Jump to content

Canadian's March 2012 Banlist Wishes


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 169
  • Created
  • Last Reply

[quote name='joex486' timestamp='1326579889' post='5764410']
I'm glad to see a few people advocating for more copies of the Blackwing cards. Quite seriously, would Blackwings be used again if you bumped Gale, Kalut, and Black Whirlwind to 2?
[/quote]

Black Whirlwind to 2 would probably be bad, but as things stand I don't see why we can't have Gale and Kalut back, especially with how cheap a BW main deck is.

Maybe it's just wishful thinking of me to hope that BWs become tier 1 again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Canadian' timestamp='1326581302' post='5764447']
Mind sharing why you think so?
[/quote]

Because Tour Guide doesn't break Sangan. Tour Guide breaks the Xyzs that it summons.

Sangan is still an overall good generic card that can support weaker decks and gives them the speed that they need. Banning it is far from sensible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Jord200' timestamp='1326577094' post='5764370']
Banned

Sangan
Future Fusion
Dandylion
[i]Legendary Six Samurai Shi En[/i]

Limited
Tsukiomi
Wind Up Zenmaighty
Master Hyperion

Semi
Grapha Dragon Lord of the Dark World
[i]Blackwing Gale the Whirlwind[/i]

At least thats what I'm hoping for. Signs point to BLS staying around for another format, and Konami probably won't touch Rabbit.
[/quote]

Gale would be nuts @2, Kalut isnt as broken and will give BW just the bump they need.
And why Shi En.. Sams are barely played as it is

BLS won't be banned, or the gold reprint in OCGlands would be pointless

Realisticly speaking:
Banned:
Sangan
Glow Up

Limited:
MST
Oppression
Earth
Rat

Semi
Hyperion
Rabbit
Grapha
Zenmaighty
Dragonfly
Hornet
Dandylion (is totally srs)

Unlimited
Monk
D-Draw, mabye. I have less faith in this one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Ctrl+Alt+Win' timestamp='1326584923' post='5764519']
Gale would be nuts @2, Kalut isnt as broken and will give BW just the bump they need.
And why Shi En.. Sams are barely played as it is

Banned:
Sangan
Glow Up

Limited:
MST
Oppression

Semi
Dandylion (is totally srs)

Unlimited
Monk
D-Draw, mabye. I have less faith in this one.
[/quote]

No. Just no.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Evil Tristan' timestamp='1326585068' post='5764523']
If you're gonna be realistic, at least be realistic.
[/quote]

ya ok

Dandylion bieng the only thing that would be crazy

And how do you not see sangan and oppression changing spots on the list?

Plants are meh w/o Glow-up

Monk is barely used

Mst is mst

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My idea is

Newly Forbidden
Dandylion

Newly Limited
Tsukuyomi
Wind-Up Carrier Zenmaity
Mystical Shine Ball
Inzektor Dragonfly
Lavalval Chain
Rescue Rabbit

Newly Semi-Limited (First 2 are impossible, and it's just my wish)
Reborn Tengu
Tour Guide
Kalut the Moon Shadow
Lumina, Lightsworn Summoner
Gale the Whirlwind

Newly Unlimited
Summoner Monk
Magical Stone Excavation
Destiny Draw

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Ctrl+Alt+Win' timestamp='1326585575' post='5764534']
ya ok

Dandylion bieng the only thing that would be crazy

And how do you not see sangan and oppression changing spots on the list?

Plants are meh w/o Glow-up

Monk is barely used

Mst is mst
[/quote]

Dandy going anywhere but banned is stupid.

Oppression is never coming back.

Glow-Up doesn't break Plants.

Monk is barely used because it's @2, @3 it's stupid.

MST @3 is incredibly healthy for the format.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='RAEGING DOGKING' timestamp='1326585649' post='5764539']
gale wouldnt be nuts at 2, its bad in every deck other than blackwings right now, who need a boost.
[/quote]

Hmm I guess so

I still want explinations on why glow-up, sangan and oppression would be bad.

EDIT: nvm

Glow up is what made the plant engine, no?

Alot of people b**** about how oppression is good for the game blahblah, and I see it coming back

Dandy for quickdraw, and plants wouldn't even be great without glow up after anyway.

Monk is bad @2 anyway? Why not put it to 3 so people can not use it more, leave it at 3 for those who do.

Mst.. Meh, that or another semi.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Ieyasu Tokugawa' timestamp='1326585937' post='5764542']
ITT: Stupid predictions.
[/quote]
Not predictions, wishes. Look at the topic title.

[quote name='Ctrl+Alt+Win' timestamp='1326585988' post='5764545']
I still want explinations on why glow-up, sangan and oppression would be bad.
[/quote]
Sangan is perfectly balanced, and Oppression is stupid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Relius Clover' timestamp='1326586143' post='5764553']
People, Zenmaity, not rat, not hunter.

Sangan and Glow-up don't need need a ban

Oppression @1 is a terrible idea

Why on earth would Sandy go to 2 or MST to 1?

(null)
[/quote]

Yeahhh... but sangan isn't healthy for the game, especially with TGU
Then what do you suppose would be good to kill plants? Dandy? Sure I guess

Don't take the opporession idea from me. I just say it because everyone is. Blahblah forget mst

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...