: 72/100

 

Well use this card’s effect for your End Phase and you can place another one out and they can’t be destroyed except by a Trap Card or Monster Effect. You still take battle damage though. But it does give a little Pyro Support.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Psycholera]

521618g.jpg

 

Score: 84/100

 

Very interesting card. It’s nice to see Spirit Monsters used as well. It’s effect is very strong. As long as you have a little luck.

 

 

 

[spoiler=blackhawk29]

511631l.jpg

 

Score: 68/100

 

Easy to draw 5 cards with a little cost. It’s ATK and DEF are not present. But it would be a better card if it’s discard hand to draw 5 cards effect was weaker.

 

 

 

[spoiler=random dude 123]

Card Not Available

 

Score: 73/100

 

A very nice effect. With some ATK boosts this card could work very well.

 

[spoiler=usetheforcehan]

2hyi8o5.png

 

Score: 85/100

 

An Effect that could work well in a deck based around Nomral Monsters. It also can be RFG to gain a little more ATK.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Syafiq_uchiha91]

537993.jpg

 

Score: 67/100

 

Well it’s the Red Eyes Black Chick version of Kaibaman. I would use this over Kaibaman since it’s a Dragon-Type. But it’s not very Original.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Ralneox]

514324i.jpg

 

Score:69/100

 

It may be hard to get it to be drawn by your opponent. But once done they are dead. It does cost you a Normal Summon though. Also I think it just skips Main Phase 1. But if it does Main Phase 2 as well this card would be banned before it was released. Of course they could always Tribute it.

 

 

 

 

[spoiler=waterwhip]

426361e.jpg

 

Score:66/100

 

Oh my. If you have 3 Pokemon in your graveyard this is a 2000 ATK monster that can go under Gravity Bind. It seems a little powerful. Think of using this in a Pokemon deck near the End of the game.

 

 

 

[spoiler=D.A.L.]

519211.jpg

 

Score: 70/100

 

A card used to kill a deck based on Destroying cards. If your opponent is the only ones with face downs this card would mess up their field. Badly against Flip effects, even if those Flip effects don’t destroy cards.

 

 

 

[spoiler=J-Max]

48078.jpg

 

Score: 95/100

 

VERY Original Effect. It works great in a Spell Counter deck. Field Chibi decks would use it…if I knew what those decks were XD.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Holo]

391367w.jpg

 

Score: 86/100

 

A card that could help you get a card back from the graveyard to your deck. Nothing else really to say. Helpful it can be.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Stick Spells]

485943.jpg

 

Score: 73/100

 

A basic LP gaining card. It doesn’t give too much LP either.

 

 

 

[spoiler=ice drago10]

342869q.jpg

 

Score: 75/100

 

200 LP a turn. Pay 500 LP to destroy 1 Lv 4 or Lower DARK monster. I would have gone with pay 700 or 800 though. And on your turn you can suicide with this card to take an opponent’s strong monster and give them good damage while maybe tributing it at end turn. It’s a bit too good. With a little higher cost may have worked better.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Ultra Dark Magician / Shooting Star Dragon]

381651i.jpg

 

Score: 78/100

 

A card that would fall in the category: Stardust Dragons Only. 500 ATK and DEF boost, but only till the end is o.k.. If you have 2 other dragons it won’t die in battle. Easier to get the monsters you need.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Neobdragon]

86446892.png

 

Score: 65/100

 

It doesn’t make any sense. That’s all there is to it.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Skyson]

55839.jpg

 

Score: 78/100

 

A VERY good card. It’s Over Powered a bit by discarding 2 cards to summon 2 Dragon monster (one of them tuner) and an easy Trident Dragon. Normally I wouldn’t use Trident Dragon’s effect any ways.

 

 

 

[spoiler= Gibbom8dman8]

Card Not Available

 

Score: 50/100

 

Wow. Sorry but I just don’t like his card. Also Flavor text is for Normal Monsters Only.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Jacy]

Card Not Available

 

Score: 58/100

 

Sorry, but No effect, Low Stats, Improper Grammar for it’s name/Flavor Text. I feel like I’m being mean to everyone. Sorry.

 

 

 

[spoiler= Seattleite]

215341a.jpg

 

Score: 78/100

 

You can select a cad card for your opponent and good for you. Also it’s a tuner. Good for RFG decks.

 

 

 

[spoiler=kevin7653]

548630.jpg

 

Score: 64/100

 

Personally I prefer monsters with the same or more ATK that can ATK directly. You can use equips on those cards as well…it’s just easier to use them. If it had more ATK it would work better.

 

 

 

[spoiler=ChaosKnux]

69911.jpg

 

Score: 69/100

 

A card to support Samas Aran decks…if they were real. Of course no other monsters ATK or DEF end in 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, or 9. Always 0.

