Jump to content

Fake Banlist Discussion

BehindTheMask

Recommended Posts

BehindTheMask Newbie

BehindTheMask

Posted
Posted

Banned ? (unconfirmed)

 

Rescue Cat

Substitoad

Cold Wave

 

 

Limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

 

Caius the Shadow Monarch

Magician of Faith

Treeborn Frog

Infernity Launcher

Black Whirlwind

Dark Hole

Pot of Duality

Bottomless Trap Hole

 

Semi-limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

 

Foolish Burial

Pot of Avarice

Icarus Attack

Infernity Archfiend

Burial from a Different Dimension

Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier

Gladiator Beast War Chariot

Dark Grepher

 

Unlimited 3 (confirmed)

 

Ultimate Offering

United We Stand

Skill Drain

 

 

For the sake of discussion...what types of decks would you play, etc.

 

THIS LIST ISNT CONFIRMED FYI

 

I'd probably play Glads still. The deck lost 1 Samnite 1 Cat and/or 1 Chariot. Nothing we can't replace.

 

What deck would you run? Would you like this format?

 

Discuss.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
evilfusion Newbie

evilfusion

Posted
Posted

The bans look fine. Wish Launcher was there.

 

I saw Dark Hole limited and started laughing.

 

Pot of Duality Limited? I think not. It balances itself by only letting one be used a turn and preventing Special Summons. Limiting it is pointless unless something I'm not aware of broke it.

 

Magician of Faith limited is...interesting.

 

Semi-limiting Dark Grepher does not kill Infernity very well. Infernity Archfiend seems so predictable semi-ed and Launcher limited. It's just as I predicted.

 

But all in all, probably not real, and it doesn't hurt X-Sabers at all. I know the list is judged by OCG standards, but Konami should know that the TCG Sabers are broke beyond belief.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
DeathSDelano Newbie

DeathSDelano

Posted
Posted

Banned ? (unconfirmed)

Rescue Catok

Substitoadok

Cold Wavereally how this get on the fake

 

Limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

Caius the Shadow Monarchok

Magician of Faithwould not mind seeing this back

Treeborn Frogback to where it was XD

Infernity Launcheralmost there

Black Whirlwinddo good BWs use this that much

Dark HoleWTF how this get moved even on the fake list

Pot of Dualityon this get on the fake O.o

Bottomless Trap Holethis better not be on the real one

 

Semi-limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

Foolish Burialdon't see this moving back up to 2 on the real one

Pot of AvariceI guess even if it is a fake

Icarus AttackWow O.o really don't see this happening

Infernity Archfiendok

Burial from a Different Dimensionwho in there right mind would but this back at 2 O.o

Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrierok but i think mist wurm should also be here

Gladiator Beast War Chariotok

Dark Grepherif this is true i don't see it stopping much of nothing

Unlimited 3 (confirmed)

Ultimate OfferingThough not many use this still don't see this going up to 3

United We StandAre they trying to make people want to use lolequips if this was true

Skill Drainok

 

IF this was true i would just do an lolPTD deck runing 3 United We Stands n scapegoat

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Ririkun Newbie

Ririkun

Posted
Posted

pot of duality is broken. Almost every deck benefits from using one, even one that focuses on special summoning.

It makes Blackwings a scary force because they have this+cards for black feathers+allure of darkness, massive draw power.

It makes Stun very effective since they don't special summon often anyway. Also, it helps you greatly to draw cards that

you sided in. Limiting it would be a good idea...especially since it's so expensive -.- I don't want to see other ppl running 3 of these.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dr. Cakey Newbie

Dr. Cakey

Posted
Posted

Good Blackwings max Black Whirlwind.

 

Rescue Cat: Sure. Do it. I don't care anymore.

Substitoad: Because Ronintoadin isn't the broken one. But fine, at least it fixes the problem.

Cold Wave: Fine, I guess.

 

Caius the Shadow Monarch: Why?

Magician of Faith: Well...actually, I wanted to test this @1, so sure.

Treeborn Frog: Not that different from being @2.

Infernity Launcher: Yeah...um...just 1 fewer.

Black Whirlwind: Look, just ban it, okay? I can tell you guys want to.

Dark Hole: Huh?

Pot of Duality: I've never used it, so I can't comment.

Bottomless Trap Hole: No.

 

Foolish Burial: Should be @3.

Pot of Avarice: I usually only use 2, anyway. But really, there's no reason for this.

Icarus Attack: Who would use 3, anyway?

Infernity Archfiend: -.- You guys really don't know what you're doing, do you?

Burial from a Different Dimension: Fine, but do something about Vayu.

Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier: ITBL (In This Ban List): Mist Wurm does not exist. What's the point of it, really?

Gladiator Beast War Chariot: So, Semi-ing seems to be Konami's way of saying, "You're on notice, card." I mean, it doesn't mean much.

Dark Grepher: Nope, you guys have NO idea what you're doing at all.

 

Ultimate Offering: Good.

United We Stand: Er...

Skill Drain: Good.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Anbu-of-Sand Newbie

Anbu-of-Sand

Posted
Posted

/does what DeathSDelano did

[spoiler=/doesn't want to page stretch]

Banned ? (unconfirmed)

 

Rescue Cat Yes

Substitoad Yes

Cold Wave No

 

 

Limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

 

Caius the Shadow Monarch No?

Magician of Faith No?

Treeborn Frog Yes

Infernity Launcher Yes

Black Whirlwind Yes?

Dark Hole No

Pot of Duality No

Bottomless Trap Hole No?

 

Semi-limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

 

Foolish Burial Yes?

Pot of Avarice Yes?

Icarus Attack Yes?

Infernity Archfiend Yes

Burial from a Different Dimension No?

Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier Yes

Gladiator Beast War Chariot No?

Dark Grepher Yes?

 

Unlimited 3 (confirmed)

 

Ultimate Offering Yes?

United We Stand No

Skill Drain Yes

 

The No's(?)

Caius the Shadow Monarch - Not really sure, but probably most likely won't happen.

Cold Wave - Isn't ban worthy. Limited is it's place.

Magician of Faith - Interesting, but probably not.

Dark Hole - Still too OP'd. It's pretty much Raigeki if you don't have any monsters.

Pot of Duality - Sure it fits in almost any Deck, but the drawbacks IMO balance itself out.

Bottomless Trap Hole - Isn't Limited worthy IMO, but can happen.

Gladiator Beast War Chariot - Isn't Semi-Limited worthy IMO, but can happen.

United We Stand - Most likely won't happen, but it's possible.

Burial from a Different Dimension - Isn't Semi-Limited worthy IMO, but can happen.

 

 

With this, I'd still most likely run my Anti-Meta Deck xD Seeing if this ban list was real, only thing that would hurt it at most was Bottomless Trap Hole being Limited.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Flame Dragon Enthusiast

Flame Dragon

Posted
Posted

Banned ? (unconfirmed)

 

Rescue Cat Good

Substitoad Good

Cold Wave Why?

 

 

Limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

 

Caius the Shadow Monarch I can understand

Magician of Faith Good

Treeborn Frog Better

Infernity Launcher Better

Black Whirlwind Better

Dark Hole >_>

Pot of Duality Better

Bottomless Trap Hole No

 

Semi-limited 8 (working on sources/translations) Who cares

 

Foolish Burial

Pot of Avarice

Icarus Attack

Infernity Archfiend

Burial from a Different Dimension

Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier

Gladiator Beast War Chariot

Dark Grepher

 

Unlimited 3 (confirmed)

 

Ultimate Offering No

United We Stand No

Skill Drain Yes

Over all everything is moving towards the right direction. So it's not bad.

 

I'd keep using GB, BW, and Zombie.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Mr. Judgment Dragon Apprentice

Mr. Judgment Dragon

Posted
Posted

Banned ? (unconfirmed)

 

Rescue Cat Good

Substitoad Good

Cold Wave Meh

 

 

Limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

 

Caius the Shadow Monarch Why?

Magician of Faith Step in the right direction

Treeborn Frog Step in the right direction

Infernity Launcher Step in the right direction

Black Whirlwind Step in the right direction

Dark Hole What the f***?

Pot of Duality Meh

Bottomless Trap Hole Why?

 

Semi-limited 8 (working on sources/translations) lolSemi Limit

 

Foolish Burial Step in the right direction

Pot of Avarice No

Icarus Attack No

Infernity Archfiend What?

Burial from a Different Dimension Step in the right direction

Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier What?

Gladiator Beast War Chariot No

Dark Grepher No

 

Unlimited 3 (confirmed)

 

Ultimate Offering No

United We Stand No

Skill Drain Awesome

 

 

For the sake of discussion...what types of decks would you play, etc.

 

THIS LIST ISNT CONFIRMED FYI

 

I'd probably play Glads still. The deck lost 1 Samnite 1 Cat and/or 1 Chariot. Nothing we can't replace.

 

What deck would you run? Would you like this format?

 

Discuss.

 

Bans are good. Limits are stupid although some are a step in the right direction. Semi Limits are stupid but sadly a few of them are a step in the right direction and the Unlimits are bad for the most part but Skill Drain at 3 is good. This format would blow in general as with all lolKonami formats although it would be nice to see Infernities hurt and Frog FTK killed but Caius, Bottomless Trap Hole and Dark Hole at 1 are ridiculously absurd. The former 2 deserve to be at 3 and Dark Hole should stay banned.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
El-Rrey Newbie

El-Rrey

Posted
Posted

Banned ? (unconfirmed)

 

Rescue Cat We all knew it!

Substitoad Agree!

Cold Wave Do not agree.

 

 

Limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

 

Caius the Shadow Monarch Why not??

Magician of Faith Why not??

Treeborn Frog Ok!

Infernity Launcher Agree!

Black Whirlwind Agree.

Dark Hole lolkeeptrolling

Pot of Duality Meh!

Bottomless Trap Hole Explain please.

 

Semi-limited 8 (working on sources/translations)

 

Foolish Burial Why not??

Pot of Avarice Mostly played at 2 or 3!

Icarus Attack Mostly played at 2 or 3!

Infernity Archfiend I expected this one.

Burial from a Different Dimension Zombies fanboy??

Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier Why not?? Now OCG will spam it 4 times instead of 5!

Gladiator Beast War Chariot Isn't 2 the magic number??

Dark Grepher Do not agree!

 

Unlimited 3 (confirmed)

 

Ultimate Offering Meh.

United We Stand Why not??

Skill Drain Why not??

 

 

For the sake of discussion...what types of decks would you play, etc.

 

I'm thinking about playing Lightsworn B)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
evilfusion Newbie

evilfusion

Posted
Posted

Cold Wave is evil. It completely locks down S/Ts for two turns (your turn and opponent's). Not just ones on the field, but also stops activations and setting, leaving a player wide open for essentially 2 of your turns (the turn activated and the turn after it wore off, when they couldn't set the cards in hand). It is definitely banworthy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
-Griffin Newbie

-Griffin

Posted
Posted

People here do not think that COLD WAVE as in the most broken legal spell card does not warrant a ban. And the funny thing is that those arethe same people who think that the likes of Breaker should be banned.

 

Good. Now start playing the damned game and stop being such idiots.

 

I get that it needs a ban, but I'd personally give that title to B-Con.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...