Enough with Protection Koomy (Plane of Debiliation)

[Kanashimi]

Plane of Debiliation

Spell/Field

Card effects that make monsters (including themselves) become unaffected or un-targetable by card effects or attacks, or prevent them from being destroyed (by battle or card effect), are negated.

[Darj]

Hmm... I once came up with a simplified version of an effect that basically sums up what this card does. I'm dropping the text fix suggestion, in case you like it:

Card effects that make monsters (including themselves) become unaffected or un-targetable by card effects, or prevent them from being destroyed (by battle or card effect), are negated.

 

Fix aside, I don't think the card is too useful. It's a Field Spell that doesn't add advantage nor enables plays like other Field Spells do, and it just allows you break through monsters that the opponent may or may not play at all depending on the deck he/she is running. This leaves the card as a situational side-deck or meta call choice at best, but there surely should be better options to play as counters. It does come with the perk of being searchable by Terraforming and getting Field Spell support, though.

[Kanashimi]

Hmm... I once came up with a simplified version of an effect that basically sums up what this card does. I'm dropping the text fix suggestion, in case you like it:

Card effects that make monsters (including themselves) become unaffected or un-targetable by card effects, or prevent them from being destroyed (by battle or card effect), are negated.

 

Fix aside, I don't think the card is too useful. It's a Field Spell that doesn't add advantage nor enables plays like other Field Spells do, and it just allows you break through monsters that the opponent may or may not play at all depending on the deck he/she is running. This leaves the card as a situational side-deck or meta call choice at best, but there surely should be better options to play as counters. It does come with the perk of being searchable by Terraforming and getting Field Spell support, though.

Don't worry its just me being annoyed with protection recently. Also the wording hmm, youre missing the "cannot be targeted for attacks" but yea, your wording is much simpler and easier to understand, thx, i'll change it.

 

Yes it doesnt do much basically, BUT you see, Kozmo ships forcing us to use non-target non-pop*ing effect to kill them, same goes with chunnibyouish Chaos MAX! *ahem* (and lately i saw them a lot at ygopro). Yes its a side card deck at best, but who knows? Playing this card against Majespecter could be fun tho~

[Flash Flyer - Sakura]

You can still run over 'specters in battle, since their protection only extends to effect removal and their stats are low (though there's also the backrow to contend with, especially Sonics). I mean, you could probably neuter them further, but you already can kill them without needing to play this for the most part.

 

Can understand the point of running this against Kozmos, because the ships are a legitimate pain in the ass to remove and yeah, they are still common (although this is Casual, so shouldn't be talking about them too much here). To be fair, a lot of common bosses nowadays do have some form of immunity (Magnus and the like are pretty much immune to everything*); including stuff like Monarchs when March is up (this card should overrule the protection it grants); then again, it stops 81 from granting something protection. For Casual purposes, not too many Decks actually have monsters that can block removal; outside of that, the obvious things you want this to counter exist.

 

At best, it just makes certain monsters easier to remove if you can't already destroy them otherwise without having to play specific cards to get rid of them, but yeah it's basically sideboard material for now. I would think this can overrule cards that grant protection, and not necessarily inherently built into the monster itself.

 

When you say "their effects", you just mean the monster's inherent effects or any effect that'll grant immunity and the like, regardless if it's theirs or not? Would like to confirm this.

 

----

* except against its own Archetype

[Kanashimi]

When you say "their effects", you just mean the monster's inherent effects or any effect that'll grant immunity and the like, regardless if it's theirs or not? Would like to confirm this.

My wording only affects monsters with their own protection, cards such March of the Monarch or Mound of the Bound Creator wont work.

 

Because "ignoring their effects." refer to the first part of the sentence, the monsters, so its ignoring the monster's protection.

 

But Darj wording, affect universally, both monster's own protection or cards that grants protection, and i'll change into that.