Jump to content

Poll: Anime or Manga Cards Allowed.

Catterjune

  

44 members have voted

  1. 1. Should they be allowed in the TCG section?

    • Sure thing Sparky.
      29
    • Nah, that's okay. TCG and OCG only please.
      10
    • Some other third option that I will explain in my post!
      5

Recommended Posts

Catterjune Newbie

Catterjune

Posted
Posted
Eh, it seems a bunch of people have been posting a bunch of manga or anime-only cards, and I want to have less posts to mod and less work to do. I'd post this in site suggestions, but I don't want a bunch of jerks who don't even visit this section to have a say in how it's moderated. So, toss the choice up to you kids.

Should anime and manga cards be allowed to be discussed in the TCG section?

Poll ends on, oh let's say, Monday, September 27th 2010

In the meantime, all current rules that still exist are still all in effect so keep that in mind and what not.

tl;dr version- Read the damn title.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Sleepy Mentor

Sleepy

Posted
Posted
People tend to discuss pointless cards like Shapesnatch once in a while. That said, I think its a good idea to allow anime/manga-only cards. Its merely something else to choose from while making discussions.

They would work sort of like, hypothetical cards.

I say experimenting with this would be good. Letting people discuss them (for a while), and see how things go.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Kaisu Newbie

Kaisu

Posted
Posted
[quote name='Manjoume Thunder' timestamp='1284876837' post='4639568']
Manga - No. When they are released they are way different that the version that appeared in the manga.
Anime - yes. But only if the card has been used recently and has a decent chance of being released.
[/quote]

This. Manga cards have weird OCG and are waay different from the TCG, while Anime is like the game we play, only without a banlist.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
-Griffin Newbie

-Griffin

Posted
Posted
[i]Anime is like the game we play, only without a banlist, and with the ability to manipulate the order - and even components of your Deck whenever you're in a tight spot - the magnitude of this ability depending entirely upon your plot relevance and if you're the hero, making risk assessment pretty much non-existent since nothing makes sense.[/i]

*Fixed
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Toffee. Newbie

Toffee.

Posted
Posted
[quote name='Manjoume Thunder' timestamp='1284876837' post='4639568']
Manga - No. When they are released they are way different that the version that appeared in the manga.
Anime - yes. But only if the card has been used recently and has a decent chance of being released.
[/quote]
Pretty much this.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Canadian Newbie

Canadian

Posted
Posted
Manga: You'll get sh** like this: http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Spellbook_Inside_the_Pot which is obviously gonna turn into an "OP'ed card is OP'ed" thread, so no for manga's.

Anime: Sure thing! [s]most[/s] Quite a few of the anime cards are discussed before they are released. Be it that some of them are "OP'ed card is OP'ed" or "Terrible, Next.", but it's still a more plausable form of discussion so sure why not. (As long as people aren't idiots about it).

Also, I said neither, because we should have just opened up an anime / manga / ect.. discussion thread if we wanted to discuss them. (Please don't end up making this a TCG [i]and[/i] OCG forum.)
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Catterjune Newbie

Catterjune

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I don't particularly see a difference between Manga and Anime cards, since they both have a limited chance of actually being released.

Would this be a fair revision?

If it's a (currently) Manga or Anime only card being discussed, have the term "Anime" or "Manga" somewhere in the title or subtitle?
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Manjoume Thunder Newbie

Manjoume Thunder

Posted
Posted
[quote]I don't particularly see a difference between Manga and Anime cards, since they both have a limited chance of actually being released.[/quote]

Manga cards do not make much sense and end up being completely different IRL.

e.g.
Manga Ocean had some battle enhancing effect that only worked under Umi. The IRL one recycles heroes.
Manga Startos ATKs directly when you half his ATK. The current one [s]is broke[/s] searches and destroys s/ts.
etc
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dr. Cakey Newbie

Dr. Cakey

Posted
Posted
[quote name='PikaPerson01' timestamp='1284909310' post='4640231']
I don't particularly see a difference between Manga and Anime cards, since they both have a limited chance of actually being released.

Would this be a fair revision?

If it's a (currently) Manga or Anime only card being discussed, have the term "Anime" or "Manga" somewhere in the title or subtitle?
[/quote]
[s]Support[/s]

I mean, yes, that sounds good.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Sleepy Mentor

Sleepy

Posted
Posted
[quote name='Manjoume Thunder' timestamp='1284913395' post='4640421']
Manga cards do not make much sense and end up being completely different IRL.

e.g.
Anime Ocean had some battle enhancing effect that worked under Umi. The IRL one recycles heroes.
Anime Startos ATKs directly when you half his ATK. The current one [s]is broke[/s] searches and destroys s/ts.
etc
[/quote]

I think you mean the other way around. Stratos and Ocean don't exist in the anime. They are manga only.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Catterjune Newbie

Catterjune

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I mostly don't wanna segregate anime from manga, but it does seem a good portion of people dislike anime and manga being under the same banner.

Also, should this thread be stickied? I mean, the main reason I didn't when it was first made was 'cause I never read the stickies and assume no one else does either so like... yeah.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...