 

 

 

[spoiler=usernames44]

No Picture Available

 

Score: 56/100

 

Not a good card at all. Sorry, not trying to be mean. Of course it is used to summon a monster. But I’ve seen your chicken soup card…

 

 

 

 

[spoiler=Inferno I20]

Pharaona- 85.5/100

Card: Happy

Comments:

Too overpowered in my opinion. You can Tribute Summon a Level 8 monster with barely a drawback, well except for discarding Happy. Minor OCG errors

 

Wolfman505- 55.0/100

Card: Hornet

Comments:

Way overpowered. Normal Summoning it alone halves the ATK of all of your opponent's monsters. Plus 500 Life Points is too low a cost for a devastating effect like that.

 

Baragon- 88.0/100

Card: Soul in the Crossroads

Comments:

Pretty interesting effect. It makes a great staller that isn't overpowered like Spirit Reaper but does still retain that annoyance factor that he has. i can imagine some cards working around his second effect.

 

Mr.D- 87.0/100

Card: Ravage Plague

Comments:

a little overpowered. basically a needle worm, however it does seem somewhat balanced because you are limited to only one per deck.

 

Light Master XX- 91.0/100

Card: Kiryun-Reaper of Death

Comments:

dang...this is a very good effect. its like a weaker Lava Golem but quite strong. it seems balanced because you would need to have your opponent summon a monster with an ATK less than 1000. overall, quite a good card. if he changed the top portion of his effect so it says when he is summoned and there is a monster with 1000 less ATK then he can switch, my rating would be a bit higher

 

Thermatic- 80.0/100

Card: Layla of the Spring

Comments:

first off i got to say "HUH!?" holy cow, a ton of OCG errors. but i can barely understand it. alone by itself it seems useless to me but if it had support cards then it might be great. but as it stands i cannot understand it that well

 

Tommers2008- 93.5/100

Card: Cursed Voodoo Doll

Comments:

he seems pretty balanced too me, however i can see him locking the opponent down very quickly. still a very interesting effect though

 

TheShedinjA- 93.5/100

Card: Shedinja

Comments:

Great card. no OCG errors from my position. great effect that can be helpful in battle and it would be a great monster worth summoning.

 

Rosuke- 65.0/100

Card: Pokabu Little Starter of Flames

Comments:

a ton of OCG errors. its first effect just seems strange too me. other than that it is an ok and average card

 

Psycholera- 94.0/100

Card: Feline Phantasm

Comments:

Nice to see a Spirit monster. i rarely see those nowadays. its effect is rather interesting. its effect is a really gambling one. i like it :3

 

Blackhawk29- 75.0/100

Card: Malefic Crystal Beast-Ruby Carbuncle

Comments:

no ATK or DEF, some OCG errors. seems too overpowered to me. You can easily draw 5 new cards and only lose one if you only have 1 card in your hand when you special summoned it. an ok effect at most.

 

random dude 123- 65.0/100

Card: Flower of Ultimate Awesomeness

Comments:

weak card (understandable because of its level) and does not have a interesting effect (god that must be annoying to hear that same word over and over again...Thesaurus!!!)

 

mahandra g- 95.0/10

Card: Astronaut-Protector Robo

Comments:

very fantastic effect! god, i sound so gay...should have said interesting...fine intriguing effect... just one problem though. synchro is spelled wrong.

 

Note By Me: Too bad he is a Judge huh?

 

usetheforcehan- 90.0/100

Card: Ulara Ulara

Comments:

seems like an ok effect for a monster with that weak of a Level. nothing really bad.

 

Syafiq_uchiha91- 30.0/100

Card: Blue-Eyes W. Chick

Comments:

Not an original effect. Kaibaman has that same effect. not being harsh but its true.

 

Ralneox- 8.50/100

Card: Vonstrainecy

Comments:

at first it seems interesting but it then became too powerful. skipping the main phase? too overpowered.

 

Waterwhip- 70.0/100

Card: Mijumaru, the Sea Otter Pokemon

Comments:

generic effect, not very interesting

 

D.A.L- 80.0/100

Card: Luck Bringers: the torch bearer

Comments:

pretty cool effect. but too powerful. you can see every card on the field. maybe if it was lessened to like 2 cards or so, then it would be okay

 

J-Max- 95.0/100

Card: Field Chibi - Counter Sorceress

Comments:

very original effect. acts like a field card and would be a great support for cards that use Spell Counters. overall, great card.

 

Holo- 93.0/100

Card: The Faithful Messenger

Comments:

seems like a card that can help you at the right time. nothing else really wrong or overpowered about it.

 

Stick Spells- 80.0/100

Card: Healing Dragon Twins

Comments:

nothing really special about it. just Life Point gain.

 

ice drago10- 80.0/100

Card: Lights Fairy

Comments:

pretty ok effect. not great or bad, just ok....its effect seems a little too overpowered too me. it can destroy and control monsters with little costs.

 

Ultra Dark Magician- 84.0/100

Card: Star Dragon

Comments:

um, its ok? would be great for Stardust Dragon though. its second effect makes it quite resilient and playable. not overpowered

 

Neobdragon- 50.0/100

Card: Death's Pet

Comments:

makes no sense to me, very vague would be the correct term.

 

Skyson- 93.5/100

Card: Geomancer Ariane

Comments:

Very interesting card. quite powerful but useful at the same time. it may be overpowered because you can synchro summon fast, but whatever.

