[Written] Cracked Pot of Greed

[Monarch King]

Normal Spell

 

 

Draw 2 cards, then your opponent chooses 1 card in your hand and you shuffle that card into your Deck.

[ChampionZero]

It's a good idea, in terms of editing the effect of of Pot of Greed. I personally wouldn't use it, but that's just me not wanting to give my opponent any options.

[dustdevil9]

Does your opponent randomly pick, or do they get to see your hand? That's not clear

[Tinkerer]

Does your opponent randomly pick, or do they get to see your hand? That's not clear

^ This. If it's random, it's basically a better Upstart, but if they get to see, it's slightly more fair. Still way too good, but more fair then a random snipe. Regardless of whether or not it's random, you still can set/Summon your good cards before using this. Either way, you end up with at least 1 new option and no net loss.

[(GigaDrillBreaker)]

^ This. If it's random, it's basically a better Upstart, but if they get to see, it's slightly more fair. Still way too good, but more fair then a random snipe. Regardless of whether or not it's random, you still can set/Summon your good cards before using this. Either way, you end up with at least 1 new option and no net loss.

If they choose, this is considerably worse than upstart, since it is replacing your best card with a random card.

 

If random, things are significantly different. It wouldn't necessarily be broken, but the risk-reward disparity is too high for my comfort.