Jump to content

Mimicat [Disc]


Recommended Posts

Yu-Gi-Oh! Duel Monsters effect

Doppelganger

Normal Spell Card

Select 1 card from either player's field or Graveyard. This card becomes treated as the selected card. If the selected card was a Spell or Trap, activate its effect. If it was a monster, this card is Special Summoned and copies the selected card's Attribute, Level, Type, ATK, DEF, and any effects it has.

 

Yu-Gi-Oh! GX effect

Mimicat

Normal Spell Card

Remove top 5 cards of your Deck from play. Add 1 card from your opponent's Graveyard to your hand.

 

Broken in both cases. Discuss

Link to comment
Share on other sites

These are only as broken as the cards your opponent has.

 

JD

 

DAD

 

Yamata No Orochi

 

Brionc

 

Yep.

 

These are main targets.

Exactly. This isn't broken' date=' those cards are.

[/quote']

 

So do the opposite of Konami logic?

 

Ban the cards that make a certain card broken?

 

Or follow Konami logic.

 

Ban the card is broken because of it's targets?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So do the opposite of Konami logic?

 

Ban the cards that make a certain card broken?

 

Or follow Konami logic.

 

Ban the card is broken because of it's targets?

Konami logic is horrible. 90% of the time it's as easy as just banning broken cards because their effect is just that ridiculous. DAD, JD, and Brionc (not sure about the other one since I can't find it) are all broken in their own right and should have been banned once they were made. With out targets like those these wouldn't be broken.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So do the opposite of Konami logic?

 

Ban the cards that make a certain card broken?

 

Or follow Konami logic.

 

Ban the card is broken because of it's targets?

Konami logic is horrible. 90% of the time it's as easy as just banning broken cards because their effect is just that ridiculous. DAD' date=' JD, and Brionc (not sure about the other one since I can't find it) are all broken in their own right and should have been banned once they were made. With out targets like those these wouldn't be broken.

[/quote']

 

You forget another thing that influences Konami logic.

 

Money.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So do the opposite of Konami logic?

 

Ban the cards that make a certain card broken?

 

Or follow Konami logic.

 

Ban the card is broken because of it's targets?

Konami logic is horrible. 90% of the time it's as easy as just banning broken cards because their effect is just that ridiculous. DAD' date=' JD, and Brionc (not sure about the other one since I can't find it) are all broken in their own right and should have been banned once they were made. With out targets like those these wouldn't be broken.

[/quote']

 

You forget another thing that influences Konami logic.

 

Money.

 

But who cares. It doesn't change that it's poor. And when calling a card "broken" or not it shouldn't even come into play.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So do the opposite of Konami logic?

 

Ban the cards that make a certain card broken?

 

Or follow Konami logic.

 

Ban the card is broken because of it's targets?

Konami logic is horrible. 90% of the time it's as easy as just banning broken cards because their effect is just that ridiculous. DAD' date=' JD, and Brionc (not sure about the other one since I can't find it) are all broken in their own right and should have been banned once they were made. With out targets like those these wouldn't be broken.

[/quote']

 

You forget another thing that influences Konami logic.

 

Money.

 

But who cares. It doesn't change that it's poor. And when calling a card "broken" or not it shouldn't even come into play.

 

For a mega corp. liek Konami.

 

They'll only ban it if it causes people to leave the game thus them losing money.

 

Only way to make them ban it is to make them.

 

Back then in the LS age, JD cost $300.

 

People complained and left.

 

They semi'd him after milking him for most of the money they could get out of him.

 

Same with Honest and the LS archetype.

 

Now their dead, near unusuable as there are stuff to funk them over more then ever.

 

And their cards that they need are semi'd or limited.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

in a spell counter deck' date=' could you rack up infinite counters by having this card copy another copy of itself?

[/quote']

 

Second one, no. Unless its a mirror match.

 

I don't know why we bother discussing these cards. It's not hard to validate that it's OP'ed and broke. Would be @0 if ever released.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Exactly. This isn't broken' date=' those cards are.

[/quote']

 

This is well thought actually, those make the card broken!

 

Which Ones

 

JD? - HOW WILL YOU SUMMON IT IF YOU DON'T RUN LSs

DAD? - Well this one will be easier to summon still....

 

ANY SYNCHRO? - They'll return to the Extra....your opponent's extra actually..........so

 

Which broken card is left for this card to become broken?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...