 

Gibbom8dman8- 10.0/100

Card: Fish Kipp

Comments:

*facepalm* i changed my score like 3 times i believe because this card is just terrible (hate being mean but its true.)

 

seattleite- 87.0/100

Card: Dark Realm Cat

Comments:

pretty good card in my opinion. it can help cards like D.D's and others. some minor OCG errors.

 

Kevin7653- 75.0/100

Cards: Unarmed Ninja

Comments:

pretty generic effect. i think there was another card like this but im not sure. its mediocre at most because there are other monsters that have the same ATK and has no real drawback. *cough*Jinzo #7*cough*

 

Chaos Knux- 50.0/100

Card: Zero Suit Samus

Comments:

um...weird...yes...let's go with weird. also DEF is weird. Not that great.

 

usernames44- 40.0/100

Card: Chicken Warrior

Comments:

no picture. OCG errors. fake type.

 

 

[spoiler=Mahandra g]

1. Pharaona =82/100

2. wolfman505 =70/10

3. Baragon =72/100

4. Mr. Ð =80/100

5. Light Master XX =80/100

6. ANBU_Leader =i dont see the card

7. Thermatic =81/100

8. tommers2008 =90/100

9. TheShedinjA =83/100

10.Rosuke =80/100

11. Psycholera =88/100

12. blackhawk29 =77/100

13. random dude 123=85/100

14. Ralneox =80/100

15. Syafiq_uchiha91 =73/100

16. usetheforcehan =85/100

17. D.A.L. =75/100

18. Waterwhip =76/100

19. sbatman505

20. J-Max =91/100

21. Holo =84/100

22. Stick Spells =82/100

23. ice drago10 =80/100

24. Ultra Dark Magician=85/100

25. Neobdragon =70/100

26. Skyson =89/100

27. Gibbom8dman8 =60/100

28. seattleite =80/100

29. kevin7653 =78/100

30. Die Predators =79/100

 

 

[spoiler=Parion555]

Okay here are my Top 3 Results for your Weak Monster Contest:

 

1 Place-Light Master XX 98/100:I see almost nothing wrong with his Card

2 Place-tommers2008 86/100 There a few Mistakes and it doesn't really seem that much original to me but everything else is fine.

3 Place-Skyson 84/100 He really came close to 2nd but i found Tommers Card to be a little better.

 

 

[spoiler=OVER ALL]

[spoiler= Scores (Based On Enetring]

1. Pharaona = 78.5/100

2. wolfman505 = 65/10

3. Baragon = 80.6/100

4. Mr. Ð = 82/100

5. Light Master XX = 89/100

6. ANBU_Leader = ???/100

7. Thermatic = 76.7/100

8. tommers2008 = 89.9/100

9. TheShedinjA = 88.8/100

10.Rosuke = 72.3/100

11. Psycholera = 88.7/100

12. blackhawk29 = 73.3/100

13. random dude 123= 74.3/100

14. Ralneox = 52.2/100

15. Syafiq_uchiha91 = 44.3/100

16. usetheforcehan = 86.7/100

17. D.A.L. = 75/100

18. Waterwhip = 70.7/100

19. sbatman505 =???/100

20. J-Max = 93.7/100

21. Holo = 87.7/100

22. Stick Spell = 78.3/100

23. ice drago10 = 78.3/100

24. Ultra Dark Magician / Shooting Star Dragon = 82.3/100

25. Neobdragon = 61.7/100

26. Skyson = 84.8/100

27. Gibbom8dman8 = 40/100

28. seattleite = 72.3/100

29. kevin7653 = 72.3/100

30. usernames55 = 59.5/100

31. ChaosKnux= 48/100

 

 

[spoiler=Scores Based on Places.]

0. J-Max = 93.7/100

1. tommers2008 = 89.9/100

2. Light Master XX = 89/100

3. TheShedinjA = 88.8/100

4. Psycholera = 88.7/100

5. Holo = 87.7/100

6. usetheforcehan = 86.7/100

7. Skyson = 84.8/100

8. Ultra Dark Magician / Shooting Star Dragon = 82.3/100

9. Mr. Ð = 82/100

10. Baragon = 80.6/100

11. Pharaona = 78.5/100

12. A TIE BETWEEN Stick Spell = 78.3/100 AND ice drago10 = 78.3/100

13. -

14. Thermatic = 76.7/100

15. D.A.L. = 75/100

16. random dude 123= 74.3/100

17. blackhawk29 = 73.3/100

18. A TIE BETWEEN seattleite = 72.3/100, kevin7653 = 72.3/100 AND Rosuke = 72.3/100

19. -

20. -

21. Waterwhip = 70.7/100

22. wolfman505 = 65/100

23. Neobdragon = 61.7/100

24. usernames55 = 59.5/100

25. Ralneox = 52.2/100

26. ChaosKnux= 48/100

27. Syafiq_uchiha91 = 44.3/100

28. Gibbom8dman8 = 40/100

 

 

WINNER: J-Max with 93.7 Points.

 

BUT, under the conditions that J-Max has been banned, the winner is now:

 

Tommers2008 with 89.9 Points!

 

Good Job and Sorry about the wait!

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...